Scan barcode
yaakovakiva's review against another edition
4.0
Good read! The non-steamy writing was a little bland and repetitive and the accents were a bit much (especially when coming from the narrator), but the romance was fun and steamy bits were fun and I devoured it once I got started. Will check out others in the series.
zaza_bdp's review against another edition
4.0
**** 4.5 ****
Au départ je n'étais pas très convaincue par ce livre, le contexte "Nouveau Monde" étant pour moi incompatible avec le kilt. Seulement c'est Pamela Clare, une de mes auteurs favorites, qui l'a écrit, donc j'ai fait fi de mes préjugés et je me suis lancée.
Hé bien quelle bonne surprise finalement !! Comme d'habitude, Pamela Clare nous offre plus qu'une banale romance, puisque le contexte historique est fortement développé. Ça nous permet de mieux comprendre les personnages et leurs motivations, ainsi que l'époque dans lequel ils évoluent.
Iain a l'étoffe d'un vrai héros : combattif et protecteur, courageux et sans pitié, sensuel et amoureux ... Une combinaison plus que réussie !!
Annie a peut-être moins d'épaisseur de lui, mais elle ne manque pas de cran, et les épreuves qu'elle a traversé l'ont rendue plus forte.
J'ai aimé les personnages secondaires, que ce soit les frères de Iain ou l'ensemble des rangers, qui deviennent une vraie famille pour Annie.
J'ai également apprécié que Wentworth soit un personnage ambigu, là encore Pamela Clare déploie tout son talent pour sortir de la
banalité !
Quant au couple Iain/Annie ... Quelle sensualité !!
Au départ je n'étais pas très convaincue par ce livre, le contexte "Nouveau Monde" étant pour moi incompatible avec le kilt. Seulement c'est Pamela Clare, une de mes auteurs favorites, qui l'a écrit, donc j'ai fait fi de mes préjugés et je me suis lancée.
Hé bien quelle bonne surprise finalement !! Comme d'habitude, Pamela Clare nous offre plus qu'une banale romance, puisque le contexte historique est fortement développé. Ça nous permet de mieux comprendre les personnages et leurs motivations, ainsi que l'époque dans lequel ils évoluent.
Iain a l'étoffe d'un vrai héros : combattif et protecteur, courageux et sans pitié, sensuel et amoureux ... Une combinaison plus que réussie !!
Annie a peut-être moins d'épaisseur de lui, mais elle ne manque pas de cran, et les épreuves qu'elle a traversé l'ont rendue plus forte.
J'ai aimé les personnages secondaires, que ce soit les frères de Iain ou l'ensemble des rangers, qui deviennent une vraie famille pour Annie.
J'ai également apprécié que Wentworth soit un personnage ambigu, là encore Pamela Clare déploie tout son talent pour sortir de la
banalité !
Quant au couple Iain/Annie ... Quelle sensualité !!
bhookjunkhie's review against another edition
5.0
Absolutely Awesome!...But everything from this author always is!...The research shes done for the historical accuracy in this book is nothing short of amazing and adds so much to the story...A great romance with an ending that made me smile through the tears....Theres a lot of reviews that paint this book as super fabulous..It really is, so just go buy it~!!
zippy_julz's review against another edition
4.0
This is the first book I have read from Pamela Clare. It is a n epic love story amidst the British, French and Indian War, specifically around the 1750s. Our Hero and Heroine are coming from different worlds such as social status, political issues, religious beliefs, and upbringing. But when love decides to strike, well, we all know that nothing can stop it.
This book is full of passion, Drama and adventure. It was one of those books that kept me reading into the wee hours of the night. Great read!
This book is full of passion, Drama and adventure. It was one of those books that kept me reading into the wee hours of the night. Great read!
sharonwb's review against another edition
5.0
I'm giving this book favorite status for the exceptional description of colonial North America during the French and Indian war. The way the author writes the adventure scenes especially in the beginning of the book where they are struggling to survive is excellent. The book gives Outlander vibes a bit and I loved it.
carobcbg's review against another edition
5.0
4.5 stars if it were possible. I just finished this last night and I have loved it. The characters were absolutely wonderful. I was emotionally invested in their plights from the first.
