Scan barcode
courtbooks's review
3.0
I liked this. Some of the essays were quite enlightening and helped me to broaden my view of the views and interpretations of The Hunger Games.
merelvh's review against another edition
3.0
*i received an e-arc from netgalley in exchange for an honost review*
I normally don't read books like this but i, surprisingly, did like these essays a lot.
If you are a big fan of the hungergames trilogy, like me, i think you would really like to read htis.
These essays made me think about this trilogy in a different way, and not only about this trilogy but about more young adult dystopian books i have read. I also love how deep these essays dig into the different subjects of the hungergames.
I know i will look at this trilogy with different eyes the next time i re-read these books.
Overall, I liked these essays. However, I did not agree with all of them, I have some different opinions about a few of the subjects. Sometimes it felt like the author's did not completely understand everything about the books, or maybe it is me who doesn't. But this fact made me feel a bit bored while reading these specific essays.
This is why i could not give it more than 3 stars. But the three stars it gets, are well deserved!
I normally don't read books like this but i, surprisingly, did like these essays a lot.
If you are a big fan of the hungergames trilogy, like me, i think you would really like to read htis.
These essays made me think about this trilogy in a different way, and not only about this trilogy but about more young adult dystopian books i have read. I also love how deep these essays dig into the different subjects of the hungergames.
I know i will look at this trilogy with different eyes the next time i re-read these books.
Overall, I liked these essays. However, I did not agree with all of them, I have some different opinions about a few of the subjects. Sometimes it felt like the author's did not completely understand everything about the books, or maybe it is me who doesn't. But this fact made me feel a bit bored while reading these specific essays.
This is why i could not give it more than 3 stars. But the three stars it gets, are well deserved!
blefen's review against another edition
4.0
3.5 rounded up
Many of the essays were wonderful but there were a few that i struggled to get through
Many of the essays were wonderful but there were a few that i struggled to get through
pghbekka's review
3.0
A bit uneven in terms of quality of essays. Highly recommend reading the first two essays though!
chaosqueen's review
5.0
This an unusual book to read for me, but a great one nonetheless. Some of the essays made me laugh out loud, but all of them were thought provoking and great discussion pieces. A great find for fans of The Hunger Games.
nerdygeekyfanboy's review against another edition
4.0
In Het meisje dat in vuur en vlam stond ga je dieper in op het verhaal van The Hunger Games. Zestien auteurs hebben papers geschreven over The Hunger Games. Vele aspecten van deze trilogie worden benoemd, zoals de personages, relaties, de samenleving, de corruptie, de oorlog, schoonheidsidealen, reality-tv, mentale stoornissen en nog veel meer. Elke schrijver heeft een bepaald onderwerp wat hij/zij nader toelicht.
Aangezien ik al een ruime collectie aan boeken over The Hunger Games heb, kon dit boek natuurlijk niet ontbreken. De flaptekst voorspelde dat je genoeg achtergrondinformatie te lezen krijgt over The Hunger Games.
Nou en of krijg je veel achtergrondinformatie! Dit boek bekijkt vele kanten van de trilogie van Suzanne Collins. Elke auteur heeft een unieke bijdrage geleverd aan dit boek en in elk hoofdstuk krijg je weer genoeg te weten over The Hunger Games.
Mijn verwachting was dat er eerst lovende recensies kwamen over de boeken zelf, en daarna de bevindingen van de auteur, wat hij/zij nog achter het verhaal zag. Maar ik had het aardig mis. De nadruk wordt niet gelegd op The Hunger Games zelf, maar meer op de diversiteit aan onderwerpen die The Hunger Games met zich mee brengt. Ik was verrast toen ik las over onderwerpen zoals verschillende posttraumatische stoornissen die de personages hebben opgelopen in de boeken door de Hongerspelen en de oorlog. De schrijver vertelt daarnaast nog uitgebreid hoe de hersenen werken en hoe die op heftige gebeurtenissen reageren. Hierdoor worden de personages niet alleen belicht, maar ook de wetenschap en de logica achter het verhaal.
Het gaat dus niet alleen om het verhaal of de personages, maar ook andere aspecten, zoals de maatschappij en hoe de tirannie van het Capitool uiteindelijk de bevolking tot een opstand zet. Er is zelfs een hoofdstuk waarin genetische manipulatie wordt beschreven en dat we nog maar even hoeven te wachten totdat de mens inderdaad in staat is om gemanipuleerde dieren zoals snatergaaien te maken.
