Scan barcode
Reviews
Planescape: Torment by ShadowCatboy, Logan Stromberg, Rhys Hess, Chris Avellone, Colin McComb
mrhumpage's review
5.0
Superb. Flawed - as a game script doesn't quite work naturally as a novel, there is such a volume of dialogue, but framing it in such a way and linking the original words with love and appreciation for the source material this is a novel anyone who liked the game should read. Even worth taking a chance on it if you just like a decent fantasy yarn.
A superlative game, and a very enjoyable book.
A superlative game, and a very enjoyable book.
bennyawesome's review
5.0
Endure, in enduring grow strong.
With this in mind I have undertaken the reading of this mammoth of a novelization (after all the game that the book draws from is famous for having a record amount of written text of all games, still I didn't expect it would be of War and Peace proportions). I ended up enjoying it immensely as I found it to be rather a successful novelizations of my all-time favorite games.
If you have played the game, you are likely to absolutely enjoy it, it's easy to follow, the original text is skillfully framed with narrative descriptions and interludes on behalf of the editor and Let's Play author (original available here: http://lparchive.org/Planescape-Torment/) which only added to the experience. I particularly enjoyed reading the various closure passages addressing the fate of some characters and locations that the protagonist have visited over the course of his journeys as well as short epilogue, which also contributed to the closure and made the transaction from game to book media all the better.
Even if you have not played the game it is still worthy, though somewhat complex fantasy tale of a man plagued by his inability to die, amnesia, namelessness and multitude of actions his past "incarnations".
With this in mind I have undertaken the reading of this mammoth of a novelization (after all the game that the book draws from is famous for having a record amount of written text of all games, still I didn't expect it would be of War and Peace proportions). I ended up enjoying it immensely as I found it to be rather a successful novelizations of my all-time favorite games.
If you have played the game, you are likely to absolutely enjoy it, it's easy to follow, the original text is skillfully framed with narrative descriptions and interludes on behalf of the editor and Let's Play author (original available here: http://lparchive.org/Planescape-Torment/) which only added to the experience. I particularly enjoyed reading the various closure passages addressing the fate of some characters and locations that the protagonist have visited over the course of his journeys as well as short epilogue, which also contributed to the closure and made the transaction from game to book media all the better.
Even if you have not played the game it is still worthy, though somewhat complex fantasy tale of a man plagued by his inability to die, amnesia, namelessness and multitude of actions his past "incarnations".
cavalary's review
4.0
This really is a novelization, a lot of effort being made to go through the game as it's played, going way beyond merely describing and attempting to make events flow more naturally. There is a lot of added writing, and much of it is actually really, really good, greatly improving an already great story. The intermissions and the multiple and fitting storytellers are also a nice touch, and successfully including that evil alternate path was quite a feat. Powerful sections follow that moment, gathered together, and later the writing improves even further. The Maze is notable, but largely fixing Curst, which was the one part of the game's story that seemed lacking to me, is even more so. And what follows is better yet, adding many more details, written and fitting so well, developing, explaining, fleshing out and, in the end, providing closure... Or perhaps not, considering the epilogue, but I'd call that a good way to end it as well, even if it may not fit with the original concept.
It's in bad need of editing, however. I'd have thought that a fan effort would have been thoroughly corrected since it was first released, but it's full of typos, missing or repeated words, places where first and second person get mixed and, worst of all, places where the idea seems to have been changed in the middle of a sentence and the old text wasn't deleted before continuing with the new. There are also moments when the one writing the descriptions of actual gameplay seemed to get bored, skipping more, which can be rather jarring, and those persuasion scenes from Curst also seem rushed. But the worst "crime" is modifying "Longing". To change what may well be the best piece of writing in a game... I guess the idea was to clean it up, maybe even "complete" it to some extent, but it just doesn't work that way, the original text being all about raw emotion and being torn in that manner. Also, don't those memories about Deionarra contradict it? Or does that section refer to another moment?
It's in bad need of editing, however. I'd have thought that a fan effort would have been thoroughly corrected since it was first released, but it's full of typos, missing or repeated words, places where first and second person get mixed and, worst of all, places where the idea seems to have been changed in the middle of a sentence and the old text wasn't deleted before continuing with the new. There are also moments when the one writing the descriptions of actual gameplay seemed to get bored, skipping more, which can be rather jarring, and those persuasion scenes from Curst also seem rushed. But the worst "crime" is modifying "Longing". To change what may well be the best piece of writing in a game... I guess the idea was to clean it up, maybe even "complete" it to some extent, but it just doesn't work that way, the original text being all about raw emotion and being torn in that manner. Also, don't those memories about Deionarra contradict it? Or does that section refer to another moment?
More...