Scan barcode
hschlecht's review against another edition
dark
emotional
sad
4.0
Content Warnings
Minor: Mass/school shootings, Racism, Murder, Death, and Gun violence
ashylibrarian's review against another edition
challenging
dark
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
***EDIT***
Truth be told, I guess I am just dumb. I did not realize that the NetGalley was only 80% of the audiobook (because I did not see it listed anywhere as such...).
I just finished the full version and it definitely was worth it! I am so glad I finally read two reviews that stated NetGalley only gave 80% of the audiobook out and don't have to be frustrated with the ending anymore.
This is a great book. It very much gives The Hate U Give meets One of Us is Lying. Nick Brooks really draws attention to the despicable systemic racism and inequality that too many young black and brown folks (especially male-presenting) face in the educational system. Brooks created more than just a YA mystery - Brooks created a call-out to systemic inequality and racism.
Brooks also touches on pretty much everything a young adult mystery should touch on, and let me just say the audiobook was killer. The full cast is phenomenal and the added sound effects really elevated the scenes for me.
I had my assumptions about who had done it about a third of the way through, but with all of the distractions and perspectives, I could never be 100% sure. I think that part of this was due to all of the perspective changes. I don't often love a book that changes perspectives so much because it feels like it is easy to become lost, but the way in which Brooks wrote the multiple perspectives was smart and intentional. And there is so much depth and complexity to each of the main characters. This created a seamless flow through the characters without losing the importance of the plot.
I am very much so looking forward to recommending this to readers!
CAN IGNORE THIS PART OF MY FIRST REVIEW - JUST KEEPING FOR MY RECORDS.
**Thank you, NetGalley and the publisher, for giving me an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.**
This book...
This book was good. It very much gives The Hate U Give meets One of Us is Lying. This book really draws attention to the despicable systemic racism and inequality that too many black and brown folks (especially male-presenting) face. Nick Brooks touches on pretty much everything a young adult mystery/thriller should touch on, and the audiobook was killer with sound effects. This really elevated the interview scenes for me.
I often don't love a book that changes perspectives so much, but the way in which Brooks wrote the multiple perspectives was smart and intentional. This created a seamless flow through the characters without losing the importance of the plot.
But y'all...I listened to the ending of this book FOUR TIMES to see if I missed something. I thought maybe I just didn't understand something or that I fell asleep during an important time in the audiobook or that maybe because I was listening to an eGalley from NetGalley that part of the book was missing. But...I don't think so. I think it just ends. Abruptly. Please tell me if I'm wrong. I was so invested in the entire book until the last 5 minutes and it kind of ruined a big part of it for me. How did everything come together like that?Was it Stanely Ennis (SP)?? Was it someone that Ennis knew? Is there more to the story? It just seems so weird to me that the story ends on a cliffhanger with the idea that this is a stand-alone novel. Someone explain!
I think teen readers will like this book, but if the ending is actually the one I listened to, I think they may be frustrated, as well. I am interested to see more reviews once the book is published.
Truth be told, I guess I am just dumb. I did not realize that the NetGalley was only 80% of the audiobook (because I did not see it listed anywhere as such...).
I just finished the full version and it definitely was worth it! I am so glad I finally read two reviews that stated NetGalley only gave 80% of the audiobook out and don't have to be frustrated with the ending anymore.
This is a great book. It very much gives The Hate U Give meets One of Us is Lying. Nick Brooks really draws attention to the despicable systemic racism and inequality that too many young black and brown folks (especially male-presenting) face in the educational system. Brooks created more than just a YA mystery - Brooks created a call-out to systemic inequality and racism.
Brooks also touches on pretty much everything a young adult mystery should touch on, and let me just say the audiobook was killer. The full cast is phenomenal and the added sound effects really elevated the scenes for me.
I had my assumptions about who had done it about a third of the way through, but with all of the distractions and perspectives, I could never be 100% sure. I think that part of this was due to all of the perspective changes. I don't often love a book that changes perspectives so much because it feels like it is easy to become lost, but the way in which Brooks wrote the multiple perspectives was smart and intentional. And there is so much depth and complexity to each of the main characters. This created a seamless flow through the characters without losing the importance of the plot.
