Scan barcode
areader09's review
3.0
3.5 stars, rounded down. Like any collection, some essays are better than others.
It was interesting to read this collection, from 2006, in 2020. And to reflect on how different travel, and the world in general, was at the this time. Of course now in 2020, travel is not possible. But that issue aside, travel in 2006 (or, in 2005, the year these articles were written) is quite different from now. The first iPhone was not even released yet, so it was not common to have a GPS in your pocket at all times. The US was in the throws of two major wars in Iraq and Afghanistan (this fact alone makes the Wakhan Corridor article all the more remarkable).
Some of the articles rubbed me the wrong way, probably mostly: The New Mecca (published in GQ, about Dubai) seemed to be written by a person who is, at best naive and at worst willfully ignorant of all of the problems that plague Dubai, forced labor being only one. The author also describes it as tolerant and inclusive, which....I guess it depends on which countries UAE is being compared to. Forced labor issues are mentioned, to be sure, but appear to be not taken seriously/dismissed quickly. To be honest, I found all three of the GQ articles to be among the weakest/most problematic in the collection.
While Outside Magazine and The New Yorker are both well represented, I appreciate the range of publications represented in this collection, including a number of publications I've never heard of.
My favorite articles in this collection include:
Ain't it Just Grand
A Short Walk in the Wakhan Corridor
Passing Through
Turbulence
A Peaceful Angle
It was interesting to read this collection, from 2006, in 2020. And to reflect on how different travel, and the world in general, was at the this time. Of course now in 2020, travel is not possible. But that issue aside, travel in 2006 (or, in 2005, the year these articles were written) is quite different from now. The first iPhone was not even released yet, so it was not common to have a GPS in your pocket at all times. The US was in the throws of two major wars in Iraq and Afghanistan (this fact alone makes the Wakhan Corridor article all the more remarkable).
Some of the articles rubbed me the wrong way, probably mostly: The New Mecca (published in GQ, about Dubai) seemed to be written by a person who is, at best naive and at worst willfully ignorant of all of the problems that plague Dubai, forced labor being only one. The author also describes it as tolerant and inclusive, which....I guess it depends on which countries UAE is being compared to. Forced labor issues are mentioned, to be sure, but appear to be not taken seriously/dismissed quickly. To be honest, I found all three of the GQ articles to be among the weakest/most problematic in the collection.
While Outside Magazine and The New Yorker are both well represented, I appreciate the range of publications represented in this collection, including a number of publications I've never heard of.
My favorite articles in this collection include:
Ain't it Just Grand
A Short Walk in the Wakhan Corridor
Passing Through
Turbulence
A Peaceful Angle
christythelibrarian's review
5.0
Here is a rundown of the essays in the 2006 compilation that stand out in my mind:
“After the Fall” by Tom Bissell and Morgan Meis
In this essay, the authors visit Vietnam, a week in advance of the 30th anniversary of South Vietnam’s surrender. Things go wrong for the journalists when they visit a few too many dissidents. The end of the article finds one of them stumbling around Saigon while the celebrations commence, his companions having been forced to leave the country.
“The Discreet Charm of the Zurich Bourgeoisie” by Alain de Botton
A sample quote: "Attractive girls born outside Switzerland are particularly against going to Zurich. Such girls (and modern science has proved this) prefer Los Angeles or Sydney. Even if they are looking for something Protestant and homey, they choose Antwerp or Copenhagen instead." (p. 71-72)
“Ain’t It Just Grand?” by Kevin Fedarko
This was a lovely essay where Fedarko travels on the Colorado River through the Grand Canyon – a three week journey. Their lead guide is a conservation legend: Martin Litton, who fought plans to dam the Colorado River, helped champion the cause of the redwood forests, and also set up this unique whitewater company in the Grand Canyon, which uses wooden dories instead of inflated rafts. The essay describes the journey and also profiles Litton.
“The Price of Paradise” by Caitlin Flanagan
This was a hilarious New Yorker piece about the author’s fascination with Hawaiian vacations, despite being vaguely disappointed each time. The essay particularly focuses on a recent stay at the Grand Wailea, where the battle for deckchairs is fierce.
“Where They Love Americans . . . for a Living” by Sean Flynn
This is one of my favorite essays. Flynn starts out deceptively nonchalant in describing the prostitution scene in Costa Rica, the American men trolling the bars. Then Flynn suddenly spins the narrative around and shows some teeth, shredding into the male fantasies that have branded Costa Rica as a ’sex haven.’
“Out of Ohio” by Ian Frazier
This essay is a wonderfully written ode to the author’s hometown of Hudson, Ohio. When he describes the days spent there after his college graduation, he captures the feel of summer and transition. He also describes hitchhiking to Chicago, Florida and New York.
“A Short Walk in the Wakhan Corridor” by Mark Jenkins
One of the adventurer tales in the compilation, Jenkins’ essay describes his travels in the Wakhan Corridor, a northern valley in Afghanistan. It used to be part of the famous Silk Road. Greg Mortenson (author of Three Cups of Tea) is a friend of Mark Jenkins and is present for some of the journey.
“XXXXL” by Michael Paterniti
In rural Ukraine, there lives a giant – a man who is over eight feet tall thanks to a botched surgery in his childhood. Fascinated by a news story about this man, Leonid Stadnik, the author decides to travel to Ukraine to interview him. The travel narrative within the travel narrative is the story of Leonid’s only trip outside of Ukraine – a short visit to Germany. It is a gentle, haunting story and I was left with the image of the giant in his apple orchard “because only the apples and the beets don’t care what size you are.”
