Scan barcode
ptaradactyl's review against another edition
informative
sad
slow-paced
This was an interesting weaving of facts and surmises, and clearly explained as such. Enslaved women vanished from the historical record, and this book fills in potential narratives based on other accounts.
It was educational and powerful, and I was not left with a good impression is Sims.
But dang, could it meander and drag at times, even with very good narration. At one point, we got recipe recitations. At another, civil was naval battles and Italian astronomers. More than once, I skipped ahead trying to get back to the central discussion of the “invention” of modern gynecology.
It was educational and powerful, and I was not left with a good impression is Sims.
But dang, could it meander and drag at times, even with very good narration. At one point, we got recipe recitations. At another, civil was naval battles and Italian astronomers. More than once, I skipped ahead trying to get back to the central discussion of the “invention” of modern gynecology.
whitecat5000's review against another edition
informative
slow-paced
1.0
DNF. It was interesting to learn about Anarcha, but the structure of the book made the narrative seem tedious. It also seemed that there was some author liberties taken with describing her childhood.
penandpage's review
4.0
The pages of history are often filled with tales of heroism, innovation, and progress. Yet, sometimes, they also harbor the unsung stories of those whose sacrifices paved the way for change, even if they themselves have been forgotten by time.
Say Anarcha: A Young Woman, a Devious Surgeon, and the Harrowing Birth of Modern Women’s Health, penned by J.C. Hallman, is a compelling literary journey that uncovers one such narrative. Nestled within the pages of this book is the tale of Anarcha, a young enslaved woman whose legacy was concealed, and the nefarious Dr. J. Marion Sims, a man who redefined the path of women’s health while tarnishing his own legacy.
Say Anarcha y J.C. Hallman
The Historical Background
In a society where historical accounts are often dominated by male voices and perspectives, “Say Anarcha” seeks to illuminate the forgotten history of women and their struggles, particularly those of Black women. The book delves into the life of Dr. J. Marion Sims, a figure heralded for over a century as the “father of modern gynecology.” Sims’s contributions to medical history were once celebrated, with statues erected in his honor, yet the book peels away the layers of his facade, revealing the darker truths beneath.
A Dark Path to Recognition
Dr. Sims’s reputation was built upon a series of experimental surgeries, conducted without anesthesia, on a young enslaved woman named Anarcha. These procedures, aimed at addressing obstetric fistula, left Anarcha enduring unimaginable pain and suffering. The book meticulously chronicles the more than 30 surgeries she underwent, all without the solace of painkillers. These operations were marked by failure, yet Sims boldly claimed success through articles and speeches, perpetuating his own image of a hero.
However, Sims’s true motivations were far from noble. His ultimate goal was not just medical advancement but financial gain. He capitalized on the pain of both Anarcha and other enslaved women, seeking wealth from wealthy white women in need of similar surgeries. This exploitative pursuit serves as a stark reminder of the intersection between racism, sexism, and the medical field during that era.
Anarcha’s Triumphs and Tribulations
Through the words of Hallman, Anarcha’s story is resurrected from the shadows of history. She emerges as a figure of strength and resilience, enduring unimaginable hardship for the sake of medical progress. Anarcha’s journey, although rooted in pain, is a testament to the fortitude of women throughout history who bore the brunt of medical experimentation and societal oppression. While Sims garnered accolades and statues, Anarcha’s story remained shrouded, buried beneath layers of time and prejudice.
Confronting the Horrors of the Past
As Hallman guides readers through the intricacies of history, he fearlessly confronts the horrors of the past. The book does not shy away from highlighting the egregious mistreatment and abuse endured by enslaved women. The surgeries on Anarcha, devoid of anesthesia, mirror the broader disregard for the physical and emotional well-being of women, especially those who were marginalized due to race and social status. It serves as a poignant reminder of the lengths to which the medical community once went, all while disregarding the humanity of their subjects.
A Nuanced Narrative
While Say Anarcha undoubtedly stands as a powerful narrative, it is not without its nuances. The book occasionally strays from its central focus, digressing into topics that, while intriguing on their own, somewhat disrupt the narrative flow. Lengthy discussions of astronomical events and family histories, while interesting, can dilute the book’s primary purpose.
