Take a photo of a barcode or cover
2.83 AVERAGE
2.83 AVERAGE
I’m not sure if something was lost in translation or if this one just wasn’t for me?
I found this typical of Japanese fiction in that there was an underlying emotion I couldn't quite place my finger on, but still found it an enjoyable read.
Not knowing much about manzai, shortly after starting the book I felt I needed to know more about this element of Japanese comedy to really understand the story - it helped a lot, and after watching a few YouTube videos I was able to engage more with the characters and their journeys.
Although the book is about a comedy duo, it is a rather maudlin tale and there are moments where I questioned the mental wellbeing of some of the characters, giving them a depth that wasn't always present. By the end of the book, I was invested in their lives and the relationships between them.
Often confusing, but well written and touching, this is a quick and fun read with moments of clarity about the human condition.
Not knowing much about manzai, shortly after starting the book I felt I needed to know more about this element of Japanese comedy to really understand the story - it helped a lot, and after watching a few YouTube videos I was able to engage more with the characters and their journeys.
Although the book is about a comedy duo, it is a rather maudlin tale and there are moments where I questioned the mental wellbeing of some of the characters, giving them a depth that wasn't always present. By the end of the book, I was invested in their lives and the relationships between them.
Often confusing, but well written and touching, this is a quick and fun read with moments of clarity about the human condition.
I'm not giving this a star rating because I don’t want to pull it down any further. This was recommended to me by my Japanese coworker with the warning that I might not like it, and that understanding Japanese manzai comedy might be necessary background knowledge to understand the book. I think I agree. It's very specific to the comedy worlds of Osaka and Tokyo, with a lot of references to specific neighborhoods and streets. Some of the rambling, alcohol-soaked wanderings and musings reminded me a little of Kerouac’s On the Road in tone. It didn’t really resonate with me at this time.
funny
lighthearted
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
emotional
reflective
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
Oddly enough, this story about comedians trying to make their mark in the world while trying to be true to themselves really hit a cord with me in some level. I truly felt the protagonists envy towards people more succesful and funnier than him. I also got his desire for an audience, someone to deliver and perform to. The ending felt super weird to me though, so that’s why I gave it only 3 stars.
funny
inspiring
lighthearted
reflective
relaxing
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
N/A
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Enjoyed quirky-awkward dynamics between a sensei and a junior in their quest to hone the art of Manzai and stamping their mark.
-1 stars because it felt like the story was not going anywhere at times.
-1 stars because it felt like the story was not going anywhere at times.
In Spark, Naoki Matayoshi delves into the world of manzai comedy, unraveling the journey of the protagonist, Tokunaga, as he navigates the intricacies of his comedic career alongside his anti-hero mentor and fellow manzai comedian, Kamiya. Matayoshi crafts a poignant and humorous narrative that explores the essence of comedy, dedication and the pursuit of authenticity.
At the heart of the story lies the profound concept that manzai, and by extension, any form of comedy, isn't merely about generating laughter; it's a reflection of genuine, unfiltered emotions. Spark also explores the interplay between individuality and societal expectations, encapsulating the tension between innovation and conformity. Tokunaga's struggles with public opinion highlight the difficulty of maintaining artistic integrity while also seeking public recognition.
Tokunaga's journey becomes a quest for authenticity, emphasising the importance of embracing one's true self, even in a world that often rewards conformity. Matayoshi's exploration of ambition and dedication underscores the idea that success isn't measured solely by fame or fortune, but by the unwavering commitment to one's craft, regardless of external circumstances. Tokunaga's struggles reflect the perseverance required to chase dreams and make a mark in a world that constantly tests one's mettle.
Through the character of Kamiya, Matayoshi offers profound insights into creativity and pushing boundaries, emphasising the need to challenge norms and embrace radical innovation. Kamiya embodies the spirit of a true artist, consistently exploring uncharted territories and inspiring Tokunaga to break free from mediocrity, despite some alarming hurdles posed by Kamiya's own nonconformist approach to life and work.
The dynamic between Tokunaga and Kamiya is a central theme in the novel. The mentor's belief that everyone is a potential manzai artist, albeit sometimes unaware, illustrates the universality of comedic expression. Kamiya's relentless pursuit of unspoken humor underscores the idea that creativity lies beyond personal talent and demands pushing one's limits.