“The New Mecca” by George Saunders
The setting is Dubai, United Arab Emirates. I love how Saunders does not settle for the easy story here. He is in awe of the excessive luxury of the place but also aware of the immigrant labor that runs the city. It’s a kaleidoscopic piece: each segment is a newly shaken perspective.
“Airborne” by Sally Shivnan
Anyone who likes looking out the window in flight will love this essay. Shivnan muses on how the aerial view of the United States affects how she views the country.
Quote: "… even Manhattan, viewed from the right altitude, is defined not by its population density but by the chunk of rock between two rivers that it stands on; it is an island with a city on it, not a city on an island." (p. 273)
“A Peaceful Angle” by Patrick Symmes
Symmes describes a fishing trip in the Mongolian wild. The sought-after prize in their catch-and-release fishing is the elusive, large taimen, from the salmon family. Jim Nachtwey, a veteran war photographer is one of Symmes’ fellow anglers and the essay is also a little bit about him.
“After the Fall” by Tom Bissell and Morgan Meis
In this essay, the authors visit Vietnam, a week in advance of the 30th anniversary of South Vietnam’s surrender. Things go wrong for the journalists when they visit a few too many dissidents. The end of the article finds one of them stumbling around Saigon while the celebrations commence, his companions having been forced to leave the country.
“The Discreet Charm of the Zurich Bourgeoisie” by Alain de Botton
A sample quote: "Attractive girls born outside Switzerland are particularly against going to Zurich. Such girls (and modern science has proved this) prefer Los Angeles or Sydney. Even if they are looking for something Protestant and homey, they choose Antwerp or Copenhagen instead." (p. 71-72)
“Ain’t It Just Grand?” by Kevin Fedarko
This was a lovely essay where Fedarko travels on the Colorado River through the Grand Canyon – a three week journey. Their lead guide is a conservation legend: Martin Litton, who fought plans to dam the Colorado River, helped champion the cause of the redwood forests, and also set up this unique whitewater company in the Grand Canyon, which uses wooden dories instead of inflated rafts. The essay describes the journey and also profiles Litton.
“The Price of Paradise” by Caitlin Flanagan
This was a hilarious New Yorker piece about the author’s fascination with Hawaiian vacations, despite being vaguely disappointed each time. The essay particularly focuses on a recent stay at the Grand Wailea, where the battle for deckchairs is fierce.
“Where They Love Americans . . . for a Living” by Sean Flynn
This is one of my favorite essays. Flynn starts out deceptively nonchalant in describing the prostitution scene in Costa Rica, the American men trolling the bars. Then Flynn suddenly spins the narrative around and shows some teeth, shredding into the male fantasies that have branded Costa Rica as a ’sex haven.’
“Out of Ohio” by Ian Frazier
This essay is a wonderfully written ode to the author’s hometown of Hudson, Ohio. When he describes the days spent there after his college graduation, he captures the feel of summer and transition. He also describes hitchhiking to Chicago, Florida and New York.
“A Short Walk in the Wakhan Corridor” by Mark Jenkins
One of the adventurer tales in the compilation, Jenkins’ essay describes his travels in the Wakhan Corridor, a northern valley in Afghanistan. It used to be part of the famous Silk Road. Greg Mortenson (author of Three Cups of Tea) is a friend of Mark Jenkins and is present for some of the journey.
“XXXXL” by Michael Paterniti
In rural Ukraine, there lives a giant – a man who is over eight feet tall thanks to a botched surgery in his childhood. Fascinated by a news story about this man, Leonid Stadnik, the author decides to travel to Ukraine to interview him. The travel narrative within the travel narrative is the story of Leonid’s only trip outside of Ukraine – a short visit to Germany. It is a gentle, haunting story and I was left with the image of the giant in his apple orchard “because only the apples and the beets don’t care what size you are.”
“The New Mecca” by George Saunders
The setting is Dubai, United Arab Emirates. I love how Saunders does not settle for the easy story here. He is in awe of the excessive luxury of the place but also aware of the immigrant labor that runs the city. It’s a kaleidoscopic piece: each segment is a newly shaken perspective.
“Airborne” by Sally Shivnan
Anyone who likes looking out the window in flight will love this essay. Shivnan muses on how the aerial view of the United States affects how she views the country.
Quote: "… even Manhattan, viewed from the right altitude, is defined not by its population density but by the chunk of rock between two rivers that it stands on; it is an island with a city on it, not a city on an island." (p. 273)
“A Peaceful Angle” by Patrick Symmes
Symmes describes a fishing trip in the Mongolian wild. The sought-after prize in their catch-and-release fishing is the elusive, large taimen, from the salmon family. Jim Nachtwey, a veteran war photographer is one of Symmes’ fellow anglers and the essay is also a little bit about him.
auntstacey's review
4.0
I enjoy this series quite a bit. A lot of the essays are about places I'll never visit so it's a great way to get a view of them.
torts's review against another edition
4.0
Funny is good. Like David Sedaris. Amusing and insightful is best.
laurafox's review against another edition
4.0
My favorite pieces from this volume:
Michael Behar, "The Selling of the Last Savage" (Indonesia)
Sean Flynn, "Where They Love Americans...for a Living" (Costa Rica)
Pico Iyer, "Our Lady of Lawson" (Japan)
George Saunders, "The New Mecca" (Dubai)
David Sedaris, "Turbulence" (air travel)
Gary Shteyngart, "A St. Petersburg Christmas" (Russia)
Michael Behar, "The Selling of the Last Savage" (Indonesia)
Sean Flynn, "Where They Love Americans...for a Living" (Costa Rica)
Pico Iyer, "Our Lady of Lawson" (Japan)
George Saunders, "The New Mecca" (Dubai)
David Sedaris, "Turbulence" (air travel)
Gary Shteyngart, "A St. Petersburg Christmas" (Russia)
More...