Scan barcode
backupandround's review
challenging
dark
medium-paced
3.0
I did not hate this book. I'm not sure what it was that kept me reading, but I'm not in the habit of finishing books I'm not enjoying. So i enjoyed it to a degree, at least.
But it was also very frustrating. Many things seemed contrived, especially the "twist" which is made so much of at the beginning of the book. Subplots and strands of the story aren't really brought to a close at all. There's a lot of focus on class throughout one subplot, but that ultimately seems to be for nothing.
I also greatly dislike the narratorial voice. It's very distracting and pulls you out of story.
In the end, this is a book that has something about it that made me keep reading, but I couldn't say I precisely enjoyed it. I would not reread or likely read anything by this author again.
But it was also very frustrating. Many things seemed contrived, especially the "twist" which is made so much of at the beginning of the book. Subplots and strands of the story aren't really brought to a close at all. There's a lot of focus on class throughout one subplot, but that ultimately seems to be for nothing.
I also greatly dislike the narratorial voice. It's very distracting and pulls you out of story.
In the end, this is a book that has something about it that made me keep reading, but I couldn't say I precisely enjoyed it. I would not reread or likely read anything by this author again.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Pedophilia, Child abuse, Sexual assault, and Rape
Moderate: Religious bigotry, Mental illness, Gore, Death, and Cannibalism
Minor: Infidelity, Misogyny, and Vomit
There is one description of rape of a child by a Catholic priest. It is not very explicit, but does describe the whole act in an unflinching sort of way. There are descriptions of violence and desecration of corpses that, again, are not very explicit, but do not shy away from details either. I am sensitive to excessive gore and was able to read them without discomfort, but use your own discretion.sarahwithersblogs's review
3.0
Note: This book was received from the publisher in return for an honest review
Just after I started reading Scorn at the beginning of the week I included it in my WWW Wednesday post, I was a couple of chapters in and I said I thought the book would be a marmite book, people would either love it of they would hate it. Despite that statement I ended up smack bang in the middle, I didn’t love it, but I didn’t hate it either, I do still predict that this book will be hugely divisive.
So what is Scorn about? Aaron Gall is a physicist working in Geneva as part of the team working at the Large Hadron Collider, when there’s an accident and a small black hole opens up in the middle of his brain leading to the events of the book, which sees the murder of a number of people linked to the Catholic church.
The book deals with the very topical subject of abuse, sexual, physical and mental, of children by members of the Catholic Church, it’s a controversial topic, and it’s certainly dealt with in a quite controversial way! I understand things than happened to Aaron and others, both in fiction and reality, was terrible; and the part of me that studied Psychology at university has a very basic understanding of things that could happen as a result of damage to the amygdala occurs, but what happens in the book can be brutal, and graphic, it’s not a book for the fainthearted!
Things I liked – I liked the two police officers, Scrope and Lister, their banter amused me, both from wealthy families they served together in the military before being fast tracked into the police, and safe to say not the most liked by the rank and file of the force.
I also liked the random doodles throughout the book,I had a proof, so I’m assuming they remain in the finished edition. I liked the way they broke up the text slightly, it’s a big book!
I also liked the cryptic crossword clues – I have a friend who likes reading the answers to cryptic crosswords and then trying to figure out how you were supposed to get there from the clue, I’m not the biggest crossword puzzler but I did enjoy trying to figure them out!
For full disclosure I have to admit there were also aspects of the book I wasn’t keen on. Firstly throughout the book there are frequent sections where the author speaks directly to the reader. I know that there are people out there who won’t mind that in the slightest,and there are people who will love it. For me, I felt it pulled me out of the main story line each time it happened. In a similar manner there were quotes between each of the chapters, in some cases relatively substantial blocks of text, which while relevant to the overall themes again tended to pull me out of the story line.
Finally a number of real people appear in the book, including The Queen, Tony Blair and The Pope. I read a lot of crime fiction and thrillers and don’t consider myself squeamish, but having things happen to real people made parts of the book a little uncomfortable for me.
Would I Recommend?
I would very rarely tell anyone not to read a book, and I’m not here either. Yes I had some issues with it, but I also enjoyed some of the dark humour and I’m just one opinion in a very large world. As I said I think this book as the potential to be controversial, I’m sure some people will find it to be anti-catholic, but I would encourage anyone who is interested by premise of the book should pick it up and give it a go
Just after I started reading Scorn at the beginning of the week I included it in my WWW Wednesday post, I was a couple of chapters in and I said I thought the book would be a marmite book, people would either love it of they would hate it. Despite that statement I ended up smack bang in the middle, I didn’t love it, but I didn’t hate it either, I do still predict that this book will be hugely divisive.
So what is Scorn about? Aaron Gall is a physicist working in Geneva as part of the team working at the Large Hadron Collider, when there’s an accident and a small black hole opens up in the middle of his brain leading to the events of the book, which sees the murder of a number of people linked to the Catholic church.
The book deals with the very topical subject of abuse, sexual, physical and mental, of children by members of the Catholic Church, it’s a controversial topic, and it’s certainly dealt with in a quite controversial way! I understand things than happened to Aaron and others, both in fiction and reality, was terrible; and the part of me that studied Psychology at university has a very basic understanding of things that could happen as a result of damage to the amygdala occurs, but what happens in the book can be brutal, and graphic, it’s not a book for the fainthearted!
Things I liked – I liked the two police officers, Scrope and Lister, their banter amused me, both from wealthy families they served together in the military before being fast tracked into the police, and safe to say not the most liked by the rank and file of the force.
I also liked the random doodles throughout the book,I had a proof, so I’m assuming they remain in the finished edition. I liked the way they broke up the text slightly, it’s a big book!
I also liked the cryptic crossword clues – I have a friend who likes reading the answers to cryptic crosswords and then trying to figure out how you were supposed to get there from the clue, I’m not the biggest crossword puzzler but I did enjoy trying to figure them out!
For full disclosure I have to admit there were also aspects of the book I wasn’t keen on. Firstly throughout the book there are frequent sections where the author speaks directly to the reader. I know that there are people out there who won’t mind that in the slightest,and there are people who will love it. For me, I felt it pulled me out of the main story line each time it happened. In a similar manner there were quotes between each of the chapters, in some cases relatively substantial blocks of text, which while relevant to the overall themes again tended to pull me out of the story line.
Finally a number of real people appear in the book, including The Queen, Tony Blair and The Pope. I read a lot of crime fiction and thrillers and don’t consider myself squeamish, but having things happen to real people made parts of the book a little uncomfortable for me.
Would I Recommend?
I would very rarely tell anyone not to read a book, and I’m not here either. Yes I had some issues with it, but I also enjoyed some of the dark humour and I’m just one opinion in a very large world. As I said I think this book as the potential to be controversial, I’m sure some people will find it to be anti-catholic, but I would encourage anyone who is interested by premise of the book should pick it up and give it a go
More...