You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
4.15 AVERAGE
4.15 AVERAGE
adventurous
dark
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
This volume really captures the essence of what one would hope from a Superman, just a superlative being with remarkable decency and nobility, on top of all the laser vision and herculean strength. It makes for a surprisingly interesting character too. Most of the comics I read have flawed protagonists or antiheroes, which are fun in their own way, but having such a straight superhero is a nice change from that. The Superman of Morrison is the paragon of what humanity could be, and it is a beautiful thing to imagine. A lot of this came up in the book he wrote [b:Supergods: What Masked Vigilantes, Miraculous Mutants, and a Sun God from Smallville Can Teach Us About Being Human|10081832|Supergods What Masked Vigilantes, Miraculous Mutants, and a Sun God from Smallville Can Teach Us About Being Human|Grant Morrison|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1327885368s/10081832.jpg|14978598] but this narrative conveys that message in a much more enjoyable format.
Like many, I've heard a lot of hype on this title. I very much enjoyed All Star Superman as a whole, but this volume certainly was the lesser of the two. The main issue I faced was the disjointedness of the narrative. Issues 7 and 8 just seem to sort of float out there without connecting to much. Then issue 9 has a very standalone feel as well.
I think it's a very interesting portrayal of Supes, and it's one of the first non-canon stories I've read, which is a very interesting situation. Setting it outside the standard universe allows quite a bit of creative freedom. The ending is where it was at for me. Nothing like ending on a crazy high note.
Might not buy it again if given the chance, but I'm proud to have it in my collection.
I think it's a very interesting portrayal of Supes, and it's one of the first non-canon stories I've read, which is a very interesting situation. Setting it outside the standard universe allows quite a bit of creative freedom. The ending is where it was at for me. Nothing like ending on a crazy high note.
Might not buy it again if given the chance, but I'm proud to have it in my collection.
If I could, I would give this ten stars. It's one of those books - those rare gems that I wish I could have read a long time ago only because that way I could have known it longer. It's absolutely wonderful.
Like the fist one, this is a MUST READ comic book. I could write a review, but i think Mark Waid, in the initial pages, pretty much sums why this is so amazing.
Hands-down the best Superman story I've ever read. Very excited to see how James Gunn incorporates the heart of this run into his movie.
I loved this series and though Morrison did an amazing job at creating an out-of-continuity Superman tale that was both new and recognizable. There was just something very personal about his take on the character and you were able to feel both excited and nostalgic over this story.
However, I will admit that the second half of his run is less impressive than is stellar beginning. One of the problems is that we spend two whole issues in bizarro world and, despite it being Morrison, this plot segment is just not compelling to take two issue out of twelve. Once we get past these issue though, things pick up once again.
Any time Luther is on scene in this book, it's an amazing ride. With Superman trying to stop his own death, with Luther trying to escape his, it's a lot of great character struggle coming to a head. But, even with how great the end moments are between these two power houses, some of the most powerful moments involve Superman and his affect on the world. The scene where he stops a girl from committing suicide with the words, "You're stronger than this." is a great one and really sets the tone that was the whole series. A great end to a great story.
H
However, I will admit that the second half of his run is less impressive than is stellar beginning. One of the problems is that we spend two whole issues in bizarro world and, despite it being Morrison, this plot segment is just not compelling to take two issue out of twelve. Once we get past these issue though, things pick up once again.
Any time Luther is on scene in this book, it's an amazing ride. With Superman trying to stop his own death, with Luther trying to escape his, it's a lot of great character struggle coming to a head. But, even with how great the end moments are between these two power houses, some of the most powerful moments involve Superman and his affect on the world. The scene where he stops a girl from committing suicide with the words, "You're stronger than this." is a great one and really sets the tone that was the whole series. A great end to a great story.
H
Want to watch things you don't understand happen for no reason because why not? This is the book for you!