Scan barcode
kylahstaley's review against another edition
4.5
This is my favorite book from TBS series thus far! I can’t wait for Dark Mirror!
aimeesbookishlife's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
mallomar91's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
_carlanoguera's review against another edition
adventurous
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
aceinit's review against another edition
2.0
What an enormously frustrating read. Since it has been a few years since the last book, I marathoned the previous installments before diving into this one, and a very distinctive pattern emerged that made this book more tedious than enjoyable.
First off, nothing substantially new happens here. TMF takes the best bits of books 2 and 3, smooshes them together, and makes it happen in France:
⎈ Paige goes to a Sheol colony? Been there, done that.
⎈ Paige decides to infiltrate Scion? Sure, why not.
⎈ Paige finds out the Grey Market has broad-reaching hands among the Voyant leaders, and she is somehow the only one who can expose the corruption? Covered that already.
⎈ Paige makes an impulsive decision to put herself into extreme danger, only to have it all go wrong? I feel like I've read this before.
⎈ Paige is betrayed by people she trusts implicitly, despite not knowing them for very long? Yup.
⎈ Jaxon manipulates the hell out of Paige , and she lets him? Of course.
⎈ Paige grossly misreads a situation, causing a whole mess of problems. Check.
⎈ Warden somehow continues to think Paige is a Strong, Smart and Singularly Capable person despite all of this? Naturally.
Must frustratingly, Paige continues a very notable trend of making bad decisions due to her tendency to absolutely 100% trust everything everyone tells her (even people she knows are the bad guys), and take it at face value. She then goes immediately into reactionary mode and doesn't consult anyone about her next actions or give herself time to analyze the information, because she absolutely must act on it right away Or Else. This leads to her creating a clusterfuck of a situation that could have been avoided with some thought or outside consultations, and subsequently getting herself and her allies badly hurt in the process. She then has to spend the rest of the book unfucking her bad decisions.
She never pauses to question things until it is too late, and then realizes she has been an fool who misunderstood everything. Over and over again.
One such misunderstanding sets the stage for the next installment. Previously, on social media, Shannon had said that Paige's reaction her recent trauma makes her drastically misunderstand a situation in this book and, given how things end, it's pretty obvious what that situation is. And, yet again, if she had took thirty seconds to actually think, she would have realized what was up. All of the evidence was right in front of her.
After reading all four volumes back-to-back and noticing this very distinctive pattern, and her utter inability to learn from it, I have come to the conclusion that, for me at least, Paige is exhausting. Warden/Arcturus is an absolute Saint for putting up with her incessantly bad decisions. I, however, am not, and am honestly not sure if I will be continuing with what was once a unique and promising series.
First off, nothing substantially new happens here. TMF takes the best bits of books 2 and 3, smooshes them together, and makes it happen in France:
Spoiler
⎈ Paige goes to a Sheol colony? Been there, done that.
⎈ Paige decides to infiltrate Scion? Sure, why not.
⎈ Paige finds out the Grey Market has broad-reaching hands among the Voyant leaders, and she is somehow the only one who can expose the corruption? Covered that already.
⎈ Paige makes an impulsive decision to put herself into extreme danger, only to have it all go wrong? I feel like I've read this before.
⎈ Paige is betrayed by people she trusts implicitly, despite not knowing them for very long? Yup.
⎈ Jaxon manipulates the hell out of Paige , and she lets him? Of course.
⎈ Paige grossly misreads a situation, causing a whole mess of problems. Check.
⎈ Warden somehow continues to think Paige is a Strong, Smart and Singularly Capable person despite all of this? Naturally.
Must frustratingly, Paige continues a very notable trend of making bad decisions due to her tendency to absolutely 100% trust everything everyone tells her (even people she knows are the bad guys), and take it at face value. She then goes immediately into reactionary mode and doesn't consult anyone about her next actions or give herself time to analyze the information, because she absolutely must act on it right away Or Else. This leads to her creating a clusterfuck of a situation that could have been avoided with some thought or outside consultations, and subsequently getting herself and her allies badly hurt in the process. She then has to spend the rest of the book unfucking her bad decisions.
She never pauses to question things until it is too late, and then realizes she has been an fool who misunderstood everything. Over and over again.
One such misunderstanding sets the stage for the next installment. Previously, on social media, Shannon had said that Paige's reaction her recent trauma makes her drastically misunderstand a situation in this book and, given how things end, it's pretty obvious what that situation is. And, yet again, if she had took thirty seconds to actually think, she would have realized what was up. All of the evidence was right in front of her.
After reading all four volumes back-to-back and noticing this very distinctive pattern, and her utter inability to learn from it, I have come to the conclusion that, for me at least, Paige is exhausting. Warden/Arcturus is an absolute Saint for putting up with her incessantly bad decisions. I, however, am not, and am honestly not sure if I will be continuing with what was once a unique and promising series.
lenaoknihach's review against another edition
5.0
Fanoušci krajinochodkyně Paige se konečně dočkali pokračování Kostičasu. Když spadne maska je čtvrtý díl série a čtenáři na něj čekali pět let.
