Scan barcode
literallykalasin's review
3.0
This book was provided to me by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
I have to start with a full disclosure: I did not realise when I requested this book that it is in fact the second book in a series. I spend the first five chapters kind of confused about the constant rush of self-referential information that the main character kept foisting on me. It was vague enough to be annoying for me, a reader who hadn't the background information of the first book (but a strong familiarity with the original Arthurian canon), but probably not vague enough for someone who had read book one and probably found themselves telling Vivienne to shut it and get on with things already.
Vivienne is an interesting character, because she subverts female norms for this period. In the original story, your ladies came in essentially three categories: ladies, good and true, that need saving -- damsels in distress, if you will; your cheating whore of a wife who must get herself to a nunnery; and witches who may also be your sister, and may also be trying to entrap you and steal everything you love. You know, the usual female tropes. Viv is none of these things, rather a young noble woman with some intelligence who apprentices herself under Merlin and learns the skills of alchemists and magicians, making her own path in a man's world. When we meet her in this book, she is attempting to build an aeroship so she can pursue the Holy Grail. Currently, her brother and lover are both missing somewhere and she has been given the coordinates to Avalon where the Grail resides. She embarks on her own to find her missing loved ones and solve the mystery of the Grail in order to restore Camelot, which has been destroyed and its people scattered after the war with Morgan le Fay.
Oh, you're probably wondering about that “aeroship” part. Yeah, this is a steampunk rendition of Arthurian England. I am not used to seeing steampunk outside of the reimagined 1800s, so I found that a bit difficult to get used to. Also, most versions of Arthur and his court place him firmly in the darkest parts of the Middle Ages, or on that razor's edge of Rome's conquest and subsequent withdrawal from England. This version felt more firmly settled in the later parts of the Middle Ages, due chiefly to the flow of information and culture that seemed to exist between East and West, which didn't really exist for England at any point in the more traditional settings.
I can definitely see the appeal of this book: the world is richly imagined, and the writing flows. While some of Viv's choices can be tough to read, you can sympathise with her and she is admirable in not following the only other paths laid out for someone of her gender. For people that love myths and magic and airships, this will be the book for you.
I have to start with a full disclosure: I did not realise when I requested this book that it is in fact the second book in a series. I spend the first five chapters kind of confused about the constant rush of self-referential information that the main character kept foisting on me. It was vague enough to be annoying for me, a reader who hadn't the background information of the first book (but a strong familiarity with the original Arthurian canon), but probably not vague enough for someone who had read book one and probably found themselves telling Vivienne to shut it and get on with things already.
Vivienne is an interesting character, because she subverts female norms for this period. In the original story, your ladies came in essentially three categories: ladies, good and true, that need saving -- damsels in distress, if you will; your cheating whore of a wife who must get herself to a nunnery; and witches who may also be your sister, and may also be trying to entrap you and steal everything you love. You know, the usual female tropes. Viv is none of these things, rather a young noble woman with some intelligence who apprentices herself under Merlin and learns the skills of alchemists and magicians, making her own path in a man's world. When we meet her in this book, she is attempting to build an aeroship so she can pursue the Holy Grail. Currently, her brother and lover are both missing somewhere and she has been given the coordinates to Avalon where the Grail resides. She embarks on her own to find her missing loved ones and solve the mystery of the Grail in order to restore Camelot, which has been destroyed and its people scattered after the war with Morgan le Fay.
Oh, you're probably wondering about that “aeroship” part. Yeah, this is a steampunk rendition of Arthurian England. I am not used to seeing steampunk outside of the reimagined 1800s, so I found that a bit difficult to get used to. Also, most versions of Arthur and his court place him firmly in the darkest parts of the Middle Ages, or on that razor's edge of Rome's conquest and subsequent withdrawal from England. This version felt more firmly settled in the later parts of the Middle Ages, due chiefly to the flow of information and culture that seemed to exist between East and West, which didn't really exist for England at any point in the more traditional settings.
