pearseanderson's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Clarkesworld Year Six blew me away. It retaught me what science fiction could be and what independent magazines could be. Clarkesworld Year Seven, however, did not do this. In Six I had dozens of memories of complex, interesting, groundbreaking moments and worldbuilding details. In Seven, I could a handful of memorable ones. Yoon Ha Lee was great as always, and de Bodard, Theodora Goss, and Lisa L Hannett had great tales, but the rest were lackluster. I really hope Year Eight has what Six gave me. Was this anthology bad? Of course not, but it left me too often bored or confused.
More...