Reviews tagging 'Slavery'

The Sword of Kaigen by M.L. Wang

3 reviews

thecriticalreader's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark emotional sad tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.75

 
Context: 
I used my free Kindle Unlimited trial to finally get around to reading The Sword of Kaigen, which has been on my TBR for a couple of years now. In case you were confused like I was, this book is a STANDALONE—I confused Wang’s recent standalone Blood Over Bright Haven for a sequel.
 
Review:
Whew! I did not know what I was getting into with this book. I’m someone who enjoys my fantasy on the lighter side with moments of darkness rather than books that feature a lot of violence and trauma. Needless to say, I was not prepared for the sheer amount of violence and emotional devastation that lay in store for me in The Sword of Kaigen. Despite not being exactly my cup of tea in this regard, this book is one of the best fantasy novels I’ve ever read. I have so many good things to say about it, so I’m going to make a bulleted list to make sure I touch on everything.

·      The writing is incredibly cinematic. I could easily visualize everything that happens in this book, to the point where making it into a movie out would be redundant. I felt this to be true even for the action scenes, which I normally struggle to visualize in fantasy stories. Typically, I find them boring and confusing. However, Wang is a master of writing exciting, comprehensible, high-stakes action, which is a good thing because this book is chock full of action scenes!

·      Holy cow, this book is full of some of the best-written characters I’ve read in a fantasy book. All of the characters—from the side characters to the protagonists—are complex, interesting, and believable. Every story beat with these characters is earned, making for a phenomenally emotional story.

·      The pacing and organization of The Sword of Kaigen is flawless. Every story beat occurs exactly when it is most effective. Wang seems to have an intuitive grasp for how long each scene should last; nothing feels rushed or glossed over, but at no point does the story drag.

·      The worldbuilding takes a familiar structure of elemental magic (very similar to that found in Avatar: The Last Airbender) but adapts it in a unique and original way that combines traditional elements of Japanese culture with modern technology.

·      The Sword of Kaigen provides an emotionally cathartic exploration into themes of family, loyalty, honor, and grief. It damn near emotionally destroyed me in the process, but if that’s something you like in a book, you should definitely pick this one up.

·      This book manages to explore feminist themes and create strong female characters without falling into traps of preachiness, shallowness, or stereotypes. It shows rather than tells, something so many modern books with feminist themes fail to do. 
 
If I had one criticism of The Sword of Kaigen, it’s that it rather clumsily handles elements the racial dynamics in its world. For example, the substitution of white people for positions of subjugation that BIPOC people often face is insensitive at best. At other points, the book has its characters spout rhetoric of racial/blood supremacy without fully pushing back against these inherently racist concepts. (The same can be said for the characters’ problematic ideas about pregnancy/miscarriage). I was able to overlook these missteps for the most part because they do not seem malicious and play a minor role in the plot. That being said, I hope Wang learned from this book and does better in the future.
 
In sum, The Sword of Kaigen is a masterpiece of fantasy and storytelling. I would recommend it to anyone who feels prepared to handle the book’s immense amount of violence and pain. 
 
The Run-Down: 
You will probably like The Sword of Kaigen if . . . 
·      You want an incredible character-driven story led by an immensely strong—yet complex— female protagonist
·      You find family dynamics and motherhood to be interesting themes in fantasy novels 
·      You like well-written, creative, and exciting action scenes
·      You love elemental magic systems
·      You want a fantasy book that combines ancient customs and beliefs with modern technology
·      You want a book that will emotionally destroy you and then build you back up
 
You might not like The Sword of Kaigen if . . .
·      You don’t have a strong stomach for violence or the host of other heavy topics present in this book
·      You want a book that will take you across many different locations in its world
·      You don’t like morally gray protaganists 
 
 
Expand filter menu Content Warnings

takarakei's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.25

I had been looking forward to reading this book for so long because everyone raved about it... As I do with most books I read, I went in knowing very little: basically that it was loosely based on Japanese history/culture (apparently feudal Japan specifically). In my opinion, even if I had read the blurb for this book prior to reading I think I still would have had incorrect expectations going in.