I can definitely see the appeal of this book: the world is richly imagined, and the writing flows. While some of Viv's choices can be tough to read, you can sympathise with her and she is admirable in not following the only other paths laid out for someone of her gender. For people that love myths and magic and airships, this will be the book for you.
hannahsophialin's review
5.0
I received this book for free from Publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
Compared to Camelot Burning, the sequel definitely surpassed most, if not all, of my expectations.
I found Avalon Rising to be a lot more enjoyable than its predecessor. There aren't as many technical terms this time around, as Vivienne seems to be more focused on the mission the Lady of the Lake left for her near the end of the first book and helping Camelot's remaining refugees rebuild after the war with Morgan Le Fay. Soon, Vivienne finds out that some of the knights, including her brother and Marcus, have been missing for several weeks on their quest to find the Holy Grail and Avalon. She also finds out that Jerusalem, where the alchemist Azur resides, is attacked by the Black Knight and his men. Wanting to offer her help, Vivienne decides to leave earlier than what the Lady of the Lake originally planned, finding out that in doing so, she may have placed Marcus's life in danger.
The second Metal & Lace novel is a lot more adventurous than the first one - Vivienne teams up with the castle blacksmith to find the missing knights, which is eventually intercepted by Merlin (who tends to be more of an obstacle this time around rather than actually helping Vivienne). They are then sent to free the Fisher King in the Perilous Lands, which actually results in several fantastic tests/trials for Vivienne to try and prove her worth to free the Fisher King and reveal the coordinates to Avalon. The trials that Vivienne goes through in Avalon Rising to find the knights and to reveal Avalon's coordinates almost felt like a female version of Percy Jackson in a medieval-esque world.
Vivienne also underwent a few changes as a character. She seems more temperamental, but is definitely extremely determined to accomplish what she wants to accomplish. A fantastic quality in a heroine, since Vivienne probably would have spent her time running away from pursuers who also want the coordinates to Avalon rather than doing something extremely interesting (like trying to resist using magic despite the pull).
Avalon Rising was a fantastic companion to Camelot Burning - I definitely look forward to reading the next book with the major cliffhanger Kathryn Rose leaves us with. Might I ask to review-nap this until the next book come out?
This review was originally posted on Bookwyrming Thoughts
Compared to Camelot Burning, the sequel definitely surpassed most, if not all, of my expectations.
I found Avalon Rising to be a lot more enjoyable than its predecessor. There aren't as many technical terms this time around, as Vivienne seems to be more focused on the mission the Lady of the Lake left for her near the end of the first book and helping Camelot's remaining refugees rebuild after the war with Morgan Le Fay. Soon, Vivienne finds out that some of the knights, including her brother and Marcus, have been missing for several weeks on their quest to find the Holy Grail and Avalon. She also finds out that Jerusalem, where the alchemist Azur resides, is attacked by the Black Knight and his men. Wanting to offer her help, Vivienne decides to leave earlier than what the Lady of the Lake originally planned, finding out that in doing so, she may have placed Marcus's life in danger.
The second Metal & Lace novel is a lot more adventurous than the first one - Vivienne teams up with the castle blacksmith to find the missing knights, which is eventually intercepted by Merlin (who tends to be more of an obstacle this time around rather than actually helping Vivienne). They are then sent to free the Fisher King in the Perilous Lands, which actually results in several fantastic tests/trials for Vivienne to try and prove her worth to free the Fisher King and reveal the coordinates to Avalon. The trials that Vivienne goes through in Avalon Rising to find the knights and to reveal Avalon's coordinates almost felt like a female version of Percy Jackson in a medieval-esque world.
Vivienne also underwent a few changes as a character. She seems more temperamental, but is definitely extremely determined to accomplish what she wants to accomplish. A fantastic quality in a heroine, since Vivienne probably would have spent her time running away from pursuers who also want the coordinates to Avalon rather than doing something extremely interesting (like trying to resist using magic despite the pull).
Avalon Rising was a fantastic companion to Camelot Burning - I definitely look forward to reading the next book with the major cliffhanger Kathryn Rose leaves us with. Might I ask to review-nap this until the next book come out?
This review was originally posted on Bookwyrming Thoughts
sarahamelias's review
5.0
Okay, what did I just read?! Incredibly good but so, so sad! I'm nearly crying as I write this. Very action packed.
More...