Scan barcode
ehgold23's review against another edition
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.75
novelheartbeat's review
2.0
I had the same problem with this one that I had with Ten: TOO MUCH DRAMA. I mean, I understand that they’re in high school, but jeez! High school is NOT like reality TV. Either that or I just had a ridiculously tame high school.
To be honest, this could have been a 4 star book for me if it hadn’t been for the characters. The originality was outstanding, and I loved the idea – anything to do with parallel universes will usually grab me. But, I couldn’t stand the main character, Josie. Quite hated her, actually. She bases her life and all of her decisions solely around a boy – Nick. If a dude is obviously not interested in you (um, helloooo, he treats you like poo and he cheated on you…with your ‘best’ friend for crying out loud), it’s time to move on! Ughhh. That always drives me bat shit crazy – maybe because I’ve always been very independent and have a ‘screw you’ mentality to people who hurt me or double cross me – but I can’t stand when females latch onto a male and make him the center of their universe. I’d better get back on track here, before I go off onto a tangent that has absolutely nothing to do with this book. *clears throat*
Back to Josie. She was a weak, spineless, sniveling coward. I can’t stand the doormat personality leads, and she was definitely one. She was meek as a mouse, and stood by and let people treat her like crap without speaking up or standing up for herself. I hate, hate when characters don’t stand up for themselves. You have a mouth, use it! She kept talking about her ‘shame’ and ‘embarrassment’ to being the butt of all jokes (because the saying ‘being Byrned‘ – her last name is Byrne, how original – is like, omg, soooo horrific) and having everyone stare at her and talk about her. Like it was Josie that was in the wrong. Um, they cheated on you! Pretty sure most people would regard them with disdain and disgust. Just sayin. Yet, she ran and hid and cried like a little baby about it. Probably beating a dead horse here, but stop crying and stand up for yourself. DO something about it. Like, move on? Maybe? But nooo. She gets even worse.
Instead of being like ‘You know what, to hell with you, I’m better off without you,’ she spies on her ex boyfriend and best friend together (and of course gets caught and is so humiliated she wants to die *eye roll*), wishes desperately that she could have ‘seen it coming’ so she could have prevented it (IF HE CHEATED ON YOU, NOTHING YOU DID WOULD HAVE MATTERED BECAUSE HE’S NOT GOOD ENOUGH FOR YOU. End of story). Then, when she sees a glimpse of Jo’s world and thinks that the other version of herself is still with Nick, she willingly trades places just to have a second chance. Gag me with a spoon.
Maybe time travel was out of the realm of possibility, but now there was another Nick. A Nick who still loved her. Maybe she could still be there for him? Fix her mistakes with Nick, even if it was just for one day.
Okay, and for the mistakes part, having a brother with cancer is NOT a reason to cheat on someone. He can’t get mad at her for ‘not caring’ when she didn’t even know! He should have told her instead of letting it go until he ended up pinning the blame on her. Ridiculous. That’s his mistake, not hers. You can’t not tell someone something and then get mad because they didn’t know. What do you think she is, a mind reader?
Oh, and did I mention she opted to walk two miles in the dark just because she didn’t want him to see her get in her car that was right there in the parking lot? How damn stupid do you have to be? She was so lame I wanted to stab myself in the leg. As if that wasn’t bad enough, then she takes a ‘short cut’ through the dark woods. Idiot. I was kind of hoping she’d die, even though I knew there’d be no story if she did. *le sigh*
Then when she gets to Jo’s world (that’s her double in the alternate universe), and Nick starts blabbing on about the Grid and Nox, she doesn’t ask what he’s talking about. You’ve never heard of this ‘Grid’ before, and you don’t wonder what it is? There was no curiosity about the terminology, not even in her thought process. It made no sense to me.
The plot was painfully predictable. I was ten steps ahead of the characters and saw the twists coming a mile away.
Spoiler
I figured out that the Nox were behind the killings in Josie’s world the second she realized objects were randomly popping from one world to the next. If a shoe or a vase can, why can’t a Nox?Also, when the dark stranger came into play, I knew immediately it was Nick’s brother. Which is sad, because he was supposed to be dead. But it was so obvious!
I felt absolutely no emotion while reading. Things that probably should have mattered to me didn’t even register.
Spoiler
One of the main characters dies and it was so abrupt and….clinical…that I didn’t give a rat’s ass. And I didn’t believe for a second that he was actually dead…again with being predictable. I was like, ‘Yeahhh nice try. He’s obviously not going to really die.’Also, Josie being immune to the Nox made NO sense, because they killed people in her world. If she’s immune just because she’s from her dimension, why aren’t all the other people from the same dimension immune as well?
