Reviews

More Than Her by Jay McLean

loribelle3's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Genre- new adult romance

Characters- I enjoyed Amanda. She was a tough girl, shook off what life has thrown at her, and has a definite potty mouth. She's a bit different, at first, than some of the other YA female heroines. The author definitely builds sympathy for Logan, because of his childhood. I hate how he continues to be scared of commitment with Amanda. The supporting characters mostly add to the story, although there are parts where you can see their spin off stories coming.

Style- I snickered and laughed out loud several times. I loved the witty banter between characters, and sometimes even the thoughts in their heads. Layooked, anyone?! POV alternated between Logan's and Amanda's.

Errors-ugh, more than 20, punctuation, capitalization, words.....

Overall- cliffhanger. Sad face emoticon. As much as I enjoyed following their story, I wish it had ended differently. I'm not a fan of cliffhangers like this, especially when it feels like to me they have been through enough. But, since their story is not finished, I shall read on!

lisamh68's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I read book 1 a few years ago but it was one of those books that sticks with you.. This group of friends continue on. This is the story about Amanda and Logan. There is so much back and forth.. Will they end up together? You will need to read this book and then More Than Him to find out.. Good story..

thaictaff's review against another edition

Go to review page

dude seriously i like logan and all but he's such and asshole and amanda is stupid af, like seriously get over and move on already. there were some nice quotes and scenes but after the whole 'i'd stay here for hours thinking about you' i was done so yep, dropping this shit.

smitch29's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Overall, this was a good book, that was a bit long and filled with too many grammatical errors, but still managed to make me want to read the next in the series.
So quick synopsis, this is Amanda and Logan's story. After meeting this characters a little in the first novel of the series, we find out there was more going on during that time frame than we got to see. In book 1, we saw Logan's man-whorey ways a fair bit, but Amanda only popped up in one scene. In this book, we get caught up on just what happens right after Amanda's appearance at Mikayla's family's wake. We see how Logan tried to woo Amanda a bit before getting scared and backing off. After over a year of trying to run into her again, his wish comes true and he talks his way back into her life. Only this time, Amanda has been through the wringer in the last year or so, which has made her trust a whole lot harder to earn.
Over half the story is this give and take became Amanda's trust issues and Logan's fear of hurting Amanda one way or another. Eventually, they settle into a routine where they are happy together. Naturally, this is a perfect opportunity for all of Logan's past demons to come back and haunt him. In a twistedly poetic way, it is sort of perfect that these demons are, in a way, brought around thanks to the same demon-bringer of the first book, Megan (Mikayla's ex-best friend
Spoilerwho slept with Mikayla's boyfriend and helped get her family killed; also, long lost sister of Logan
).
The ending actually surprised me because it was a bit of a cliffhanger. It wasn't all that bad as cliffhangers go (other authors could learn something about how a cliffhanger ought to be used from this book). There was an uphill slope right before the cliff's drop off, but rather the story was already starting to wind downwards when the cliff showed up and got me interested in the next book.
SpoilerSPOILER: the cliffhanger: so the demons that showed up were Logan and Megan's dad and Megan's ex-boyfriend, and they beat up Logan and messed up Amanda a bit. Megan's ex tried to rape Amanda, but things were stopped before that happened. The next thing we find out is that Logan never visits Amanda in the hospital because he is done with her from what we assume is his fear of his past hurting Amanda. She goes to confront him and pleads for him to fight for her and their relationship, but instead he does nothing. His parting words were to tell her he loves her. The story then all of the sudden ends 5 weeks later with Amanda trying to move on and Logan doing who knows what while traveling the world.

The cliffhanger surprised me because I didn't expect a second book from these characters because this was already a pretty darn long story. Their give and take about trust issues and overcoming fears that I mention before that took over half the book, was a bit long and exhausting. I even ended up having to stop reading and pick up another book. I am actually a bit glad though that I chose to finish reading this one. I don't know if the writing was too long and poor and redundant or if I just was in more of a mood to read something edgier. I suppose I'll never really know.
Granted, the story was still intriguing and had a great mix of characters. They were all loveable but with their own personalities; it was just a pool of quirky support, it was an amusing array of flawed and humorous personalities.
For the quality of the story telling, the grammatical errors littered throughout this novel was atrocious. There were too many ridiculous mistakes that it made me question if the author just said the book aloud and had an eight-year-old transcribe it for them. I get that this wasn't a big publisher-production type of book, but it still makes it hard for me to take this book seriously when it barely seems polished at all.

supergirls_2008's review

Go to review page

4.0

I liked More Than This, but More Than Her was even better! Logan was a great lead. I was not a huge fan of him at the beginning of this book and I think his character development was pretty cliche and spotty. But what I really liked about this book was the ending! Holy! A few pages to go and that comes out of nowhere. Warning: Huge cliffhanger, but the story is continued in book 3

bookishplansandthings's review

Go to review page

4.0

4.25 *GASP!!!!*

jenrich26's review

Go to review page

5.0

I'm really enjoying this series and getting more of the story from different points of view and as the present moves forward hearing updates about people from past books. I loved Logan, even as the jerk from the first book. I wasn't as much as a fan of Amanda as I was of Mickey. I still couldn't put it down and feel like I'll finished the next 2 in the next 2 days.

halbloewenherz's review

Go to review page

3.0

I liked the second part of the series, which is a prequel to More Than This, much more than the first book. You get more background on the characters and they're not as ridiculously jealous as Jake in the first volume. Nevertheless, I found the plot repeating itself in many places. And even though I knew - after the surprise in the first part of the series - that sexual descriptions were included, I always found them described the same way. All in all fast and easy to read - and I can smile about so much drama in just one circle of friends.

thatrandomdancer's review

Go to review page

emotional funny inspiring lighthearted sad medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? No

5.0


Expand filter menu Content Warnings