I hope you read this on the near future, I just don't have the interest in continuing to read it at the moment.
adventurous dark funny hopeful slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

loved this read. once you get used to the fanfiction vibe, it fades into the background and really allows you to enjoy the story. i LOVED this jack sparrow adventure—it fit perfectly into the existing canon. the characters were so lovable. the author did a great job of treating something so sensitive with great care and poignancy. if you’re a potc fan, this is 100% a must read

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
adventurous funny mysterious relaxing medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
adventurous emotional funny hopeful inspiring lighthearted mysterious medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

I LOVED this book!!!! From start to finish, it was wonderful! I loved how you knew it was the same Jack we all know and love, but he was not as mature and still had some lessons to learn.
adventurous dark emotional sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

DNF at about a third way in.

I had high expectations of this book, so it's rather disappointing that it just doesn't live up to them. I love the original PotC trilogy, and the idea of more backstory was very appealing. Unfortunately, I don't find the writing very good , and to be honest, I feel that every page I've read up until now barely contributes anything to the story. If this hadn't been so many pages, I probably would've finished it, but I'm not going to force myself through 650 pages of something I don't really like all that much.

I really enjoyed this book. It covered a lot of excellent fun backstory regarding Jack's relationship with Teague & the EITC, etc. There were a number of fun accounts regarding how certain objects in Jack's wardrobe or other possessions came to be his.

The only thing keeping this one from 5 stars for me is that I think Ms. Crispin both found and LOST Jack's personality and voice throughout the book. It would be tough to write for him, but I think there was a silliness and bravado that he was lacking at key moments, though she captured his "softer side" rather well in some more intimate moments.

Was hoping to find out what happened to some of her characters (Esmerelda) after the story ends and Jack's "official" PotC stories begin with the films... Would also have been nice to see some of the other Disney characters' introductions--Joshamee Gibbs in particular, since it seems like he and Jack go way back, but there was no mention of him in this prequel... Also would love to see how the crew of the Black Pearl came together once he convinced Barbossa to be his first mate (Marty, Pintel, Ragetti, etc) and how Jack became an official Pirate Lord... But perhaps these loose ends just leave Ms. Crispin a few stories she could tell in another book one day. Disney willing, I'd read it!

Jack Sparrow, as seen in this novel, is courteous, respectful, compassionate, loving and selfless. That is to say, he's completely unrecognizable from the movies.

Gone are most of Jack's flaws, like his greediness, cowardice, self-serving nature, childishness, or lack of hygiene. Sure, in the movies, Jack eventually does the right thing in the end. But in this book, there's no hint of a struggle; he's downright heroic from start to finish.

Much like the fourth and fifth films in the Pirates franchise, this book suffers the problem of centering the story on Jack. In my opinion, we the audience are best left not knowing Jack's intentions or thought process. As Will says of Jack's plans in the Curse of the Black Pearl, "This is either madness or brilliance." Therein lies the charm of Jack's escapades. As much as I would have preferred to have an original character, with Jack Sparrow as a scene-stealing secondary character, let's forgive this as a conceit of the novel.

This book is a prequel novel, with Jack serving as an EITC captain under Cutler Beckett. It's possible that this book was intended to show Jack's progression from a straight-laced officer to a cutthroat pirate. But that arc is completely undercut by the half of the book dedicated to flashbacks of Jack's childhood growing up as a pirate in Shipwreck Cove. He grew up a pirate, he'll be a pirate in the movies, so why keep this charade of an honest life?

There's little in the way of trickery, scheming, and backstabbing, which were core components of the POTC trilogy. Several times in this novel, the characters verbally announce their plans, they execute them, and nothing goes wrong. For example, they set out to free a captured prince enslaved in the Bahamas. They find him and free him. Nothing goes wrong, no one discovers them, no one chases them.
SpoilerThe one character who betrays Jack is so cartoonishly evil that it's not a surprise at all. Let's talk about the strange sequence of these events. Christophe, a French pirate, assaults a female barkeep in Shipwreck Cove and Jack and Esmeralda find out about it. Christophe is then arrested for murder and breaking the pirates' code. Barely a dozen pages later, Jack decides to free this guy, because he thinks he can't possibly be guilty. This guy?? The guy who you just learned assaulted someone?? Truly a baffling plot decision.


There are two female characters, Lady Esmeralda and Princess Amenirdis, who are hopelessly in love with Jack. While it's nice that both are competent women with unique skillsets, the romance is anything but interesting. They are never annoyed or frustrated with Jack (because he has no negative traits in this book). Both are completely content with sharing him as a lover and completely accept that Jack's love for the sea will keep him from settling down. I'm not asking for a love triangle, but, man, a little conflict in either relationship would be nice.

Some plotlines go nowhere: Cutler Beckett hires a spy aboard the Wicked Wench. He doesn't do anything, Jack learns about him, and he's never mentioned again. Several problems are resolved by magic: the Wicked Wench is about to be shot to pieces by an enemy ship, and
Spoiler Amenirdis blows up the enemy ship with magic. She also casts a convenient spell to make Jack's crew forget about her entire secret island.


On the positive side, this book is well-researched. I stuck around and learned a lot about ships and sailing. Crispin does a great job describing era-appropriate clothing and food.

If you love Pirates of the Caribbean and you're looking for more...I would look elsewhere. Maybe try Treasure Island or the Count of Monte Cristo. I'm going to check out On Stranger Tides, the Tim Powers book that the fourth movie was loosely based on.

Brilliant! Absolutely loved this book. I'll write a more detailed review at a later date, but I'd recommend it to anyone that liked the films, likes pirates, or adventure novels!