Additionally, the transition between past and present was jarring. A more seamless integration of this shift could have allowed for a smoother reading experience. Yet, in the midst of these distractions, Anarcha’s story remains a shining light, a beacon of perseverance and courage in the face of unimaginable odds.
Read more at A Pen and a Page
Say Anarcha: A Young Woman, a Devious Surgeon, and the Harrowing Birth of Modern Women’s Health, penned by J.C. Hallman, is a compelling literary journey that uncovers one such narrative. Nestled within the pages of this book is the tale of Anarcha, a young enslaved woman whose legacy was concealed, and the nefarious Dr. J. Marion Sims, a man who redefined the path of women’s health while tarnishing his own legacy.
Say Anarcha y J.C. Hallman
The Historical Background
In a society where historical accounts are often dominated by male voices and perspectives, “Say Anarcha” seeks to illuminate the forgotten history of women and their struggles, particularly those of Black women. The book delves into the life of Dr. J. Marion Sims, a figure heralded for over a century as the “father of modern gynecology.” Sims’s contributions to medical history were once celebrated, with statues erected in his honor, yet the book peels away the layers of his facade, revealing the darker truths beneath.
A Dark Path to Recognition
Dr. Sims’s reputation was built upon a series of experimental surgeries, conducted without anesthesia, on a young enslaved woman named Anarcha. These procedures, aimed at addressing obstetric fistula, left Anarcha enduring unimaginable pain and suffering. The book meticulously chronicles the more than 30 surgeries she underwent, all without the solace of painkillers. These operations were marked by failure, yet Sims boldly claimed success through articles and speeches, perpetuating his own image of a hero.
However, Sims’s true motivations were far from noble. His ultimate goal was not just medical advancement but financial gain. He capitalized on the pain of both Anarcha and other enslaved women, seeking wealth from wealthy white women in need of similar surgeries. This exploitative pursuit serves as a stark reminder of the intersection between racism, sexism, and the medical field during that era.
Anarcha’s Triumphs and Tribulations
Through the words of Hallman, Anarcha’s story is resurrected from the shadows of history. She emerges as a figure of strength and resilience, enduring unimaginable hardship for the sake of medical progress. Anarcha’s journey, although rooted in pain, is a testament to the fortitude of women throughout history who bore the brunt of medical experimentation and societal oppression. While Sims garnered accolades and statues, Anarcha’s story remained shrouded, buried beneath layers of time and prejudice.
Confronting the Horrors of the Past
As Hallman guides readers through the intricacies of history, he fearlessly confronts the horrors of the past. The book does not shy away from highlighting the egregious mistreatment and abuse endured by enslaved women. The surgeries on Anarcha, devoid of anesthesia, mirror the broader disregard for the physical and emotional well-being of women, especially those who were marginalized due to race and social status. It serves as a poignant reminder of the lengths to which the medical community once went, all while disregarding the humanity of their subjects.
A Nuanced Narrative
While Say Anarcha undoubtedly stands as a powerful narrative, it is not without its nuances. The book occasionally strays from its central focus, digressing into topics that, while intriguing on their own, somewhat disrupt the narrative flow. Lengthy discussions of astronomical events and family histories, while interesting, can dilute the book’s primary purpose.
Additionally, the transition between past and present was jarring. A more seamless integration of this shift could have allowed for a smoother reading experience. Yet, in the midst of these distractions, Anarcha’s story remains a shining light, a beacon of perseverance and courage in the face of unimaginable odds.
Read more at A Pen and a Page
rc_cola's review
4.0
Vividly painting the antebellum South's cultural lanscape, Hallman brings dark buried histories of slavery, gynecological research, and doctoral ethics into the light. A work of speculative nonfiction that reads as compelling as Butler's "Kindred" and well-researched as Larson's, Chernow's, and Kearns Goodwin's volumes. A creative powerhouse, brilliantly stitching science, healing, violence, and humanity together for a telling read.
tipsytarsier's review against another edition
challenging
emotional
informative
inspiring
sad
medium-paced
5.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Pregnancy, Violence, Rape, Sexual violence, and Slavery
full_of_flowers's review
The story of Anarcha herself is one that needs to be known, but this book, thick as it is, contains too little of it in proportion. There's so much tangential information that pulls focus from her experience, as well as too much grace given to J. Marion Sims (the doctor who experimented on Anarcha without consent or anesthesia) in my opinion.