Take a photo of a barcode or cover
3.55 AVERAGE
3.55 AVERAGE
A tale of two women from different eras. I enjoyed both Martha and Elizabeth's story though feel the pace was a little lost with the reveal of Elizabeth's 'secret'. Some great universal themes linked the two women (love, family, emigration) and it was interesting to see the perspectives of these change depending on the era it was set in. The setting of Arran was lovely and Elizabeth's world felt large and full of life.
Wow, what a nicely written treat! I just loved all the carefully interspersed stories and local details which only someone who loved the island would take the trouble to mention. I look forward to further novels and it just so nice to hear a clearly Scottish voice, with all the rhythms and nuances of the West Coast.
reflective
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
A surprisingly good read about the struggles of old age and mysteries of everyday life, set against the spectacular scenery of the Isle of Arran. If the vivid descriptions of this windswept island aren't enough, the characters will be sure to draw you in.
The narrative switches easily between Martha and Elizabeth, moving at a swift but steady pace through the story. I had figured out the big secret before its reveal, but don't necessarily see this as problematic - perhaps that is the way the author wanted the reader to interact with the book.
I read this while on a road trip and found it both light and easy to follow while still being intelligent and capturing my imagination.
The narrative switches easily between Martha and Elizabeth, moving at a swift but steady pace through the story. I had figured out the big secret before its reveal, but don't necessarily see this as problematic - perhaps that is the way the author wanted the reader to interact with the book.
I read this while on a road trip and found it both light and easy to follow while still being intelligent and capturing my imagination.
There is some great characterization here and some lovely writing. The two stories intertwine beautifully, But do we always have to have the unlikely romance? And isn't Elizabeth's secret a bit of a cliche? I'd really like to give 4.5. Just couldn't quite justify 5 stars.