Scan barcode
crowandtome's review
4.0
I struggled to rate this book because I felt that, while it was accessible, accurate, and surprisingly funny, it was a bit advanced for a so-called "beginner's guide." This book expects you to have a fairly solid grasp of concepts like the plebiscite, feudalism, Enlightenment philosophy, and monetary policy, and at least a passing knowledge of figures such as Robespierre, Marie Antionette, and Napoleon. Various relevant dates were omitted, and there was no sense of geography in the book, nor were there helpful tools such as timelines, indices, or maps. I gave it as high of a rating as I did on the strength of the writing, which was engaging and easy to understand, and the research, which was smoothly organized and hung together well, but if they had broken down the topics for true beginners then it would have received 5 stars.
filipmagnus's review
5.0
Originally posted over at my blog, The Grimoire Reliquary. With an extra outtake you won't find below!
Has another event in European history affected the age we live in as much as the French Revolution? Hasn’t every political debate, every crisis of our time been directly shaped by blood spilled and lines drawn in the sand throughout the events that unfolded in those first months, years and decades following 1789? Left and right, republicans and traditionalists, radicals and radicals and a thousand more shades of radicals, each more extreme than the other, killing ripping each other to bloody bits, some for political expediency; others out of loyalty to egalitarian beliefs; yet others, like the members of the lower aristocracy and the bourgeois with whom the tide began, wished for more incremental reform — say, a liberal democracy! Little did they know the beast they were unleashing.
The French Revolution is a snake that eats its own tail, and this excellent introductory novel shows just how events pushed Paris ever deeper under the mud and blood of revolution. There’s plenty to enthrall and horrify — the lithany of beheadings, the crushing debt and superinflation France goes under as result of its financing America’s war for independence, the startling turn in fortunes for some of France’s best and worst.
I must sound slightly insane, proclaiming such events ‘enthralling.’ Oh, well.
As you might’ve guessed by the title, this novel covers more than just the first revolution – fixating on Napoleon’s exploits for a sizable chunk, it eventually goes past the 1850s, in fact, covering even the Paris commune in 1871.
Excellent illustrations by Tom Motley, both poignant and funny. Motley’s pen captures many of the paradoxes of different revolutionary idealogues, pierces through the hypocrisies of the time and challenges the reader to reevaluate certain events through a different angle entirely.
This is a great starting point that leaves a lot unsaid — and it’s up to you to find out which events to dig deeper about. Me, I think I’ll get better acquainted with Georges Danton, a lawyer and revolutionary plagued by scandals about the misappropriation of revolutionary funds. The Napoleonic era is also one I’m itching to start with, and there’s plenty I want to learn about the inner workings of the Paris Commune, short as that lasted. Soon, very soon!
Pre-Review Babble:
What a fantastic introduction to the French Revolution(s)! Full of interesting historical facts presented concisely, funny quotes by many of the main actors throughout the different revolutionary and counter-revolutionary regimes and satirical illustrations as drawn by Tom Motley, this introductory book on the 19th century history of France's bloodiest period was a treat to read.
I'll expand my thoughts on this next time I write my Mini-Reviews over at The Grimoire Reliquary.
Has another event in European history affected the age we live in as much as the French Revolution? Hasn’t every political debate, every crisis of our time been directly shaped by blood spilled and lines drawn in the sand throughout the events that unfolded in those first months, years and decades following 1789? Left and right, republicans and traditionalists, radicals and radicals and a thousand more shades of radicals, each more extreme than the other, killing ripping each other to bloody bits, some for political expediency; others out of loyalty to egalitarian beliefs; yet others, like the members of the lower aristocracy and the bourgeois with whom the tide began, wished for more incremental reform — say, a liberal democracy! Little did they know the beast they were unleashing.
The French Revolution is a snake that eats its own tail, and this excellent introductory novel shows just how events pushed Paris ever deeper under the mud and blood of revolution. There’s plenty to enthrall and horrify — the lithany of beheadings, the crushing debt and superinflation France goes under as result of its financing America’s war for independence, the startling turn in fortunes for some of France’s best and worst.
I must sound slightly insane, proclaiming such events ‘enthralling.’ Oh, well.
As you might’ve guessed by the title, this novel covers more than just the first revolution – fixating on Napoleon’s exploits for a sizable chunk, it eventually goes past the 1850s, in fact, covering even the Paris commune in 1871.
Excellent illustrations by Tom Motley, both poignant and funny. Motley’s pen captures many of the paradoxes of different revolutionary idealogues, pierces through the hypocrisies of the time and challenges the reader to reevaluate certain events through a different angle entirely.
This is a great starting point that leaves a lot unsaid — and it’s up to you to find out which events to dig deeper about. Me, I think I’ll get better acquainted with Georges Danton, a lawyer and revolutionary plagued by scandals about the misappropriation of revolutionary funds. The Napoleonic era is also one I’m itching to start with, and there’s plenty I want to learn about the inner workings of the Paris Commune, short as that lasted. Soon, very soon!
Pre-Review Babble:
What a fantastic introduction to the French Revolution(s)! Full of interesting historical facts presented concisely, funny quotes by many of the main actors throughout the different revolutionary and counter-revolutionary regimes and satirical illustrations as drawn by Tom Motley, this introductory book on the 19th century history of France's bloodiest period was a treat to read.
I'll expand my thoughts on this next time I write my Mini-Reviews over at The Grimoire Reliquary.