Het meisje dat in vuur en vlam stond is een must voor diehard-fans van The Hunger Games die hun visie op deze boeken drastisch willen uitbreiden. Door dit boek te lezen kan je een grote indruk maken als mensen het over The Hunger Games hebben, aangezien je onwijs veel over de boeken komt te weten. Dankzij dit boek blijft Katniss Everdeen voor eeuwig in je hart!
http://nerdygeekyfanboy.blogspot.nl/2014/09/recensie-het-meisje-dat-in-vuur-en-vlam.html
Aangezien ik al een ruime collectie aan boeken over The Hunger Games heb, kon dit boek natuurlijk niet ontbreken. De flaptekst voorspelde dat je genoeg achtergrondinformatie te lezen krijgt over The Hunger Games.
Nou en of krijg je veel achtergrondinformatie! Dit boek bekijkt vele kanten van de trilogie van Suzanne Collins. Elke auteur heeft een unieke bijdrage geleverd aan dit boek en in elk hoofdstuk krijg je weer genoeg te weten over The Hunger Games.
Mijn verwachting was dat er eerst lovende recensies kwamen over de boeken zelf, en daarna de bevindingen van de auteur, wat hij/zij nog achter het verhaal zag. Maar ik had het aardig mis. De nadruk wordt niet gelegd op The Hunger Games zelf, maar meer op de diversiteit aan onderwerpen die The Hunger Games met zich mee brengt. Ik was verrast toen ik las over onderwerpen zoals verschillende posttraumatische stoornissen die de personages hebben opgelopen in de boeken door de Hongerspelen en de oorlog. De schrijver vertelt daarnaast nog uitgebreid hoe de hersenen werken en hoe die op heftige gebeurtenissen reageren. Hierdoor worden de personages niet alleen belicht, maar ook de wetenschap en de logica achter het verhaal.
Het gaat dus niet alleen om het verhaal of de personages, maar ook andere aspecten, zoals de maatschappij en hoe de tirannie van het Capitool uiteindelijk de bevolking tot een opstand zet. Er is zelfs een hoofdstuk waarin genetische manipulatie wordt beschreven en dat we nog maar even hoeven te wachten totdat de mens inderdaad in staat is om gemanipuleerde dieren zoals snatergaaien te maken.
Het meisje dat in vuur en vlam stond is een must voor diehard-fans van The Hunger Games die hun visie op deze boeken drastisch willen uitbreiden. Door dit boek te lezen kan je een grote indruk maken als mensen het over The Hunger Games hebben, aangezien je onwijs veel over de boeken komt te weten. Dankzij dit boek blijft Katniss Everdeen voor eeuwig in je hart!
http://nerdygeekyfanboy.blogspot.nl/2014/09/recensie-het-meisje-dat-in-vuur-en-vlam.html
lanikei's review
2.0
I've been on a kick of "Philosophy of...." books lately, or "critical analysis of pop fiction" books in this case. I read the Hunger Games recently and thought they were decent, and I suppose they have some interesting political parallels compared to books like, say, Twilight.
I enjoyed essays that addressed some of the real world parallels and encouraged critical thinking for readers that may have limited themselves to Team Peeta or Team Gale. But generally the analysis wasn't particularly stimulating, and I didn't feel like I got much more out of the essays than I did by reading the trilogy myself.
Apparently I spent a lot less time agonizing over who Katniss should end up with than many readers did, because the idea of a Team Anyone hadn't really occurred to me. But if this book gets readers thinking more critically about the books they read, then kudos.
I enjoyed essays that addressed some of the real world parallels and encouraged critical thinking for readers that may have limited themselves to Team Peeta or Team Gale. But generally the analysis wasn't particularly stimulating, and I didn't feel like I got much more out of the essays than I did by reading the trilogy myself.
Apparently I spent a lot less time agonizing over who Katniss should end up with than many readers did, because the idea of a Team Anyone hadn't really occurred to me. But if this book gets readers thinking more critically about the books they read, then kudos.
taschima's review
4.0
I reviewed this book on April 2011, when it was first brought into my attention. Recently though I received the new movie edition which includes 3 new essays that pretty much rocked my world. Here is my original review, along with the new paragraphs on the new content.
