Reviews

Guardian Demon by Meljean Brook

prgchrqltma's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Characters: Seen these two before. Now mentally untangled, they must deal with the aftermath.
World Building: All over the map. Literally.
Plot: Clearly tying up a bunch of loose ends in the overall story arc. Heavily internal, though.
Sex: Interesting.
Read another: I haven't done the whole series, so probably.

oliwija's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Jag gillade den här boken väldigt mycket. Trots att jag gjorde det på det lite otraditionella sättet och började med sista boken först. Men då vet jag i alla fall vad jag har att vänta mig framöver. Jag gillade verkligen den här boken och den har sin egen lilla nisch.

mcummings's review

Go to review page

3.0

While I thought this was a satisfying conclusion to the series, with everyone from the previous books participating in the final battle, it kind of dragged for me, especially in regards to the Michael/Andromeda relationship.

elusivity's review

Go to review page

2.0

2 STARS.

Unlike previous novels, these two are Standard-Issue Hero and Heroine. Straight Alpha male and typical "tough" woman with trust issues, enacting female-oriented ultimate fantasy of a powerful, gorgeous, manly, strong, 8000-year-old warrior who continuously proclaims "I am yours" with sincerity, all-consumingly protective, and completely selfless. Against all of this, she eventually "melts" and trusts him. Then throws a giant tantrum when he might be going away.

I suppose I should not expect depictions of self-awareness and maturity in what is essentially a wish-fulfillment fantasy. However, a relationship based on a perfect man satisfying EVERY secret fantasy and circumventing ALL your fears is infantile. If you have trust issues, it is your responsibility to deal with them, not to place all burdens upon some person who promises to never violate your trust.

Could not stop rolling my eyes at all the talk of her sex rubbing against his hardness. Or the repetitive description of her as being SO UNIQUE, unlike ANYONE he'd EVER MET in 8000 years. For one, this cannot be true by statistics alone. For another, the woman herself is ... a bland cliche, especially compared to that ultimate STRONG but vulnerable woman, Irena. Sigh..

The Demon-Angel-Vampire Satan End-of-the-world plots are negligible, much less fascinating than in previous novels.

Is it me, or does Ms. Brook really enjoy putting Savi and Collin in situations where either one or the other or both are brutally tortured, with inevitable displays of just HOW MUCH he ADORES her and would rather die himself than see her harmed, etc etc.. They are my favorite couple and I enjoy seeing them, but really, poor Collin!

Recommended for Meljean Brook fans, who seem very satisfied with this book. For me, an anticlimactic finish to an outstanding series.

oliwija's review

Go to review page

4.0

Jag gillade den här boken väldigt mycket. Trots att jag gjorde det på det lite otraditionella sättet och började med sista boken först. Men då vet jag i alla fall vad jag har att vänta mig framöver. Jag gillade verkligen den här boken och den har sin egen lilla nisch.

darlenemarshall's review

Go to review page

4.0

Excellent conclusion to an outstanding paranormal series. It makes me want to re-read all the previous books to reacquaint myself with the characters and enjoy their stories all over again.

The story of Andromeda "Andy" Taylor and Michael, the chief of the Guardians, has been building over time. Brook delivers the goods with a romance full of passion and angst, and not a little bit of humor ("House porn"). Fans will be impressed and pleased at how the author skillfully pulls all the threads together into a lovely tapestry by the end.
More...