Scan barcode
jenniferbbookdragon's review against another edition
3.0
An overview of how Buffy Summers, Wonder Woman, Xena, and Hermione Granger can help you face personal challenges in your life. I would have liked it if the author had dug a little deeper (most chapters are about 3-5 pages) and focused less on trying to include the maximum number of female characters from video games, comics, movies, TV shows and books.
romancelibrarian's review against another edition
4.0
ARC provided by Edelweiss and the Publisher.
So I don't know on what planet I was on when I thought that this was going to be YA leaning self-help/personal growth book ... maybe it was the cover (because this cover would sell SO HARD to teenage girls - especially the fangirls and the cosplayers)? Maybe it was the use of the word "girls" in the title? Maybe it is because micro-biographies are having a moment in YA non-fiction and a book set up as a fan-girl index/guide to life would have CIRC'ed SO HARD? My expectations were dashed when I discovered that this was not YA at all.
Content-wise, this is really aimed at adult female readers (I'd put my use of "adult" here aged at College+ with interest leaning towards the older/oldest teen readers) who are clearly familiar with both the characters mentioned and their cannon. Towers does a pretty great job of explaining why the character was selected for inclusion in the book but general character/cannon knowledge is still kind of needed to understand the gravity of all of it.
I also think that the title may be a little misleading. This book has a heavy mental illness/psychology lean which makes it more of an "acknowledgement of the importance of self-care" book than anything else. Each character is diagnosed with something and then the meaning of that diagnosis to their character arc/storylines are discussed followed by discussions about how each character deals with their mental illness within cannon and/or therapy. From a library/circulation perspective, I think Geek Girls Don't Cry: Lessons about Mental Illness and Self Care from Fictional Female Characters, may have overall served this title better.
While this was a short read that was overall interesting and well researched, I am afraid that it won't find a readership at the library because it appears to be one type of title masquerading as another. The older reader might pass it by because it appears to be "young" and the younger reader might pick it up due to interest and find that the content may be aged above them. I obviously really wanted this to be a YA-NF #missedopportunity
So I don't know on what planet I was on when I thought that this was going to be YA leaning self-help/personal growth book ... maybe it was the cover (because this cover would sell SO HARD to teenage girls - especially the fangirls and the cosplayers)? Maybe it was the use of the word "girls" in the title? Maybe it is because micro-biographies are having a moment in YA non-fiction and a book set up as a fan-girl index/guide to life would have CIRC'ed SO HARD? My expectations were dashed when I discovered that this was not YA at all.
Spoiler
Content-wise, this is really aimed at adult female readers (I'd put my use of "adult" here aged at College+ with interest leaning towards the older/oldest teen readers) who are clearly familiar with both the characters mentioned and their cannon. Towers does a pretty great job of explaining why the character was selected for inclusion in the book but general character/cannon knowledge is still kind of needed to understand the gravity of all of it.
I also think that the title may be a little misleading. This book has a heavy mental illness/psychology lean which makes it more of an "acknowledgement of the importance of self-care" book than anything else. Each character is diagnosed with something and then the meaning of that diagnosis to their character arc/storylines are discussed followed by discussions about how each character deals with their mental illness within cannon and/or therapy. From a library/circulation perspective, I think Geek Girls Don't Cry: Lessons about Mental Illness and Self Care from Fictional Female Characters, may have overall served this title better.
While this was a short read that was overall interesting and well researched, I am afraid that it won't find a readership at the library because it appears to be one type of title masquerading as another. The older reader might pass it by because it appears to be "young" and the younger reader might pick it up due to interest and find that the content may be aged above them. I obviously really wanted this to be a YA-NF #missedopportunity
thatgaydm's review against another edition
3.0
I thought it was interesting, a little too Girl Boss for me. I thought there was certainly some really great parts of it, but overall I thought the book was lacking in some other actual lessons to be learned and finding inspiration. I think that this is really great for some people, but maybe not others. I also felt like there were moments that could have brought up sexism in the geek community in a better way. The book felt like it was for a very specific type of Geek Girl, mostly white and mostly straight, and I just didn't really relate to that part of geekdom.
izze5's review
3.0
Interesting psychology behind each character, a good book if you need a super heroine boost.
theyasmindiaries's review
4.0
Not a person that is really into comics/superheroes but the mental health information was super interesting, and having that information connected to a superhero brought in a new perspective.
More...