I am very much so looking forward to recommending this to readers!
CAN IGNORE THIS PART OF MY FIRST REVIEW - JUST KEEPING FOR MY RECORDS.
**Thank you, NetGalley and the publisher, for giving me an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.**
This book...
This book was good. It very much gives The Hate U Give meets One of Us is Lying. This book really draws attention to the despicable systemic racism and inequality that too many black and brown folks (especially male-presenting) face. Nick Brooks touches on pretty much everything a young adult mystery/thriller should touch on, and the audiobook was killer with sound effects. This really elevated the interview scenes for me.
I often don't love a book that changes perspectives so much, but the way in which Brooks wrote the multiple perspectives was smart and intentional. This created a seamless flow through the characters without losing the importance of the plot.
But y'all...I listened to the ending of this book FOUR TIMES to see if I missed something. I thought maybe I just didn't understand something or that I fell asleep during an important time in the audiobook or that maybe because I was listening to an eGalley from NetGalley that part of the book was missing. But...I don't think so. I think it just ends. Abruptly. Please tell me if I'm wrong. I was so invested in the entire book until the last 5 minutes and it kind of ruined a big part of it for me. How did everything come together like that?
I think teen readers will like this book, but if the ending is actually the one I listened to, I think they may be frustrated, as well. I am interested to see more reviews once the book is published.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death and Racism
Moderate: Violence, Gun violence, and Emotional abuse
crazybookishcool's review against another edition
challenging
dark
emotional
funny
inspiring
sad
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Bullying, Blood, and Murder
bookswithca's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
hopeful
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Gun violence and Racism
Moderate: Gun violence, Murder, Alcoholism, Gaslighting, Physical abuse, Racism, Classism, Bullying, Addiction, Blood, Stalking, Death, Injury/Injury detail, and Violence
natashaleighton_'s review against another edition
dark
emotional
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
4.0
An unputdownable YA thriller that expertly uses multiple POVs (from main characters, secondary sources and even the media) into an intrigue-filled and plot twisty murder mystery that highlights the systemic inequality in both the criminal justice and education systems towards boys of colour —and hopefully see readers reevaluate and spark conversations around the harmful effects these biases have in our societies.
It follows three teens whose lives are irrevocably changed when their school’s principal is shot to death and they’re all named as suspects in his murder. In order to clear their names, the three boys (Trey, J.B and Ramón) band together to track down the killer before they find themselves wrongfully charged for the crime.
This was such an evocative and incredibly moving story that I found myself thoroughly and emotionally invested in!
J.B, Trey and Ramón were all incredibly well written characters whose lives I became inextricably concerned for and felt the multimedia aspects and interviews with students, teachers and local members of the wider community gave a richer and more realistic portrayal to how investigations like this actually work.
With widespread media coverage and the age old rumour mill acting as judge & jury in the court of opinion, able to spread misleading narratives long before a suspect can even plead their case.
I loved all three boys and really enjoyed getting to see their experiences in life, but seeing how the system was failing them (with soo many people in positions of authority giving up on them before the murder) was incredibly heartbreaking. The details into their home lives and the dreams they have for their futures was truly lovely to see and really brought each boy to life.
J.B is the quiet one that keeps his head down and works hard to earn that promise scholarship for university and make his mum proud. But the suffocating, prison-like conditions of the school make things much more challenging, his only light right now is Keyana—the smartest and prettiest girl in he know (and who he’s had a crush on forever) has finally agreed to date him.
Trey is the charismatic basketball star and a bit of a joker despite having such a tough uncle, who expects nothing but excellence from Trey on an off the court. But someone’s it’s a role that Trey finds too overwhelming to maintain.
And Ramón is a culinary wizard who unlike his beloved cousin Cesar—the leader of the Dioses del Humo gang (who’s been trying to recruit him), Ramón only dreams of starting his own restaurant who helps shoulder some of his grandmother’s financial burdens by selling pupusas at school.
