Scan barcode
shannny2k's review
5.0
Just finished 'Red Runner v The Surgeon', absolutely phenomenal.
Those Who Watch From on High by Eric J. Guignard stayed with me for weeks.
The rest were good, those were outstanding.
Those Who Watch From on High by Eric J. Guignard stayed with me for weeks.
The rest were good, those were outstanding.
evavroslin's review
5.0
*** Review copy purchased online ***
--- Truncated review ---
I've been wanting to read Chiral Mad 3 ever since I heard it was coming out. Having been thoroughly impressed by the stories in the previous volumes, and seeing the all-star lineup unveiled bit by bit before the book's release made me eager to get my mitts on a copy. This anthology features a mixture of short stories and poetry as well as artwork. Now, I will say right off the bat that I didn't review the poetry in this anthology, not because I didn't think it was excellent (it was). The quality was, unsurprisingly, sublime, but I've never felt comfortable reviewing poetry. However, what I will say is that the placement of the poems functioned as a unique complement to each of the stories. As well, the artwork deserves high commendation because it truly enhanced the quality of each of the pieces.
To say that this is anthology has been put together well would not do it justice. The fact that editor Michael Bailey manages to pack so much immense quality and talent in all of his endeavours is truly astounding. If you're a horror fan, you must make his anthologies a part of your library.
--- Truncated review ---
I've been wanting to read Chiral Mad 3 ever since I heard it was coming out. Having been thoroughly impressed by the stories in the previous volumes, and seeing the all-star lineup unveiled bit by bit before the book's release made me eager to get my mitts on a copy. This anthology features a mixture of short stories and poetry as well as artwork. Now, I will say right off the bat that I didn't review the poetry in this anthology, not because I didn't think it was excellent (it was). The quality was, unsurprisingly, sublime, but I've never felt comfortable reviewing poetry. However, what I will say is that the placement of the poems functioned as a unique complement to each of the stories. As well, the artwork deserves high commendation because it truly enhanced the quality of each of the pieces.
To say that this is anthology has been put together well would not do it justice. The fact that editor Michael Bailey manages to pack so much immense quality and talent in all of his endeavours is truly astounding. If you're a horror fan, you must make his anthologies a part of your library.
lilyn_g's review
4.0
Chiral Mad 3 was an interesting book. I’d never read an anthology which put poems side by side with stories, and peppered the pages with illustrations too. Visually, it was a nice change, and I’d say it looks much better on paper than it did as an e-book. It’s fairly easy to get through, and didn’t give me the ‘tedious read’ experience that I’m generally afraid of when it comes to anthologies. The illustrations were great. Probably one of my favorite parts of the book, and some of the stories were just awesome.
I expected to be creeped out or greatly unsettled. That, unfortunately, rarely happened. So, I had to sit back from the book for a bit, and readjust how I looked at it. I took the overall tone from the first several stories and poems and adjusted my expectation. That worked, because the stories contained within are great – they just weren’t what I was expecting. My enjoyment of Chiral Mad 3 stepped up immensely after that, though I definitely still prefer paranormal and physical horror.
My favorite story from the anthology was Red Runner versus the Surgeon Issue 18 by Jessica May Lin. It screwed with my head a little bit, but it was so interesting and not something you see normally, so I truly enjoyed it. The runners-up were A Rift in Reflection by Hal Bodner, A Flash of Red by Erinn L. Kempler, The Bigger Bedroom by Josh Malerman, and The Dead Collection by Mercedes Yardley. I do have to give a disturbing imagery/dead child trigger warning on The Dead Collection, though. Josh Malerman’s piece is one that I’m going to end up going back and reading a few times. I’m still not sure I understood exactly what was going on there. It was definitely creepy, though.
As for poems, I have to admit in general they were not a hit with me. However, Put Me to Dream and Arbitration were both enjoyable.
Overall, I think almost everyone could find at least one story or poem in here that they liked. It’s worth checking out. However, fans of the darker horror probably are going to have a little bit of a harder time. Chiral Mad 3 excels in making you think and screwing with your head, which is fitting considering its a psychological horror collection, but doesn’t really hit the levels of deeply disturbing you might be expecting.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
For this and other horror and science fiction reviews, please visit Sci-Fi & Scary.
I expected to be creeped out or greatly unsettled. That, unfortunately, rarely happened. So, I had to sit back from the book for a bit, and readjust how I looked at it. I took the overall tone from the first several stories and poems and adjusted my expectation. That worked, because the stories contained within are great – they just weren’t what I was expecting. My enjoyment of Chiral Mad 3 stepped up immensely after that, though I definitely still prefer paranormal and physical horror.
My favorite story from the anthology was Red Runner versus the Surgeon Issue 18 by Jessica May Lin. It screwed with my head a little bit, but it was so interesting and not something you see normally, so I truly enjoyed it. The runners-up were A Rift in Reflection by Hal Bodner, A Flash of Red by Erinn L. Kempler, The Bigger Bedroom by Josh Malerman, and The Dead Collection by Mercedes Yardley. I do have to give a disturbing imagery/dead child trigger warning on The Dead Collection, though. Josh Malerman’s piece is one that I’m going to end up going back and reading a few times. I’m still not sure I understood exactly what was going on there. It was definitely creepy, though.
As for poems, I have to admit in general they were not a hit with me. However, Put Me to Dream and Arbitration were both enjoyable.
Overall, I think almost everyone could find at least one story or poem in here that they liked. It’s worth checking out. However, fans of the darker horror probably are going to have a little bit of a harder time. Chiral Mad 3 excels in making you think and screwing with your head, which is fitting considering its a psychological horror collection, but doesn’t really hit the levels of deeply disturbing you might be expecting.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
For this and other horror and science fiction reviews, please visit Sci-Fi & Scary.
More...