Scan barcode
skycrane's review against another edition
5.0
I literally could not put this book down. I started it as soon as I finished the first one and read straight through till the end. My only complaint about Daughter of Mystery was that there wasn't enough of it, that it'd be nice to see more scenes developing some of the side characters. So I was delighted when The Mystic Marriage delivered on that.
There's a particular scene in this book, which is just lovely. Very dramatic and powerful: "This is my heart: it is what you see. I don’t know if it will come through the fire. But it’s yours, if you will have it." In general, I like how The Mystic Marriage has a different view of love, or tackles a different kind of love, than the first book. In Daughter of Mystery the love between Barbara and Margerit is miraculous. They were connected before their births, and divine providence saw them reunited as young women. In this book, love is something the characters work at, a project built slowly layer after layer, with setbacks and false starts that can only be overcome through patience and effort. I appreciate how the author ties the romance into the larger themes of the story.
There's a particular scene in this book, which is just lovely. Very dramatic and powerful: "This is my heart: it is what you see. I don’t know if it will come through the fire. But it’s yours, if you will have it." In general, I like how The Mystic Marriage has a different view of love, or tackles a different kind of love, than the first book. In Daughter of Mystery the love between Barbara and Margerit is miraculous. They were connected before their births, and divine providence saw them reunited as young women. In this book, love is something the characters work at, a project built slowly layer after layer, with setbacks and false starts that can only be overcome through patience and effort. I appreciate how the author ties the romance into the larger themes of the story.
eletricjb's review against another edition
4.0
This series is like if A Song of Ice and Fire were good. And gay. Actually gay. Please write as many words as frickin' GRR Martin, Ms. Jones.
druv's review against another edition
5.0
Like the first book, this book follows a set of protagonists whose point of view we get to follow. This book expands the cast and from the eyes of others we get to see other sides and weaknesses of the characters of the first book. Antuniet, the main character, was ill-served by events in the first installment, and her struggles gives a welcome perspective on the social structure in Alpennia.
Much like the first book, I thoroughly enjoyed this book, the characters are all very likeable despite their flaws and its a pleasure (though sometimes a heartwrenching pleasure) to follow their adventures. Also like the first book, I found the side characters somewhat underdeveloped. Through the point-of-view structure we go deep on several of the characters, but it feels like it would be helpful if more of the characters whose points of view we don't get would wear their hearts on their sleeves a bit more. The princesses you got a good insight to, but the others felt a bit soulless at times. Which is a pity, because there are some I'd really like to see more animated, such as Anna.
Looking forward to future sequels!
Much like the first book, I thoroughly enjoyed this book, the characters are all very likeable despite their flaws and its a pleasure (though sometimes a heartwrenching pleasure) to follow their adventures. Also like the first book, I found the side characters somewhat underdeveloped. Through the point-of-view structure we go deep on several of the characters, but it feels like it would be helpful if more of the characters whose points of view we don't get would wear their hearts on their sleeves a bit more. The princesses you got a good insight to, but the others felt a bit soulless at times. Which is a pity, because there are some I'd really like to see more animated, such as Anna.
Looking forward to future sequels!
storytimed's review against another edition
5.0
Didn't really buy Jeanne and Antuniet together that much, but the alchemy and ANNA who is a cutie pie and Jeanne's Lesbian Picnic makes me round up from 4.5 to a 5.
activehearts's review against another edition
4.0
Super satisfying follow-up to Daughter of Mystery. The plot unfolds slowly, but I love the characters and how their relationships progress. If you're into scholars, scientists, some court intrigue and f/f romance, do read Heather Rose Jone's Alpennia books. I'm happily awaiting for the next installment.
hildea's review
emotional
hopeful
lighthearted
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
hfnuala's review
adventurous
mysterious
relaxing
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
3.75
I didn't enjoy it as much as the first book but it was fun.
torkin's review against another edition
5.0
Thus is a lovely, creative fantasy novel set in well-realized alternate Europe, with a compelling f/f romance to boot. This book has a full cast of four interesting, dynamic women to lead it. The magic system is interesting, and the plot is too. Read it! Read the whole series; I certainly will.
jesshale's review against another edition
2.0
A less engaging read than book one. I kept going because I did want to find out what happened, but it left me wanting.
I think the major problem in this book is a lack of focus. I enjoyed seeing Margerit and Barbara again, and if the story had focussed on them and resolving the political intrigue, that might have worked.
I was also charmed by Jeanne - the social butterfly who is, perhaps, starting to age a tad (I think she's just over forty), and Antuniet, the proud young alchemist who opens herself to friendship, family and love. But, I felt some of this story was told not shown, their conflict not as well resolved as the one in Book 1, and it was overall done a disservice by not being the focus of its own book.
There were a lot of threads picked up but not put down, and I honestly couldn't tell if they were plot holes or being left for book three:
- the Arpik title that Barbara purchases
- Iuli's stories - there was one bit with a big deal made of her running out to give a forgotten one to Margerit who tucket it under a carriage seat, and I really thought it would be discovered and proven to reveal...something
- Efrederik's marriage - potential brides are mentioned a few times
- how Jeanne is going to regain her social capital
- why the Emperor of Austria thinks the de Boot book was his, and how Antuniet came to be pursued
- Tio's fate
- what is going to become of Anna
- Barbara's family, including her cousin and new armin
- Antuniet's place in the alchemist/scholar community, especially since she has developed a new method
Plus more that I can't remember because this was a VERY LONG book. A lot of these may be done in Book 3, but it didn't feel finished, if that makes sense - not like little seeds of plot I'm eager to see develop, but more like things that might be resolved if the author remembers.
Things were mentioned, felt important, then were resolved off the page. Overall just quite uneven, and a disappointment after how enthralling book one was.
I think the major problem in this book is a lack of focus. I enjoyed seeing Margerit and Barbara again, and if the story had focussed on them and resolving the political intrigue, that might have worked.
I was also charmed by Jeanne - the social butterfly who is, perhaps, starting to age a tad (I think she's just over forty), and Antuniet, the proud young alchemist who opens herself to friendship, family and love. But, I felt some of this story was told not shown, their conflict not as well resolved as the one in Book 1, and it was overall done a disservice by not being the focus of its own book.
There were a lot of threads picked up but not put down, and I honestly couldn't tell if they were plot holes or being left for book three:
- the Arpik title that Barbara purchases
- Iuli's stories - there was one bit with a big deal made of her running out to give a forgotten one to Margerit who tucket it under a carriage seat, and I really thought it would be discovered and proven to reveal...something
- Efrederik's marriage - potential brides are mentioned a few times
- how Jeanne is going to regain her social capital
- why the Emperor of Austria thinks the de Boot book was his, and how Antuniet came to be pursued
- Tio's fate
- what is going to become of Anna
- Barbara's family, including her cousin and new armin
- Antuniet's place in the alchemist/scholar community, especially since she has developed a new method
Plus more that I can't remember because this was a VERY LONG book. A lot of these may be done in Book 3, but it didn't feel finished, if that makes sense - not like little seeds of plot I'm eager to see develop, but more like things that might be resolved if the author remembers.
Things were mentioned, felt important, then were resolved off the page. Overall just quite uneven, and a disappointment after how enthralling book one was.