Spark is a testament to the courage required to pursue unconventional paths, as Tokunaga and his partner navigate a career where failure and vulnerability are constants. The novella encapsulates the dichotomy of comedic pursuit—simultaneously exhilarating and terrifying—as the characters face their fears of rejection and strive for authenticity. The story of Tokunaga and Kamiya—on their path to becoming manzai artists—is also an open invitation to embrace the authenticity of our aspirations, challenge societal norms, and persevere in the face of adversity.
At the heart of the story lies the profound concept that manzai, and by extension, any form of comedy, isn't merely about generating laughter; it's a reflection of genuine, unfiltered emotions. Spark also explores the interplay between individuality and societal expectations, encapsulating the tension between innovation and conformity. Tokunaga's struggles with public opinion highlight the difficulty of maintaining artistic integrity while also seeking public recognition.
Tokunaga's journey becomes a quest for authenticity, emphasising the importance of embracing one's true self, even in a world that often rewards conformity. Matayoshi's exploration of ambition and dedication underscores the idea that success isn't measured solely by fame or fortune, but by the unwavering commitment to one's craft, regardless of external circumstances. Tokunaga's struggles reflect the perseverance required to chase dreams and make a mark in a world that constantly tests one's mettle.
Through the character of Kamiya, Matayoshi offers profound insights into creativity and pushing boundaries, emphasising the need to challenge norms and embrace radical innovation. Kamiya embodies the spirit of a true artist, consistently exploring uncharted territories and inspiring Tokunaga to break free from mediocrity, despite some alarming hurdles posed by Kamiya's own nonconformist approach to life and work.
The dynamic between Tokunaga and Kamiya is a central theme in the novel. The mentor's belief that everyone is a potential manzai artist, albeit sometimes unaware, illustrates the universality of comedic expression. Kamiya's relentless pursuit of unspoken humor underscores the idea that creativity lies beyond personal talent and demands pushing one's limits.
Spark is a testament to the courage required to pursue unconventional paths, as Tokunaga and his partner navigate a career where failure and vulnerability are constants. The novella encapsulates the dichotomy of comedic pursuit—simultaneously exhilarating and terrifying—as the characters face their fears of rejection and strive for authenticity. The story of Tokunaga and Kamiya—on their path to becoming manzai artists—is also an open invitation to embrace the authenticity of our aspirations, challenge societal norms, and persevere in the face of adversity.
When I first started reading this book, I thought this book would be about an aspiring stand-up comedian's struggle on his way up. But pretty soon it became all about his senpai, Kamiya. 70% of the story is about Kamiya and the protagonist, Tokunaga's times spent together as senpai and kohai. However, there wasn't much plot to begin with. The story is very much character driven and quiet. Not much happens. Not saying I don't like/read character heavy books, but if you're looking for a plot heavy book, this is not for you.
Around 90% of the book, the climactic incident where Tokunaga and his partner, Yamashita, perform their last ever performance, I liked that moment. That moment somehow made the entire book and its theme coherent and cognizant. However, around 95% of the book, a stunt pulled by Kamiya gave a bitter, nasty taste in my palate. It was gross and offensive and pathetic and just straight-out transphobic. Tokunaga's reaction and response to this warmed my heart for him and confirmed my dislike and loathing toward Kamiya. This guy is straight up transphobic.
Anyway, giving it 2 stars not just because of that stunt, but also because this book tried to make the readers empathize Kamiya (when it should have focused more on Tokunaga), and instead made me hate him even more. He's a parasitic, irresponsible, delusional jerk. I'm glad Maki and Yuki didn't end up with this vampire.
Around 90% of the book, the climactic incident where Tokunaga and his partner, Yamashita, perform their last ever performance, I liked that moment. That moment somehow made the entire book and its theme coherent and cognizant. However, around 95% of the book, a stunt pulled by Kamiya gave a bitter, nasty taste in my palate. It was gross and offensive and pathetic and just straight-out transphobic. Tokunaga's reaction and response to this warmed my heart for him and confirmed my dislike and loathing toward Kamiya. This guy is straight up transphobic.
Anyway, giving it 2 stars not just because of that stunt, but also because this book tried to make the readers empathize Kamiya (when it should have focused more on Tokunaga), and instead made me hate him even more. He's a parasitic, irresponsible, delusional jerk. I'm glad Maki and Yuki didn't end up with this vampire.
emotional
funny
reflective
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No