It doesn't make me want to rush out and read the next one in the series, but it does cement for me (not that I had any doubts) just how seamlessly Pamela Clare goes between writing interesting, suspenseful contemporaries as well as beautiful, gripping historical romances. For me, the ending was a little too pat, too easily resolved, but I was also ready for the book to end so it kind of worked for me. I felt like I travelled the emotional journey with the characters and by the end of the book, was happy to see them well settled.
Thanks to Heather for making this read possible.
It doesn't make me want to rush out and read the next one in the series, but it does cement for me (not that I had any doubts) just how seamlessly Pamela Clare goes between writing interesting, suspenseful contemporaries as well as beautiful, gripping historical romances. For me, the ending was a little too pat, too easily resolved, but I was also ready for the book to end so it kind of worked for me. I felt like I travelled the emotional journey with the characters and by the end of the book, was happy to see them well settled.
Thanks to Heather for making this read possible.
nataliejoann's review against another edition
5.0
Throughly entertaining and gave me everything I enjoy in the genre with low levels of depressing storyline and a solid HEA
tatdine's review against another edition
1.0
DNF. Not my thing. Very fanfictiony. At one point the FMC is woken by an abrupt kiss from the MMC — which was the exactly moment I gave up on the book. That’s something that happens frequently in fanfiction and it just found it so…weird that I couldn’t keep reading.
I was really rooting for it too because I’ve been wanting a romantic version of Last of the Mohicans but this book was just so poorly written that I didn’t want to push through.
I was really rooting for it too because I’ve been wanting a romantic version of Last of the Mohicans but this book was just so poorly written that I didn’t want to push through.
desiree_mcl's review against another edition
5.0
Reread: 2/2020
Still 5 stars. I listened to the audiobook and Kaleo Griffith does the narration and he's great, he also does her I-Team series and I think her other historical romance trilogy. Love his narration every time.
I've been wanting to reread this for a couple years now, I think the audiobook used the Berkley edition, which has new material. I don't know what that was since it has been a while since I read the Leisure Book edition.
I'm looking forward to rereading the other two in this trilogy.
Original Review:
5 stars.
PC has written another awesome novel.
This is my first historical by her and certainly it won't be my last.
Still 5 stars. I listened to the audiobook and Kaleo Griffith does the narration and he's great, he also does her I-Team series and I think her other historical romance trilogy. Love his narration every time.
I've been wanting to reread this for a couple years now, I think the audiobook used the Berkley edition, which has new material. I don't know what that was since it has been a while since I read the Leisure Book edition.
I'm looking forward to rereading the other two in this trilogy.
Original Review:
5 stars.
PC has written another awesome novel.
This is my first historical by her and certainly it won't be my last.
naomilane's review against another edition
5.0
Surrender was my first book by Pamela Clare and I am so very happy to have read it. Guys, it was AMAZING!!! This book moved me, it was beautiful and interesting and funny, seriously, if you haven’t already, please read it!
I fell in love with Iain MacKinnon right away, I’ve never loved a character like him. Iain is so perfect…he’s mindful, loyal, caring, strong, courageous, smart, funny, sweet, stubborn… Pamela did an amazing job with him. Annie is so different from Iain, she’s sweet, shy, innocent but also loyal and strong, in her own way. Annie is also very young, I think, she’s eighteen. And I think that Iain is twenty-eight, but I’m not sure because I’m the worst when it comes to guessing characters age.
Anyway, these two characters, who are so very different from each other, they come from a different world, they’re supposed to be enemies, well, they formed the most beautiful couple in history (almost).
Pamela did a wonderful job with the romance. It was unhurried, it felt real, she did not try to make things easier for them, and in the middle of all this, the plot and the story were fantastic. The historical side of the story was great, it was very interesting and new for me and I loved it! Pamela must have done lots of research and just for that, you have my respect. I was never bored, not once, not even when it was mostly talks of war and history and all that, I just love Pamela’s writing style!