How can the other Nick be so different, if he’s basically the same person? And since he’s supposedly THAT different, we have a raging case of instalove.
They needed each other, were desperate to be together no matter whose universe they chose. Josie’s heart ached from happiness. She’d never felt this way with her ex-boyfriend. This was something different. Something deeper. Even though they had only known each other a few days, Nick knew her better than anyone else, and loved her even more because of it.
“Even though they had only known each other a few days-“…..a few days. A FEW DAYS. AND YOU LOVE EACH OTHER. Yeah, and I have the magical ability to snort water up my nose and ralph it up as wine. Would anyone like a glass?
The saving grace of this book was the originality. Obviously the alternate universe part, but also because of the Nox. It reminded me a bit of Pitch Black. And it was pretty cool, I’ll have to admit. Honestly, I was going to give this 3 stars before I started writing this review. But just talking about how much all those things annoyed me annoys me all over again, and now I’m just plain annoyed. How annoying. I didn’t realize how much it bothered me until now because I was too busy reading the book. Oh, the woes of being a reviewer. Life is so terrible. Oh gawd, Josie is rubbing off on me.
OVERALL ASSESSMENT
Plot: 3.5/5
Writing style: 3/5
Originality: 4.5/5
Characters: 0.5/5
World-building: 3/5
Pace: 3.5/5
Cover: 3/5
sc104906's review
3.0
This book started off slow, but it pulled through in the end. It was your typical parallel universe book with a supernatural twist. The main character finds a portal to a parallel universe through her mirror (so very Alice in Wonderland). There is a world switch and then the lies and intrigue begin. Can Josie save her friends and family before it is too late?
sstensland's review
2.0
In the acknowledgements, she mentions the difficulty she had writing this. Needless to say, it showed. The concept is good, but that's about where it ends. Yes, I did enjoy it for a quick read, but there is still little to be desired. Unexplained change of hearts, silly romance that developed too late, and plenty of dead ends. There is some set up for a sequel--wouldn't be too surprising as everything is a series now. However I feel like this book would have been better off with a different ending in either case. For me, it feels like she gave up and jotted down the first ending she could come up with.
losetimereading's review
4.0
I was SOOOO excited to start 3:59. It was actually one of my most anticipated reads for the fall. I really started to fall in love with parallel worlds/alternate universe stories after I read Pivot Point and I was itching to fill that void.
Josie, the main character, was very likable. She was one of those characters that cared more about the people around her than herself and I appreciated that. She wasn’t self-centered, she was a bit nerdy and very loyal to her friends, or really anyone that she thought deserved that loyalty. Jo, the alternate, was totally the opposite and I can’t say I liked her at all (although looking back I’m not sure if the reader was really meant to like her). The characters weren’t really a focus of mine in the story. While I liked the majority of them, besides Josie-Nick (what an ass), I didn’t really get attached to any of them.
3:59 is definitely a plot-driven story in that aspect. I LOVED the story. I thought it was fantastic, and extremely well done. It did have quite a bit of science (quantum physics?) but it was well explained and didn’t confuse me as a reader at all. Sometimes I find sci-fi is VERY confusing, and some things aren’t detailed out for a non-regular reader of science fiction. The mirror as a portal to the parallel universe, that only stayed open for one minute every twelve hours, was just so freakin cool to me. I loved that aspect.
Another element that I very much enjoyed was the fact that the alternates had totally different personalities. I liked that even though I didn’t like a character on one side of the mirror, I liked them on the other side. It was also very hard to tell who to trust, and maybe I was naive, but I didn’t catch on to a lot of the twists until they were happening. That itself was probably my favorite thing about this novel, that the twists and turns were very well done. I often can predict parts of the story before they happen but I didn’t do that in 3:59.
I really enjoy Gretchen McNeil’s writing. I have all of her other novels but had yet to pick up one, but this has convinced me I need to do that asap. Her style of writing is catchy and engrossing and I didn’t want to put 3:59 down once I started.
The ending was well done, and slightly open-ended which was interesting. The reason this is a 4 star, and not a 5 star for me though, is because of the ending. I will not spoil it but I would have liked it done a bit differently. It’s not a deal breaker though, and I still think a lot of people would like the way the story turns out.
I would definitely recommend picking up this one, especially if you enjoy other parallel universe stories. It has only made me want MORE!
