Scan barcode
Reviews
GURKHA: Better to Die than Live a Coward: My Life in the Gurkhas by Kailash Limbu, Alexander Norman
spencesational's review
3.0
I'm sorry but this book bored me to tears, as do all books regarding Afghanistan. This is because the book market is saturated with them. And they all read the same.
When you pick up a book in a shop entitled 'Gurkha', you expect it to be about Gurkhas. This skimmed over the life of a Gurkha; deciding to concentrate on the Afghanistan war instead. I wanted to read about the life of a Gurkha; their history, how and why they are one of the most feared regiments in the world, what makes them different, do they train differently, for example? I didn't want to read about Gurkhas fighting in Aghanistan. OK, Limbu mentions how he became a Gurkha but it was no different to how any other member of any regiment would get into the army: join young, get shouted at, get up early, run, get fitter, pass out, go to war. Same old, same old!
There was a sad ending but this lasted for the last three pages of the book and was predictable; I knew from early in the book what was going to happen to who. Overall, I don't see why this book has so many 5 star ratings. I was quite glad when I'd finished it.
When you pick up a book in a shop entitled 'Gurkha', you expect it to be about Gurkhas. This skimmed over the life of a Gurkha; deciding to concentrate on the Afghanistan war instead. I wanted to read about the life of a Gurkha; their history, how and why they are one of the most feared regiments in the world, what makes them different, do they train differently, for example? I didn't want to read about Gurkhas fighting in Aghanistan. OK, Limbu mentions how he became a Gurkha but it was no different to how any other member of any regiment would get into the army: join young, get shouted at, get up early, run, get fitter, pass out, go to war. Same old, same old!
There was a sad ending but this lasted for the last three pages of the book and was predictable; I knew from early in the book what was going to happen to who. Overall, I don't see why this book has so many 5 star ratings. I was quite glad when I'd finished it.
venkyloquist's review
3.0
The feeling that stems from a reading of Colour Sergeant Kailash Limbu can at best be described as ambivalent. If you are looking for an extended and elaborate history of the stellar origins and stupendous achievement of the much admired and feared Gurkha Regiment, then this definitely is not a book. However if you are interested in the manner in which the indomitable Gurkhas act in the face of a deadly siege during the course of a particular operation, then this sans any doubt is a perfect primer.
Nawzad, is a small town, the centre of Nawzad District in Helmand Province, Afghanistan. It is located at an altitude of 1221 metres above sea level. Famously named Apocalypse "Now Zad", this town was the epicentre of a war of attrition between the murderous Taliban forces and the combined British, Gurkha and Estonian forces. As part of Operation Herrick (the codename under which all British operations in the War in Afghanistan were conducted from 2002 to the end of combat operations in 2014), soldiers from the Gurkha regiment were sent into Now Zad to man a compound housing an Afghan police station and a few members of the ANP Military. The Gurkhas were subjected to one of the longest sieges in the battle of Now Zad lasting for all of thirty one days.
Kailash Limbu who was commanding the Gurkha troops chronicles the thirty one day siege in spectacular detail. Abiding by the Gurkha motto of ''Kaphar hunnu bhanda marnu ramro' which when translated into English reads "Better to die than live a coward", Kailash and his team face a relentless barrage of Afghani RPGs, sniper fires, treacherous deceptions and night attacks with stoicism and courage. During the course of detailing the siege, Kailash also provides a sneak peek into the process of recruitment for entry into the Gurkha regiment, and the ways of the Limbu people going about their lives in Nepal.
This according to the author is the first ever time in the 200 year old glorious history of the Gurkhas that a soldier has been permitted to write their story. Although very honest and interesting in its intent, the book could have taken a much greater advantage of such a precious and unique privilege granted to its author.
Nawzad, is a small town, the centre of Nawzad District in Helmand Province, Afghanistan. It is located at an altitude of 1221 metres above sea level. Famously named Apocalypse "Now Zad", this town was the epicentre of a war of attrition between the murderous Taliban forces and the combined British, Gurkha and Estonian forces. As part of Operation Herrick (the codename under which all British operations in the War in Afghanistan were conducted from 2002 to the end of combat operations in 2014), soldiers from the Gurkha regiment were sent into Now Zad to man a compound housing an Afghan police station and a few members of the ANP Military. The Gurkhas were subjected to one of the longest sieges in the battle of Now Zad lasting for all of thirty one days.
Kailash Limbu who was commanding the Gurkha troops chronicles the thirty one day siege in spectacular detail. Abiding by the Gurkha motto of ''Kaphar hunnu bhanda marnu ramro' which when translated into English reads "Better to die than live a coward", Kailash and his team face a relentless barrage of Afghani RPGs, sniper fires, treacherous deceptions and night attacks with stoicism and courage. During the course of detailing the siege, Kailash also provides a sneak peek into the process of recruitment for entry into the Gurkha regiment, and the ways of the Limbu people going about their lives in Nepal.
This according to the author is the first ever time in the 200 year old glorious history of the Gurkhas that a soldier has been permitted to write their story. Although very honest and interesting in its intent, the book could have taken a much greater advantage of such a precious and unique privilege granted to its author.
More...