Reviews with content warning for Transphobia - A Strange and Stubborn Endurance

Reviews tagging 'Transphobia'

A Strange and Stubborn Endurance by Foz Meadows

67 reviews

sabertoothjello's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark emotional funny hopeful mysterious tense fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

5.0

Content Warnings

osladek's review

Go to review page

adventurous emotional tense fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

3.0

I really enjoyed a lot of this book, but there were too many mistakes and overall bad writing choices to rate it highly. I enjoyed the characters and diversity the most. Having a character communicate in sign language, multiple nonbinary people, and other queer people and POC characters was great to read. I think all the characters felt like real people with realistic dialogue. I enjoyed the lyrical prose and the food descriptions. I think the romance was well written but also left a bit to desire.
For parts that I didn't enjoy, the main stumbling block was the plot. I haven't read such a terribly written murder mystery in a while, but this one took the cake for most predictable and horribly written mystery. The pace has a lot to do with this, the book takes place over a week when we get to the new country our main character is traveling to. Because of this, about 50 things happen every single day and I kept getting whiplash when the writing would say something like, "All this on day 1." Because of the plot whipping by, you don't get any character development, no subtle hinting at angst in the romance, no real story building of the plot, not even a second to breathe in the new world you're in, despite the page length being at 544 pages. This resulted in a horrible mystery that I predicted from the beginning and our two main characters fumbling the entire time trying to react to one plot event before being thrust into another life changing event.
Another issue I have is the decision to write an explicit rape scene and continue to graphically reference it. I think especially since this is fantasy and the book seems to be trying to be light-hearted, it's a confusing choice. If this was trying to be a dark fantasy I might understand it better, but it seems to straddle the two at the same time in a seemingly useless way. I also have conflicted feelings about if we need explicit and graphic SA scenes in any media. There is proven research that shows depicting SA can lead to more violence, regardless of the original media being against it. This also just feels like it unnecessarily causes harm to the readers who might have a history or know someone who has been an SA survivor. I'm not saying that we shouldn't have SA survivors as characters, or never discuss it, but I think this could've been written in a less explicit way that caused less harm and still had the same effect. The book also eventually treated the main character's trauma as almost non-existent when it was so extremely recent to the end of the story.
Overall, I think I will read the sequel since I enjoyed enough of the book to breeze through it and enjoy the characters.

Content Warnings

beetitnerds's review

Go to review page

mysterious medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

3.0

Overall: I don't regret reading this book and I'll probably recommend it to people who are comfortable with the content warning topics. I wish the execution was better on an otherwise fun sorta-court romance/drama plot

However: The pacing made it difficult to enjoy either the romance or the mystery. All the characters are enjoyable, so I was happy to read them making friends and falling in love. But the 'falling in love' itself felt forced. Not that chemistry wasn't there, but that the bulk of the romance came from the fact the leads are in a queer romance, and therefore must be in love by the end of the book. It would have been nice to see their romance pushed off until the sequels. The mystery wasn't a real mystery as much as a series of things that happened over the course of a week that are solved when the main characters eventually- literally- accidentally stumble into the villain doing a full monologue. The reader doesn't have a chance to try and solve the mystery themself because we don't know anything about the world until specific details are told to us the moment they become relevant. The villain wasn't exactly a surprise, because it follows pretty standard story conventions, but the reveal wasn't satisfying enough to make the lead-up enjoyable. The villain essentially stares at the camera and explains every plot detail, with the heros occasionally popping in to remind us they're in the room. Even though I really liked each character, there's no actual character development for anyone. Everyone ends exactly where they started, with the exception of one of the main characters, who technically learns to be more open with his affections, but who also doesn't really have a problem with public affection except in occasional offhand remarks about how it would be scandalous in his home-country. I don't want to read about a main character who's homophobic or ableist or classist or sexist or any other version of bigot. But since we're told about how terrible his home-country is, and how every other person from that country is some degree of bigot almost without exception, AND the main character frequently apologizes on behalf of the culture he was raised in, it makes it really weird that he doesn't actually NEED to do any growing. Even the times he does 'mess up', which I'd argue are usually situations in which he thinks he's messed up because of miscommunication and really hasn't, he immediately realizes his mistakes, often as he's making them, and immediately apologizes and corrects himself. This is a book where all the characters assume he's a bigot and a third of his interactions are him explaining about how He's Actually An Ally.

All that being said: The action scenes were fun. I wish the action wasn't left to the last handful of pages, because it was thrilling. All of the characters, even the villains, were very fun to read, and likable. I really liked the focus on friendships, especially pre-existing friendships, ESPECIALLY subverting the Hot Jealous Ex trope. The casual inclusion and diversity of marginalized identities in the book was refreshing. No one felt like a stereotype or a token character. The dialogue always felt authentic, and character choices and motivations always felt realistic and understandable. The magic system and different cultures around it was also fun, though woefully underutilized. The mixed use of first and third person was fun and helped differentiate between the POV characters. The writing, itself, was beautiful. The plot twist at the VERY end-

That the villain's plan was totally unnecessary and her plan was always going to cause her own downfall

- was fun! I think it's because it was set up earlier in the story in a way none of the mystery parts were.

Content Warnings

lethargicbumblebee's review

Go to review page

adventurous emotional mysterious slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

2.75

I was very disappointed. I found the relationship between the two main characters compelling, but I found a lot about their and other characters' reactions to events so unrealistic that it took me out of the story. There are so many violent and threatening events in a short period of time and no one responds by locking doors or hiring/assigning additional guards to the targeted people. The characters, completely traumatized by one early event, seem almost immune to later violent happenings--they SAY they find it distressing to be attacked or find dead bodies, but they don't demonstrate it in their actions, they joke and flirt and laugh and have breakfasts and parties minutes after these horrible things happen, apparently unaffected. I just couldn't believe the characters unfortunately, as much as I wanted to be invested in their relationship, so that kind of ruined the book for me.

Content Warnings