Reviews

The Best American Mystery Stories 2017 by Otto Penzler, John Sandford

bookhawk's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Anthologies of short stories seem inherently hit or miss and this one fits right there. There were several stories that really grabbed my interest led by William Kent Krueger and Craig Johnson stories along with Brendan Dubois, K. Magee, and C.J. Box. A solid 3 stars and recommended for those who wants change of pace.

firerosearien's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Flight, Dot Rat, The Man From Away were the standouts for me in this volume.

lorimichele's review

Go to review page

3.0

There’s a few great stories here, and some absolutely boring ones.

greg1984's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

Puncher's Choice by Doug Allen ***
The Master of Negwegon by Jim Allyn ***
The Human Variable by Dan Bevaqua **
Power Wagon by C.J. Box
Williamsville by Gerri Brightwell
Abandoned Places by S.L. Coney
Flight by Trina Corey ****
The Incident of 10 November by Jeffery Deaver
The Man from Away by Brendon DuBoius
GI Jack by Loren D. Estleman
Ike, Sharon, and Me by Peter Ferry ***
Lovers and Thieves by Charles John Harper
Land of the Blind by Craig Johnson
The Painted Smile by William Kent Krueger
Dot Rat by K. McGee
The Woman in the Window by Joyce Carol Oates
The Sweet Warm Earth by Steven Popkes
All Things Come Around by William Soldan
The Process Is a Process All Its Own by Peter Straub
Night Run by Wallace Stroby

lorijo's review

Go to review page

3.0

There’s a few great stories here, and some absolutely boring ones.

craigkingsman's review

Go to review page

3.0

A mystery needs to have an element of...mystery. A good WhoDoneIt is usually what you look for. Despite the title of this book, there are very few mysteries here. Only three of the twenty stories are actual mysteries. The others are crime stories, but not mysteries. I've downgraded my rating because of the false promises from the title.

spygrl1's review

Go to review page

3.0

This collections skews toward the hard-boiled, toward the masculine, but the two stories I liked most both have female protagonists:

In Trina Corey's Flight a woman with MS is the only one in her nursing home to realize that a killer is preying on residents.

In K. McGee's Dot Rat a widow who seems content with her quiet life finds a lonely, mistreated young boy hiding in her garden one night. Once her reluctance is worn away, she becomes a fierce protector.
More...