I enjoyed the murder mystery sleuthing aspects and felt the ending was genuinely satisfying, in terms of finding answers —I just wish the investigation aspect was little longer as given how pacey the book was, it flew by soo quickly.
Nick Brooks’ film making skills were also very visible in the seamless transition between tenses and POVs, as well as in the visual descriptions—which were wonderfully,emotionally visceral—and I definitely hope to see this adapted on the big screen at some point in the future.
Overall, a moving and incredibly enjoyable YA thriller that you won’t forget any time soon—I definitely recommend to fans of Angie Thomas and Holly Jackson.
Also, a huge thank you to MacMillan for the physical proof.
It follows three teens whose lives are irrevocably changed when their school’s principal is shot to death and they’re all named as suspects in his murder. In order to clear their names, the three boys (Trey, J.B and Ramón) band together to track down the killer before they find themselves wrongfully charged for the crime.
This was such an evocative and incredibly moving story that I found myself thoroughly and emotionally invested in!
J.B, Trey and Ramón were all incredibly well written characters whose lives I became inextricably concerned for and felt the multimedia aspects and interviews with students, teachers and local members of the wider community gave a richer and more realistic portrayal to how investigations like this actually work.
With widespread media coverage and the age old rumour mill acting as judge & jury in the court of opinion, able to spread misleading narratives long before a suspect can even plead their case.
I loved all three boys and really enjoyed getting to see their experiences in life, but seeing how the system was failing them (with soo many people in positions of authority giving up on them before the murder) was incredibly heartbreaking. The details into their home lives and the dreams they have for their futures was truly lovely to see and really brought each boy to life.
J.B is the quiet one that keeps his head down and works hard to earn that promise scholarship for university and make his mum proud. But the suffocating, prison-like conditions of the school make things much more challenging, his only light right now is Keyana—the smartest and prettiest girl in he know (and who he’s had a crush on forever) has finally agreed to date him.
Trey is the charismatic basketball star and a bit of a joker despite having such a tough uncle, who expects nothing but excellence from Trey on an off the court. But someone’s it’s a role that Trey finds too overwhelming to maintain.
And Ramón is a culinary wizard who unlike his beloved cousin Cesar—the leader of the Dioses del Humo gang (who’s been trying to recruit him), Ramón only dreams of starting his own restaurant who helps shoulder some of his grandmother’s financial burdens by selling pupusas at school.
I enjoyed the murder mystery sleuthing aspects and felt the ending was genuinely satisfying, in terms of finding answers —I just wish the investigation aspect was little longer as given how pacey the book was, it flew by soo quickly.
Nick Brooks’ film making skills were also very visible in the seamless transition between tenses and POVs, as well as in the visual descriptions—which were wonderfully,emotionally visceral—and I definitely hope to see this adapted on the big screen at some point in the future.
Overall, a moving and incredibly enjoyable YA thriller that you won’t forget any time soon—I definitely recommend to fans of Angie Thomas and Holly Jackson.
Also, a huge thank you to MacMillan for the physical proof.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Murder, Racism, and Child abuse
Moderate: Cursing, Alcoholism, Gun violence, and Classism
caseythereader's review
dark
emotional
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
Thanks to Macmillan for the free advance copy of this book.
- I blew through PROMISE BOYS in one sitting. The format of the book - switching between the three boys' perspectives along with commentary from others in the community, news clippings, etc. - made the book move super fast as I was eager to gather the clues with the protagonists.
- You'll find yourself wanting to shout at the book as each boy's story is told, wanting to grab the adults and make them pay attention to what is actually going on in these kids' lives. It's a really heavy book, despite the speed at which it moves.
- I blew through PROMISE BOYS in one sitting. The format of the book - switching between the three boys' perspectives along with commentary from others in the community, news clippings, etc. - made the book move super fast as I was eager to gather the clues with the protagonists.
- You'll find yourself wanting to shout at the book as each boy's story is told, wanting to grab the adults and make them pay attention to what is actually going on in these kids' lives. It's a really heavy book, despite the speed at which it moves.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Cursing, Death, Injury/Injury detail, Racism, Violence, Blood, Child abuse, Gun violence, Murder, and Physical abuse
More...