3.97 AVERAGE

adventurous challenging dark mysterious sad tense slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
dark mysterious tense slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

The story was well paced and a fascinating blur of various plots. Miéville is absolutely fantastic at conveying emotions and imagery. The mixing of fantasy and science fiction and steampunk was done ingeniously. My only complaint (and it is a mild one at that) is some of his vocabulary seemed a little forced, like he was trying to use as scarcely known words as he could even if they attenuated his descriptive imagery. But, really, I hardly noticed it. This is worth reading by anyone interested in either Science Fiction, Fantasy, or looking for something a little different.

This was a massive dnf. The writing was so detailed as to make reading laborious, the characters were universally unpleasant. Life is too short.
adventurous dark tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

When I first started reading this, I loved it. The story was intriguing, the characters were exotic and interesting, and the writing was enjoyable. Mieville's descriptions of the city were detailed and did an excellent job of conjuring up pictures in my head. After I got about 500 pages into it, however, something snapped, and I became desperate to finish this book so I could get rid of it. I thought about giving up multiple times, but after getting so far, I was loath to call it quits, so I forced myself to finish it, even though it made me miserable. The story didn't get any better or worse, but at some point, everything started to annoy me. The characters all sucked, and I realized I didn't give a damn about their fates, and I was sick to death of the writer endlessly comparing the city to feces, garbage, and oozing pustules. (Okay, buddy. The city is disgusting. I get it. Move the f*** on.) His need to describe things in endless metaphorical detail was exhausting, and made the book almost twice as long as it needed to be. When I closed this book for the last time, I actually let out a sob of relief. That's how glad I was to be done with it.

What always strikes me about the “steampunk” genre is the wealth of ideas that populate them. Perhaps it is simply an unfamiliarity on my part with the conventions of steampunk (and, truthfully, the more I read, the more the innovation and creativity in one book resemble the last), but in the case of Perdido Street Station, I found it distracting and a little irritating. There were any number of diverse storylines, and while they all connected to the story arc in some way or another, I found myself asking “why do I care?” Sometimes the plot was advanced by these interludes, but others were chapters full of stagnating exposition. Innovation and complex storylines are wonderful, but I felt like every time I turned the page I faced the possibility of having to make room in my head for a new set of rules for the universe of New Crobuzon.


The story itself was slow to grab me, though I was interested enough to finish it once I really got started reading it. There were points in the book, particularly in describing the city where Miéville’s prose isn’t so elegant as to almost be poetry, it is poetry. I found myself marveling at the cadence and texture of the language. I wanted to read it out loud, savor the feel and taste of it, knowing for certain that if it was beautiful in my head, it would be damned near ecstasy spoken aloud. And yet… And yet, this same symphony of words, this rich, writhing mass of description sometimes bogged down the story as much as it enhanced it.


Perdido Street Station left me with a curious mix of feelings and impressions. I wanted to know what happened at the end, though I did not always want to do the reading to get there. I did not love the conclusions drawn, though I can respect them. I marveled at the prose, though I think that it hindered the storytelling. I will probably never read this book again, though I might pick up a Miéville book in the future.

adventurous mysterious medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

wow this book is good. I've never been thrown headlong into a world so complete, with each image and species and reference point so utterly alien, yet entirely understandable and so, so incredibly vivid. Lovecraftian, Poe and Gaiman and Pratchett all mixed up and blended into something completely fresh and as captivating as a slake-moth... doesn't compare to Perdido Street Station. Its not my new favorite book but Miéville is most definitely a new writer I'll look for, snatching anything I see with his name on it. There's plenty of criticism for him, his style, etc but that's all vastly overshadowed by the brilliance in this book.

New Crobuzon is a city that is almost a state in its own right. The upper echelons are governed by a dictatorship, and the underclass are subject to the whims of the criminal elite. Miéville has created a city that you can almost smell when reading it. It has a feel of somewhere in the middle of the Victorian age and is dark, damp and imposing.

The tech in the book is steampunk, and is straightforward and uncomplicated, with basic pistols, clockwork devices, steam powered computers that use cards to programme them, but he has raised it to another level with the addition of elyctricity from simple batteries and magic.

But it is with the characters and people that inhabit this city state that he has made this so very different. There are regular humans with the regular count of legs and arms, Khepri with insect heads, cactacae who are green people with spikes like cactuses, the garuda, part bird part human and the vodyanoi, amphibians with human form, and the Remade who are those who have extra limbs or machines or other parts added.
And in this richly imagined, vivid, alien and yet slightly familiar landscape the plot is draped. Isaac has agreed to help a garuda who no longer has his wings, to be able to fly again. Whilst researching methods of flight of birds and other creatures he acquires a grub with fantastic colouring. It nearly dies, but when he discovers that it likes the new narcotic on the street, it starts to grow rapidly and changes into a cocoon and one night is gone. But this is no regular insect, this is a slake moth, a huge humanoid insect that feeds on fear, and the excretions make the new narcotic. It finds its four other companions and frees them, and shear terror descends on New Crobuzon as the victim count grows. And the authorities scrabble to find these creatures, the criminal want them back for the drugs and Issac seeks to destroy them too.

Miéville has taken the genres of Steampunk, gothic horror and fantasy, popped them in a blender and turned the dial to 11 with this book. The way that he describes the city and the inhabitants is full of detail and intensity. There are parts that are chilling too. The only reason that I didn’t give this five was I though that the plot was not so strong, but it is a solid 4.5

I couldn't put this book down and am sad that it is over. I am sad for two reasons: I enjoyed the milieu, and I hated final act. I don't know where the author was in his career in this book, but he overstepped himself toward that end, and the story frayed a bit. That doesn't mean that I am unhappy with the final disposition of the charaters, I think that fit the steam punkishness well; It was just not as well done as the rest. It is a bit of distopia, scifi, fantasy, steampunk, and political commentary rolled into one, and it worked well. I hope to discover there are more in the same universe.