Scan barcode
shorshewitch's review
adventurous
challenging
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.25
1) wish the spells were more impactful. The Hindi jarred it for me. Why Hindi? Even English would have done it good. Or the best would be invention of a new language altogether. Tantrism language. 2) The story building is very good. 3) Editing should have been tighter, some parts felt stretched. Some continuity issues like Chotu suddenly starts becoming an "it" from "she". No clue what happened to Lala. Those sorts. 4) the character building is good. And the description of all the species and races. The imagination is absolutely brilliant. The magic system is nice. 5) will I recommend it? - yep. Loads of content warnings though. Death of children, animals, plenty gore.
kalikabali's review
4.0
I was really looking forward to this book not the least because it starred a badass woman Tantric detective (or Tantrist) from Delhi. Cult, Magic (Black and White), Murders et al, this is a book that graphically depicts it all in a simple language and style. It took me some time to get into the rhythm and characters and all the stuff that was shooting out from all sides but once I did, I just couldn't put it down and stayed up until the wee hours of the morning to finish it. And even though the protagonist hates the f-word ("feminist"), this is totally a celebration of feminism. And no, the blood, gore and violence didn't bother me, so well did it sit in the story.
I can't wait to see what Anantya does next.
I can't wait to see what Anantya does next.
devinmelone's review
4.0
100 points to Shweta Taneja for the ingenuity of the story and the setting.
At a time when fantasy fiction in India is riddled with just re-writes of our Ramayana and Mahabharata, Shweta dares to create a new fantasy universe of her own. And sets it alongside the modern Delhi that we all know of, at once adding believability and intrigue to the premise. This is still a fantasy, mind you, it talks of a world filled with daevas, rakshasas, spirits, crazy animal mutants, and a lot of other supernatural beings (or "sups", as is the slang word for it is in the book). But there is talent is making us believe that such a world could exist, just like the magical world of Harry Potter, and the author achieves it splendidly here. Everything works in the boundaries that the book sets for itself, and nothing feels too silly or far-fetched.
I would love to read more of this new fantasy world!
And to say nothing about the protagonist Anantya who goes by the rather "flashy" surname Tantrist. But there's a reason for that too. I loved how well thought-out everything was. Anantya has a past, a dark one, yet it is not revelaed like a knowledge dump. Little hints are dropped along the way finally allowing us to piece things for ourselves. Anantya is a revolution in Indian fiction. She's a tantric, and is pretty unapologetic of everything she does. She has casual sex, smokes beedis, has a foul mouth and a dirty mind too. In which universe would you have imagined that someone like that would be the heroine in an Indian novel? But she's indeed the prime attraction of this book, you really take this journey along with her (the first-person narrative helping tremendously) and you really root for her. Her fearlessness is something I think will inspire a lot of young girls. Yet, I'm a bit unsure the allowed age group for this book, as things get pretty graphic at times - both violence and sex. Good thing the book has on the cover 'Mature Readers only'. And that's just not being mature in age, it requires a maturity in your outlook as well otherwise you would coin this book as plain blasphemy.
Some of the things that did not work for me are the numerous inspirations from Dan Brown books. It distracted me from the flow a bit. And the sudden change in the sidekick from Madhu to Shukra, I understand it had to be done to fulfill the story but maintaining a single sidekick would have enhanced my investment in him. And I thought that a lot of the end felt a bit anticlimactic, at a point I just know how it ended and not worry too much about what paved for the ending. But it was an exciting read nonetheless!
After a lot of time, I've started reading Indian fiction and I'm glad that people like Shweta are pushing the borders on contemporary literature with entirely new concepts such as these!
Highly recommended.
At a time when fantasy fiction in India is riddled with just re-writes of our Ramayana and Mahabharata, Shweta dares to create a new fantasy universe of her own. And sets it alongside the modern Delhi that we all know of, at once adding believability and intrigue to the premise. This is still a fantasy, mind you, it talks of a world filled with daevas, rakshasas, spirits, crazy animal mutants, and a lot of other supernatural beings (or "sups", as is the slang word for it is in the book). But there is talent is making us believe that such a world could exist, just like the magical world of Harry Potter, and the author achieves it splendidly here. Everything works in the boundaries that the book sets for itself, and nothing feels too silly or far-fetched.
I would love to read more of this new fantasy world!
And to say nothing about the protagonist Anantya who goes by the rather "flashy" surname Tantrist. But there's a reason for that too. I loved how well thought-out everything was. Anantya has a past, a dark one, yet it is not revelaed like a knowledge dump. Little hints are dropped along the way finally allowing us to piece things for ourselves. Anantya is a revolution in Indian fiction. She's a tantric, and is pretty unapologetic of everything she does. She has casual sex, smokes beedis, has a foul mouth and a dirty mind too. In which universe would you have imagined that someone like that would be the heroine in an Indian novel? But she's indeed the prime attraction of this book, you really take this journey along with her (the first-person narrative helping tremendously) and you really root for her. Her fearlessness is something I think will inspire a lot of young girls. Yet, I'm a bit unsure the allowed age group for this book, as things get pretty graphic at times - both violence and sex. Good thing the book has on the cover 'Mature Readers only'. And that's just not being mature in age, it requires a maturity in your outlook as well otherwise you would coin this book as plain blasphemy.
Some of the things that did not work for me are the numerous inspirations from Dan Brown books. It distracted me from the flow a bit. And the sudden change in the sidekick from Madhu to Shukra, I understand it had to be done to fulfill the story but maintaining a single sidekick would have enhanced my investment in him. And I thought that a lot of the end felt a bit anticlimactic, at a point I just know how it ended and not worry too much about what paved for the ending. But it was an exciting read nonetheless!
After a lot of time, I've started reading Indian fiction and I'm glad that people like Shweta are pushing the borders on contemporary literature with entirely new concepts such as these!
Highly recommended.
More...