hneite's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Most stories in this book is very good.

kitaliae's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

I am disappointed to say this is maybe my least favorite collection out of all the ones I've read. I love the idea of immortality and all of the moral and ethical questions that come with it. All of the writers in here have the technical skill and it seems like the editing is just fine. And while I will indeed check out the author's other works, I'm unsure if I'll recommend this one right off the bat to anyone. I felt like the first half of the collection ended up harping on the same 1-2 themes which was almost frustrating to read. With how short this one is it would have been nice to have more variation - and I don't fault the writers on this one, I doubt they had any idea what everyone else was doing. So while the stories were well written I feel like it was just an oversaturation of the same ideas.
More...