Scan barcode
dlrosebyh's review against another edition
adventurous
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
The Avicen, an ancient race of humans with feathers for hair and magic coursing through their veins, live underneath the streets of New York City. Age-old enchantments keep them concealed from all except one human: Echo, a fugitive pickpocket who survives on the black market by selling stolen riches.
Echo's only family is the Avicen, so when a centuries-old battle erupts on her doorstep, she decides it's time to take action. According to legend, in order to end the fight once and for all, Echo must locate the firebird, a mythological monster thought to wield power the world has never seen. It won't be simple, but if Echo's life as a thief has taught her anything, it's how to find what she wants and how to approach it.
I suppose you could say that this book is mediocre at best? It felt like any normal young adult fantasy: snarky dialogue, found family, badass characters, and stunning descriptions. As previously said, this is a knockoff of Daughter of Smoke and Bone, so I don't have much to say. This is undoubtedly more diversified than Daughter of Smoke and Bone, but that's about all.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Adult/minor relationship, Death, and Torture
Moderate: Ableism and Confinement
Minor: Alcoholism and Drug use
booksthatburn's review
adventurous
funny
hopeful
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
The worldbuilding is light on details, focusing on a few key mechanics (such as the powder that lets Echo turn doorways into portals), a little bit of the Avicen social structure, and the library where Echo lives. Where it dwells is in descriptions of interactions between the characters, coupled with their internal struggles. That there is a war between the Avicen and the Drakharin, one which has gone on for a long time and taken many lives, that is enough for now, but I do hope the sequels have more background detail.
Dorian has one eye, having lost the other by knife in a previous fight. What gradually frustrated me is how often his one-eyed status is brought up in connection with some unrelated negative trait, whether real or imagined. He tortured one of the other characters before they ended up working together, so it's completely understandable that he wouldn't be seen in a positive light and he's in a redemption arc. However, those extremely valid reasons to highlight any of his negative attributes kept being paired in the text with mentions of his disability. It's not a huge thing, but making the villain be the character missing an eye or with some other visible disfigurement is such a longstanding ableist trope that it's frustrating to see echoes of it here, even if dimly. I do understand that's he's not a villain by about halfway through, but he begins the book in the position of villain to Echo and her Avicen friend, Ivy, by being part of Ivy's torture in Drakharin hands.
The main storyline involves Echo following clues left behind in a series of objects which turn out to be relevant to one of the other characters. From there it's a lot of running and pining, long on vibes and short on plot (in an enjoyable way). I like how Echo collects words from different languages in order to say a single word to encapsulate some complicated feeling or circumstance. It blends well with her genre-savviness and tendency to reference the many things she read while living in a library.
The chain of requited and unrequited romantic interest between the five main characters (and Echo's quickly sidelined sort-of-boyfriend) is delightfully messy, beginning to explore possible configurations among the main cast before they've even become a group. Echo and Caius are drawn together pretty quickly (for backstory reasons that end up paying off later), to the disappointment of Dorian who has been quietly pining for Caius for years. Luckily, someone else becomes interested in Dorian, and I'm especially looking forward to that playing out more in the next book. I'd be remiss if I failed to mention that Echo is seventeen and Caius is around two hundred years old, with his previous relationship taking place a century ago. Dorian is of a similar age as Caius.
The ending is fine, though a bit abrupt. I'm glad this is the first of a trilogy because it does a lot of work to set up these characters and I'm interested in what they'll do next.
Dorian has one eye, having lost the other by knife in a previous fight. What gradually frustrated me is how often his one-eyed status is brought up in connection with some unrelated negative trait, whether real or imagined. He tortured one of the other characters before they ended up working together, so it's completely understandable that he wouldn't be seen in a positive light and he's in a redemption arc. However, those extremely valid reasons to highlight any of his negative attributes kept being paired in the text with mentions of his disability. It's not a huge thing, but making the villain be the character missing an eye or with some other visible disfigurement is such a longstanding ableist trope that it's frustrating to see echoes of it here, even if dimly. I do understand that's he's not a villain by about halfway through, but he begins the book in the position of villain to Echo and her Avicen friend, Ivy, by being part of Ivy's torture in Drakharin hands.
The main storyline involves Echo following clues left behind in a series of objects which turn out to be relevant to one of the other characters. From there it's a lot of running and pining, long on vibes and short on plot (in an enjoyable way). I like how Echo collects words from different languages in order to say a single word to encapsulate some complicated feeling or circumstance. It blends well with her genre-savviness and tendency to reference the many things she read while living in a library.
The chain of requited and unrequited romantic interest between the five main characters (and Echo's quickly sidelined sort-of-boyfriend) is delightfully messy, beginning to explore possible configurations among the main cast before they've even become a group. Echo and Caius are drawn together pretty quickly (for backstory reasons that end up paying off later), to the disappointment of Dorian who has been quietly pining for Caius for years. Luckily, someone else becomes interested in Dorian, and I'm especially looking forward to that playing out more in the next book. I'd be remiss if I failed to mention that Echo is seventeen and Caius is around two hundred years old, with his previous relationship taking place a century ago. Dorian is of a similar age as Caius.
The ending is fine, though a bit abrupt. I'm glad this is the first of a trilogy because it does a lot of work to set up these characters and I'm interested in what they'll do next.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Fire/Fire injury, Blood, Murder, and Torture
Moderate: Grief, Suicide, Adult/minor relationship, Confinement, Violence, War, Ableism, Cursing, and Kidnapping
Minor: Alcoholism, Drug use, Sexual content, and Vomit
More...