Josie, the main character, was very likable. She was one of those characters that cared more about the people around her than herself and I appreciated that. She wasn’t self-centered, she was a bit nerdy and very loyal to her friends, or really anyone that she thought deserved that loyalty. Jo, the alternate, was totally the opposite and I can’t say I liked her at all (although looking back I’m not sure if the reader was really meant to like her). The characters weren’t really a focus of mine in the story. While I liked the majority of them, besides Josie-Nick (what an ass), I didn’t really get attached to any of them.
3:59 is definitely a plot-driven story in that aspect. I LOVED the story. I thought it was fantastic, and extremely well done. It did have quite a bit of science (quantum physics?) but it was well explained and didn’t confuse me as a reader at all. Sometimes I find sci-fi is VERY confusing, and some things aren’t detailed out for a non-regular reader of science fiction. The mirror as a portal to the parallel universe, that only stayed open for one minute every twelve hours, was just so freakin cool to me. I loved that aspect.
Another element that I very much enjoyed was the fact that the alternates had totally different personalities. I liked that even though I didn’t like a character on one side of the mirror, I liked them on the other side. It was also very hard to tell who to trust, and maybe I was naive, but I didn’t catch on to a lot of the twists until they were happening. That itself was probably my favorite thing about this novel, that the twists and turns were very well done. I often can predict parts of the story before they happen but I didn’t do that in 3:59.
I really enjoy Gretchen McNeil’s writing. I have all of her other novels but had yet to pick up one, but this has convinced me I need to do that asap. Her style of writing is catchy and engrossing and I didn’t want to put 3:59 down once I started.
The ending was well done, and slightly open-ended which was interesting. The reason this is a 4 star, and not a 5 star for me though, is because of the ending. I will not spoil it but I would have liked it done a bit differently. It’s not a deal breaker though, and I still think a lot of people would like the way the story turns out.
I would definitely recommend picking up this one, especially if you enjoy other parallel universe stories. It has only made me want MORE!
paxultek's review
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.25
jenbsbooks's review against another edition
2.0
Eh ... I've been in a reading mood and I got through this quickly, but it was more just pressing to finishing than actually enjoying the story. I don't know if I missed some things attempting to read too quickly, but I certainly didn't want to go back and re-read in an attempt to better understand.
Josie happens to be doing a complex science experiment on parallel universes ... her mom is a scientist, doing a lot of work at home, so I guess it runs in the family. There was quite a bit of pseudo-science talk that bogged things down for me. I never quite understood the whole "mirror" thing. The trains carrying some element were crossing paths in both parallel universes at the same time (3:59) and that created a portal? Then, at 3:59 (both a.m. and p.m.) Josie gets glimpses into this parallel universe, via a dream ... or she can see looking through the mirror, and even walk through the mirror. Of course, some items seem to be switching places in the two universes randomly (through the mirror, or something else?) Glimpses into the parallel plain things are remarkably similar ... yet there are clues that it's different too (over there Jo sleeps with the lights blazing all night, hmmmm, why?) Oh, and there are mysterious deaths. When Josie is swapped into the parallel plane she is attacked by these creatures, saved somehow, then the creatures seem to NOT attack her for all future encounters (this was one of the things I didn't get but didn't want to reread to investigate).
So it's this mystery the kids are trying to solve, trying to fix things and save the world(s). It all seemed a bit silly and b-movie. I really did not like the ending either, although I guess a perfect happily ever after wouldn't really have worked either.
Just ... blah.
Josie happens to be doing a complex science experiment on parallel universes ... her mom is a scientist, doing a lot of work at home, so I guess it runs in the family. There was quite a bit of pseudo-science talk that bogged things down for me. I never quite understood the whole "mirror" thing. The trains carrying some element were crossing paths in both parallel universes at the same time (3:59) and that created a portal? Then, at 3:59 (both a.m. and p.m.) Josie gets glimpses into this parallel universe, via a dream ... or she can see looking through the mirror, and even walk through the mirror. Of course, some items seem to be switching places in the two universes randomly (through the mirror, or something else?) Glimpses into the parallel plain things are remarkably similar ... yet there are clues that it's different too (over there Jo sleeps with the lights blazing all night, hmmmm, why?) Oh, and there are mysterious deaths. When Josie is swapped into the parallel plane she is attacked by these creatures, saved somehow, then the creatures seem to NOT attack her for all future encounters (this was one of the things I didn't get but didn't want to reread to investigate).
So it's this mystery the kids are trying to solve, trying to fix things and save the world(s). It all seemed a bit silly and b-movie. I really did not like the ending either, although I guess a perfect happily ever after wouldn't really have worked either.
Just ... blah.