Reviews

Winternacht by Arnaldur Indriðason

ridgewaygirl's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I have a great fondness for noirish crime novels set in the north, so when I snagged Arctic Chill by Arnaldur Indridason from the Early Reviewers program I was enormously pleased. Indridason is an Icelandic author and this book, one of a series of police procedurals, is set in Reykjavik in the winter. In Arctic Chill, the body of a boy is found near the apartment building in which he and his mother and brother live. His mother is Thai and although his father is Icelandic, the suspicion of the police is that this was a racially motivated murder.

The investigation is led by the dour and unfriendly Erlender, a man who is less lonely and wounded than asocial. He's an interesting variation on the usual loner detective and although his behavior is partially explained by events in his childhood, he is an unpleasant guy. He is haunted by an earlier missing woman case and can't let it go.

The novel's setting is an integral part of the story and, in the course of the investigation, Indridason explores the impact of immigrants, primarily from Asia, on the small Icelandic population. In comparison to events in the United States (where I am) the racism is mild and calmly addressed, but what really struck me about Indridason's Iceland is the isolation in which people choose to live. Marriages break up with very little thought and children are abandoned by their fathers who leave without having to support their offspring in any way and people live next to neighbors they never get to know. All this is amplified by the early dark and relentless cold of the Icelandic winter.

littletaiko's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Not sure what it says about me that I purposely chose this book for my plane read. These books are never the most uplifting but they sure do keep me engrossed. This time a young Thai boy is found dead near his family's apartment. By all accounts he was a sweet boy with no inclination to trouble. The police immediately wonder if it's a hate crime as there are tensions between native Icelanders and the Asian immigrants. I thought the parallels between the tensions and what we have in the US to be quite interesting. It seemed a little off that the police immediately leap to that assumption. As usual, there are several other stories going on that continue to carry forward from book to book.

kcfromaustcrime's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

There are some authors who are on my buy immediately list. Some of these books I can happily hoard - waiting until just the right moment to sit and enjoy them. And there are the ones that are buy and read immediately. ARCTIC CHILL has definitely been one of those books. As soon as it arrived in the house it danced around before my eyes until I could finish what I was reading and start this one.

And you know when you've picked up a fabulous book because you find yourself sitting in the car, reading it - "it's no problem I can wait in the car while you run in and do ......". You don't mind missing meals, you forget your favourite TV shows and you're finding excuses to miss meetings and social events so that you can just finish this book.

ARCTIC CHILL is also one of those unputdownable books because of the stylish way in which it scratches a number of itches - works on those points that I think make good crime fiction stand head and shoulders above many other possible reading options for me.

There's discussion and revelations of the society in which the crime occurs. In this case there is some stark observations of the difficulties of immigration within Icelandic society - from both the immigrants and the native resident viewpoint. The portrayal of both sides of the issue was fair, and deftly done - no preaching / no overt support for one side or the other. Many of these elements have considerable echoes with issues that arise in my own country, and the reminder that intolerance, suspicion as well as acceptance can be anywhere is both timely and pointed.

There's also one of those tremendous senses of place. Not just because Iceland is different climatically from elsewhere, but also in the way that the society itself is portrayed. Obviously it's a much smaller country than so many others, and their societal structures work differently from many that - for example - I'm used to. But the way that the Icelandic sensibility is portrayed in all of the Indridason books is revealing, without being a travelogue, too sentimental or too much of a documentary.

There are also great individual characters. The focus switches a little around a central group of police investigators all of whom take a different prominence throughout the individual stories, and throughout all the books. The central investigator though, the wonderfully rumpled, questioning, almost quixotic Erlendur always remains the central focus of the team though. His own personal background is complicated by the disappearance of his brother as children - an event that he has never fully come to terms with - and his divorce from his wife and separation from his children. All throught their adult years Erlendur and his two children have struggled to form a relationship which works for them all, and that struggle, whilst not taking over from the investigation or the crimes in each book, adds a level of sadness and somewhat unexpectedly hope to Erlendur.

And finally there's a good story about the death of a little boy. A child who it seems nobody could possibly have wanted dead. Unless there is a racial motive. Maybe revenge. The ultimate resolution is stark in what it says about the true nature of so much violent crime.

These books are definitely police procedurals, but they incorporate a lot of social commentary and personal insight. As atmospheric perhaps as Henning Mankell's Wallender series, Erlendur, however, isn't Wallender and there's a very different personality at work here. If you haven't read any of Arnaldur Indridason's fabulous books, then start somewhere with the series. If you can go back to the beginning, then you'll learn about him and his team as the books progress, but each also stands alone if you can't. The books so far have been:

* Jar City (also published as Tainted Blood)
* Silence of the Grave
* Voices
* The Draining Lake
* Arctic Chill

ru_ro's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark slow-paced

4.0

sandin954's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

While an interesting look at Icelandic society and the struggles immigrants have adapting to both the extreme weather conditions and the rather insular culture, this entry just was not quite up to its predecessors high quality in both plot and writing flow.

ebokhyllami's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Må si, at dette er den minst gode jeg har lest i serien sålangt. Ikke spesielt spennende plott, mye mellomsnakk og digresjoner, forsøk på to paralelle plot som jeg ikke syntes gjorde hverandre mer spennende eller tilføyde noe. Tror jeg skal ta en Indridason-pause nå...

liberrydude's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Interesting mystery that delves into immigrants and the prejudices that ensue. At the same time the reader and police could be "prejudiced" in their interpretation of the "usual suspects." Things are never as they seem. Erlendur continues to be haunted by his childhood tragedy and is distracted by a missing person case. Even though the weather is dark and dismal and his personal life is a major bummer Erlendur is a compelling character whom we follow and respect inspite of his aloofness and lack of charisma.

iriswildeboer's review

Go to review page

mysterious reflective slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? No

3.0

ingabbjarna's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark mysterious sad medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.0


Expand filter menu Content Warnings

saltycorpse's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

As all the Erlender books have, Arctic Chill uses a murder to explore an aspect of Icelandic culture and history - this book being dedicated to immigration to Iceland, and Icelandic attitudes towards it, and the perspective of those who have immigrated to Iceland from abroad. The pace of this one was quick - it covered a matter of hours and days, realistically following the beginning of a homicide investigation. Another well-done novel from Indriðason.