Unfortunately I felt like I read 3 different books that felt a bit disjointed. 
  • The first ~1/3 of this book is fantastic - good world building and character introductions, multiple povs to round out the perspective, very cool magic and I thought we were being set up for such a cool adventure.
  • The second ~1/3 was one long battle/war scene. This is maybe a "me" thing because typically battle scenes are really not my favorite thing to read, but this went on FOREVER. Even with the magic being super cool to read, at some point I was just really over reading about it and it felt rather repetitive.
    The deaths in this section also felt mostly like for shock value to me
  • The last ~1/3 after this battle the book took a sudden turn into a super character driven not-plot where we just follow the aftermath of the battle where they are rebuilding this town and it was honestly boring. As my friend said "the culmination of this epic fantasy is….logging and building a school….."
  • ALSO I HATED the Takeru redemption "arc" cause it's not an arc, it was a complete 180 out of nowhere with no build up and sorry I do not sympathize with him! His character development was not nuanced enough for me to care, and in the end he was still doing dumb things. IMO if Takeru had been explained to be mainly just distant/cold but not outright abusive to Misaki/the children this change would have made more sense.

I guess I just didn't expect to literally not leave this one small town the entire book (Misaki's flashbacks do not count imo). The men in this book were all incredibly insufferable and useless. Misaki was also a bit frustrating to read at times because while I can understand why she entered into this marriage based on societal expectations, I cannot understand how she became a completely different person for 15 years. 

After finishing I did some research and realized this book was written as a prequel to a YA series this author wrote that I guess holds the more conclusive ending to the empire etc??? But that made this read not like a completed standalone because at the end I still had a lot of questions about how things in this world would get resolved.

The audiobook narrator mispronounces words which was very irksome as someone who speaks some Japanese. These are not words that were made up by the author, but real Japanese words that were being used in their original context. I found actually the narration was inconsistent with some pronunciation.
Expand filter menu Content Warnings

pistachiolatte's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional hopeful reflective slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.25

La premisa de este libro no puede ser mas tentadora: poderes elementales al estilo Avatar the Last Airbender, combinado con Ciudad de Jade, con una escenografía que recuerda a las películas de samurais de Zhang Yimou.

Combina esos elementos de manera muy solvente, en un mundo con sus propias religiones, política, continentes... todo muy bien construido. La narración es en tercera persona desde el punto de vista de diferentes personajes, mi favorita. Es un libro character-driven (no suceden muchas cosas, hay acción pero no es su foco, se centra en los personajes ). Para mi, sus mayores defectos son su ritmo irregular (arranca muy fuerte y en la segunda mitad se estanca) y los cabos sueltos/información a medias que deja.

En resumen, si la premisa te atrae, dale una oportunidad. Está muy bien escrito y se agradece una novela única de fantasía en lugar de una serie de +3 volúmenes.

Dicho esto voy a entrar a detallar más, para los que ya lo hemos leído.

Me gustó mucho más la primera mitad del libro que la segunda. Me encantaba el punto de vista de Mamoru, su relación con Kwang Chul-Hee, los flashbacks del pasado de Misaki, la tensión del conflicto que se avecina... la segunda mitad se me ha hecho aburrida. Estaba esperando que se resolvieran cosas que nunca llegan. 

Por poner un ejemplo, todo el tema del secuestrador de niños para formar un ejercito se queda en el aire. Robin y Misaki hablan al final sobre una conversación que ella debería tener con Hiroshi (nunca llega). Empezamos el libro con Kwang Chul-Hee siendo MUY relevante y a mitad literalmente no se le vuelve a mencionar.

También pensaba que rechazaban la ayuda del emperador como primer paso de una venganza/revolucion por Takayubi, pero tampoco llega nunca. Quiero decir, es el punto principal del libro y no se hace nada al respecto. Está claro que en la guerra no todo son victorias épicas, pero se supone que sois los mejores luchadores del mundo y esenciales para el continente y casi os exterminan sin que os quejéis. :(

La extensión de los episodios también se me ha hecho algo pesada e irregular. Además, se usa mucho vocabulario exclusivo de este libro, lo cual interrumpe mucho la lectura para revisar el glosario, especialmente al inicio, cuando no estás familiarizado aún.

Pese a estas cosas, el libro me ha gustado mucho. Para empezar, el autor se ha arriesgado a la hora de desarrollar la historia. Por ejemplo, los de aire en esta historia son los malos, en lugar de los de fuego COMO SIEMPRE. Además, en una historia mas inmadura la relación de Robin y Misaki seguramente se hubiera llevado de manera muy distinta, con huidas a caballo al atardecer y cosas asi. Me ha encantado como se trata la reconstrucción de su relación con Takeru. 

De hecho, ha sido muy refrescante leer a una protagonista de +30 años en lugar de a una niñata de 17. Me ha encantado toooodo el arco de Mamoru. Me ha encantado la magia de este mundo, las habilidades de cada personaje, la escenografía de montañas nevadas.
Siento que voy a recordar este libro con cariño, porque pese a sus defectos consigue que retengas esta historia, como si hubieras estado allí.
Expand filter menu Content Warnings
More...