April, 2011:
These kinds of books are awesome, and specifically this one is amazing! The essays are so good! There are 13 essays (for 13 districts?) in total, some have to do with fashion, psychology, PSTD among the winners of The Hunger Games, Team Katniss, and so much more. Theres something for everybody.
When the people at Smart Pop contacted me about reviewing this one I was so psyched!!! Any fan of The Hunger Games would be. I first learned about Smart Pop when I bought their essays on A New Dawn, I was soo into Twilight and this book was a life saver. I read it before I got Breaking Dawn because it wasn't out yet. Anyways this book is as good as A New Dawn was, if not better (let me think about it... definitely better). The authors talk about various parts of The Hunger Games with such insight that it make you think "holly crap how did I not see it? Why wasn't this clear to me from the get go?"
After I reads this book I immediately picked up The Hunger Games and started re reading it. Cinna is by far one of my favorite characters in the book, before reading The Girl Who Was on Fire I didn't paid much attention to him, but after reading the essay on fashion I got to say that he is one of the bravest most creative characters ever. Also after re reading The Hunger Games (and reading an essay that talked about the love triangle thing in The Girl Who Was on Fire) is hard to see where anyone got the idea that Katniss could ever end up with Gale, Peeta is such a sweet heart and clearly the right choice. Oh and also, I'm Team Katniss, she is the best. You will understand if you read The Girl Who Was on Fire, it really is an eye opener. Not to say that that all the essays will appeal to just everybody, there was one heavily on the science part that didn't interest me at all, but for the most part is so good.
January 2012:
All that I have said above? Completely true. Nonetheless, I have to add a bit more due to the new essays that the Movie Edition brings.
The essays are written by Diana Peterfreud (author of the killer unicorn series Rampant), Brent Hartinger (author of Geography Club) and Jackson Pearce (author of Sisters Red, Sweetly and Purity).
The one written by Diana is about Game Theory, and how it applies to The Hunger Games. It is very informative and interesting that is for sure. Maybe if my teachers taught me about the Game Theory with Hunger Games examples I would have learned a bit more about it, or been more interested.
"Game Theory is not about games. It's about politics and psychology, war and strategy. For Katniss Everdeen, it is life and death, and in the end, everyone in Panem comes to learn that the only way to truly win the game is not to play at all."
Brent Hartinger's essay is basically on "does the Mockingjay book suck or not?". It is his personal belief that the book wasn't as good as the others, it is my personal belief that I loved it. So it was interesting reading the other side of the coin. Brent does a very fine job indeed. He not only puts forward why he beliefs the book sucked and where he thinks things could have been done better, but he also speaks up for the people who loved the book and gives various reasons on why he would understand why the book would be loved (something about cynicism in his essay struck a cord with me).
"...there are two sides to the question of whether or not the book sucks. But there's also a third point of view to be considered: that there is some truth to both arguments. That Mockingjay might be flawed in some respects, but it's a bold and challenging work of fiction in others, specially the ending."
Last but not least is Jackson Pearce's essay. Her essay has to do with Gale, surprisingly. It has to do with how Gale is the knight, or cowboy if you prefer the men with boots and hats, of the series. He is willing to do whatever is necessary for the greater good, even if it interferes with what he wants the most as an individual (in this case this would be Katniss' love). To some degree I would agree with Jackson. Gale was never going to end with Katniss, we all knew that deep inside. Why? Well, you will have to read the essay to figure that out.
"All this time, Gale has been fighting not just for Katniss' heart, but for her safety, to create a world in which she and everyone else can be happy. And he wins -only he can't live in that world with her, because she can't forgive him for what he has done, things she has deemed to be evil."
This book is as close to the Hunger Games inner workings as you are going to get. It's like getting together with your friends and discussing the Hunger Games in great detail- only your friends in this case are inside the pages. You will enjoy every single second of the conversation, and after it is finished you will ask for seconds. That's when you get up, go to your best friend, and put this book in their hands. Only then will they be able to understand this love we have deep inside for The Hunger Games and why we keep trying to keep the world alive even though the series as long ended.
Long live The Hunger Games.
April, 2011:
These kinds of books are awesome, and specifically this one is amazing! The essays are so good! There are 13 essays (for 13 districts?) in total, some have to do with fashion, psychology, PSTD among the winners of The Hunger Games, Team Katniss, and so much more. Theres something for everybody.