Po takové době si ne všichni pamatují osudy všech hrdinů, proto autorka na konec knihy kromě slovníku výrazů sepsala i důležité postavy a jejich příběhy. I když jsem předchozí díl četla nedávno, shrnutí o všech jsem velmi ocenila.
Paige jen o vlásek unikla smrti a s Arcturem teď prchají do Paříže. Ale ani ve Francii nejsou v bezpečí. A víc neprozradím, protože chci, abyste jasnovidce poznali sami. Jsou totiž skvělí!
Oblíbila jsem si příliš mnoho postav a už teď se těším na další jejich dobrodružství, ale doufám, že tuhle plánovanou sedmidílnou sérii nebudu dočítat v padesáti letech.
Kostičas se bezpochyby řadí mezi mé oblíbence z fantasy žánru a vám ho moc a moc doporučuji.
Po takové době si ne všichni pamatují osudy všech hrdinů, proto autorka na konec knihy kromě slovníku výrazů sepsala i důležité postavy a jejich příběhy. I když jsem předchozí díl četla nedávno, shrnutí o všech jsem velmi ocenila.
Paige jen o vlásek unikla smrti a s Arcturem teď prchají do Paříže. Ale ani ve Francii nejsou v bezpečí. A víc neprozradím, protože chci, abyste jasnovidce poznali sami. Jsou totiž skvělí!
Oblíbila jsem si příliš mnoho postav a už teď se těším na další jejich dobrodružství, ale doufám, že tuhle plánovanou sedmidílnou sérii nebudu dočítat v padesáti letech.
Kostičas se bezpochyby řadí mezi mé oblíbence z fantasy žánru a vám ho moc a moc doporučuji.
amykatereads's review against another edition
3.0
The biggest issue I had with this book was the amount of French with no translation. It was better than the previous ones (equal to The Bone Season) it ended on a Cliff hanger, so obviously I wanna know what happens next haha.
brookemaarie's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
robiok's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
1.75
I am unspeakably disappointed
Ms Shannon is writing this story like she is still a 19 years old first time author
I am begging Bloomsbury Pub to hire a fuckin editor and to have a shred of outline drawn for this clusterfuck of a seires
The plot is inconsistent and non-cohesive, the cast AFTER 4 NOVELS AND 2 NOVELLAS is not estabilished, the wolrdbuilding is sloppy and lacks any clear aesthetic or sense of identity
The foreshadowing is, i am afraid to say, pathetically naive…i saw the second dreamwalker coming immediately. And im SHIT at predictions
Ms Shannon wears her references as well as i did with mines at 16 writing fanfiction during class hours when i was bored. Operation albion? References to bears? Honestly why did u even bother to try and be subtle just say u r gonna use the arthurian legend to try and lend some sense of profundity to this mess cause there is nothing to guess here…its so superficially done its like it was written in NEON LIGHTS
Finally: i would like to immediately and decisively dispell any delusion any english speaker may have that their language be immune from the issues of the gender binary
English does not have a neutral title to refer to women either: yall use ms and mrs too, in reference to marriage state so take a chill pill.
The betrayal of Arcturus truly was the last drop, when i knew we could not save this mess: the whole series is a ONE TRICK PONY following the formula abduction-rescue attempt-betrayal
Honestly this series has been ongoing for a decade…its time someone starts to write it like that means anything.
Ms Shannon is writing this story like she is still a 19 years old first time author
I am begging Bloomsbury Pub to hire a fuckin editor and to have a shred of outline drawn for this clusterfuck of a seires
The plot is inconsistent and non-cohesive, the cast AFTER 4 NOVELS AND 2 NOVELLAS is not estabilished, the wolrdbuilding is sloppy and lacks any clear aesthetic or sense of identity
The foreshadowing is, i am afraid to say, pathetically naive…i saw the second dreamwalker coming immediately. And im SHIT at predictions
Ms Shannon wears her references as well as i did with mines at 16 writing fanfiction during class hours when i was bored. Operation albion? References to bears? Honestly why did u even bother to try and be subtle just say u r gonna use the arthurian legend to try and lend some sense of profundity to this mess cause there is nothing to guess here…its so superficially done its like it was written in NEON LIGHTS
Finally: i would like to immediately and decisively dispell any delusion any english speaker may have that their language be immune from the issues of the gender binary
English does not have a neutral title to refer to women either: yall use ms and mrs too, in reference to marriage state so take a chill pill.
The betrayal of Arcturus truly was the last drop, when i knew we could not save this mess: the whole series is a ONE TRICK PONY following the formula abduction-rescue attempt-betrayal
Honestly this series has been ongoing for a decade…its time someone starts to write it like that means anything.