Reviews

Catwoman, Vol. 4: Gotham Underground by Ann Nocenti

cloudchaimber's review

3.0

Okay collection at best. At worst, the Joker’s Daughter is one-dimensional and ruins an otherwise interesting story.

iam_griff's review

1.0

Nocenti strikes again with even a worse story. Will somebody cut off 2 of her fingers so she can’t write anymore. Catwoman used to be such a badass until this tart started writing for DC.

kellylynnthomas's review

3.0

This was better than volume 3, but still far from excellent. Storytelling is still jumpy and disconnected, with no real character development.

dance64's review

3.0

*Rounded to 2.75*

stellardoc's review

3.0

Catwoman deserves better stories than these.

lukeisthename34's review

2.0

Just a hot mess.

a_h_haga's review

1.0

Ok, this whole album was just a mess. The story could be interesting, but there was so much back and forth, some storylines seemed to drop out of nowhere, and somehow everyone knew who everyone was the moment they met each other.
And despite everything going on, I was bored. The whole album felt like such a drag.
I usually don't give 1 stars, but here I did. There was nothing good about this album, not compared to the other ones.

I will be reading the next - and last - album, though, if only so I can say that I've finished the first arc

birdmanseven's review

2.0

I like Catwoman. I've even liked some solo Catwoman. Not this, but other solo stuff. I liked her war with Penguin and her team up with the cop, but not enough to carry me through this mess.

raphynette's review

1.0

It went from bad (vol. 3) to worse (vol. 4). I don't even know if I can put myself through reading vol. 5 considering it's run by Ann Nocenti. AGAIN.
It took me 16 days to finish that volume. WHO THE HELL TAKES 16 DAYS TO READ A 200+ PAGE COMIC BOOK? That's a token of how bad this volume is.

booknooknoggin's review against another edition

2.0

Gotham underground,and the Joker's Daughter. wouldn't bother with this.