When the people at Smart Pop contacted me about reviewing this one I was so psyched!!! Any fan of The Hunger Games would be. I first learned about Smart Pop when I bought their essays on A New Dawn, I was soo into Twilight and this book was a life saver. I read it before I got Breaking Dawn because it wasn't out yet. Anyways this book is as good as A New Dawn was, if not better (let me think about it... definitely better). The authors talk about various parts of The Hunger Games with such insight that it make you think "holly crap how did I not see it? Why wasn't this clear to me from the get go?"
After I reads this book I immediately picked up The Hunger Games and started re reading it. Cinna is by far one of my favorite characters in the book, before reading The Girl Who Was on Fire I didn't paid much attention to him, but after reading the essay on fashion I got to say that he is one of the bravest most creative characters ever. Also after re reading The Hunger Games (and reading an essay that talked about the love triangle thing in The Girl Who Was on Fire) is hard to see where anyone got the idea that Katniss could ever end up with Gale, Peeta is such a sweet heart and clearly the right choice. Oh and also, I'm Team Katniss, she is the best. You will understand if you read The Girl Who Was on Fire, it really is an eye opener. Not to say that that all the essays will appeal to just everybody, there was one heavily on the science part that didn't interest me at all, but for the most part is so good.
January 2012:
All that I have said above? Completely true. Nonetheless, I have to add a bit more due to the new essays that the Movie Edition brings.
The essays are written by Diana Peterfreud (author of the killer unicorn series Rampant), Brent Hartinger (author of Geography Club) and Jackson Pearce (author of Sisters Red, Sweetly and Purity).
The one written by Diana is about Game Theory, and how it applies to The Hunger Games. It is very informative and interesting that is for sure. Maybe if my teachers taught me about the Game Theory with Hunger Games examples I would have learned a bit more about it, or been more interested.
"Game Theory is not about games. It's about politics and psychology, war and strategy. For Katniss Everdeen, it is life and death, and in the end, everyone in Panem comes to learn that the only way to truly win the game is not to play at all."
Brent Hartinger's essay is basically on "does the Mockingjay book suck or not?". It is his personal belief that the book wasn't as good as the others, it is my personal belief that I loved it. So it was interesting reading the other side of the coin. Brent does a very fine job indeed. He not only puts forward why he beliefs the book sucked and where he thinks things could have been done better, but he also speaks up for the people who loved the book and gives various reasons on why he would understand why the book would be loved (something about cynicism in his essay struck a cord with me).
"...there are two sides to the question of whether or not the book sucks. But there's also a third point of view to be considered: that there is some truth to both arguments. That Mockingjay might be flawed in some respects, but it's a bold and challenging work of fiction in others, specially the ending."
Last but not least is Jackson Pearce's essay. Her essay has to do with Gale, surprisingly. It has to do with how Gale is the knight, or cowboy if you prefer the men with boots and hats, of the series. He is willing to do whatever is necessary for the greater good, even if it interferes with what he wants the most as an individual (in this case this would be Katniss' love). To some degree I would agree with Jackson. Gale was never going to end with Katniss, we all knew that deep inside. Why? Well, you will have to read the essay to figure that out.
"All this time, Gale has been fighting not just for Katniss' heart, but for her safety, to create a world in which she and everyone else can be happy. And he wins -only he can't live in that world with her, because she can't forgive him for what he has done, things she has deemed to be evil."
This book is as close to the Hunger Games inner workings as you are going to get. It's like getting together with your friends and discussing the Hunger Games in great detail- only your friends in this case are inside the pages. You will enjoy every single second of the conversation, and after it is finished you will ask for seconds. That's when you get up, go to your best friend, and put this book in their hands. Only then will they be able to understand this love we have deep inside for The Hunger Games and why we keep trying to keep the world alive even though the series as long ended.
Long live The Hunger Games.
mugoika's review
3.0
I guess this is a nice anthology of essays for those who want to think about The Hunger Games a bit more in detail, but it is actually not that useful for someone who wants to write a paper. So, for my purposes it wasn't quite right, but it is still pleasant to read.
My favourite essays were Bent, Shattered, and Mended by Blythe Woolston and Hunger Game Theory by Diana Peterfreund.
My favourite essays were Bent, Shattered, and Mended by Blythe Woolston and Hunger Game Theory by Diana Peterfreund.