Like I said, the romance was great. Iain is perfect on his own but also with Annie and vice versa. They were so understanding with each other, of course, it took some time for Annie to trust Iain, which is understandable even though I wanted her to trust him right away. This book was also very erotic in a very beautiful way, the sex scenes weren’t hard or very detailed but they were perfect. I could actually feel their love for each other at the end, throughout the book, Pamela described their feelings for each other so well, not only in words but also in actions. I can’t truly describe how I feel right now, but, after finishing Surrender, I cried. I actually cried because it was over. I shall miss my Rangers so much.
Speaking of Rangers: oh my, I love them too!!! The secondary characters were as awesome as the MCs. Iain’s brothers, Morgan and Connor were amazing and I cannot wait to read their story. Joseph, Killy and all the others as well, I enjoyed reading about them so much and that’s why I cried so badly at the end. Because, even though it was a beautiful ending, it was over. I really need to read the next book! I’m still a bit confused about Lord William Wentworth, I mean, he is a bastard, no doubts about that but he’s confusing me! I need more information about him!
The plot, the story in itself was, once again, amazing. The romance is a good part of the book, the story is mostly focused on the relationship between Iain and Annie but it’s also much more than just that. Like I said, the historical part of the book was so interesting and needed.
I don’t want to write a big review because I will repeat myself but Surrender blew my mind, it really did and thank you Pamela for this amazing, mind blowing and beautiful story.
I fell in love with Iain MacKinnon right away, I’ve never loved a character like him. Iain is so perfect…he’s mindful, loyal, caring, strong, courageous, smart, funny, sweet, stubborn… Pamela did an amazing job with him. Annie is so different from Iain, she’s sweet, shy, innocent but also loyal and strong, in her own way. Annie is also very young, I think, she’s eighteen. And I think that Iain is twenty-eight, but I’m not sure because I’m the worst when it comes to guessing characters age.
Anyway, these two characters, who are so very different from each other, they come from a different world, they’re supposed to be enemies, well, they formed the most beautiful couple in history (almost).
Pamela did a wonderful job with the romance. It was unhurried, it felt real, she did not try to make things easier for them, and in the middle of all this, the plot and the story were fantastic. The historical side of the story was great, it was very interesting and new for me and I loved it! Pamela must have done lots of research and just for that, you have my respect. I was never bored, not once, not even when it was mostly talks of war and history and all that, I just love Pamela’s writing style!
Like I said, the romance was great. Iain is perfect on his own but also with Annie and vice versa. They were so understanding with each other, of course, it took some time for Annie to trust Iain, which is understandable even though I wanted her to trust him right away. This book was also very erotic in a very beautiful way, the sex scenes weren’t hard or very detailed but they were perfect. I could actually feel their love for each other at the end, throughout the book, Pamela described their feelings for each other so well, not only in words but also in actions. I can’t truly describe how I feel right now, but, after finishing Surrender, I cried. I actually cried because it was over. I shall miss my Rangers so much.
Speaking of Rangers: oh my, I love them too!!! The secondary characters were as awesome as the MCs. Iain’s brothers, Morgan and Connor were amazing and I cannot wait to read their story. Joseph, Killy and all the others as well, I enjoyed reading about them so much and that’s why I cried so badly at the end. Because, even though it was a beautiful ending, it was over. I really need to read the next book! I’m still a bit confused about Lord William Wentworth, I mean, he is a bastard, no doubts about that but he’s confusing me! I need more information about him!
The plot, the story in itself was, once again, amazing. The romance is a good part of the book, the story is mostly focused on the relationship between Iain and Annie but it’s also much more than just that. Like I said, the historical part of the book was so interesting and needed.
I don’t want to write a big review because I will repeat myself but Surrender blew my mind, it really did and thank you Pamela for this amazing, mind blowing and beautiful story.