Reviews with content warning for Emotional abuse - Caraval

- Definitely intended for a younger reader (probably about 13-15)
- Main character is incredibly naive and has like two personality traits: protecting her sister, and having trust issues. Oh and the third trait of being incredibly quick to trust things she hears despite trust issues
- Becomes way more interesting about 2/3s in (which at that point is a bit late really)
- Far too many plot twists. Like I'm not kidding, past the half way mark the entire situation changes context about five times
- The ending ruined the entire thing. All the stakes were gone and it made me absolutely hate most of the characters (aside from Aiko who was genuinely helpful but there for like five seconds and Scarlett who was just a normal girl in an awful situation)
- Yes I'm planning on reading the next two books (unless the second one's worse). No I would not recommend
- The prose is beautiful tho

Content Warnings

alex1's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging mysterious tense slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.5

Content Warnings

juliannereads's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional mysterious medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.75

Writing Style: 1/1

Story: 1.25/2

Characters: 0.5/2

Total: 2.75 stars

Extra rating: Enjoyability: 0.75/1

The writing style is what first drew me in. Colorful, vivid and fantastical. The main character had some form of synesthesia which made for interesting and really beautiful narrative in some parts of the book.

The story however, well…

The story had the potential to be something more thrilling if the romance didn’t completely overshadow every single plot progression for 75% of the book.

And ugh, the romance was so…blah. I wanted to love Scarlett so much as a character especially because much of her motivations and fears were being fueled by her trauma, but it was quickly drowned out by all her feelings associated with the love interests. Even her thoughts outside the love interest felt redundant because it was the same train of thoughts every single god damn time.

“I must save my sister”

“I am scared, but my sister would want me to be brave.”

“I shouldn’t share my secrets here.”

“Nothing in Caraval is real”

and just so many starry-eyed, gooey descriptions of Julian to the point where I was in literally agony trying to get through one more scene where she talks about being in close proximity to him.

Scarlett and Tella’s relationship was also something I was excited to see, especially since the synopsis literally introduces them as sisters that have a bond like no other. Every time Scarlett describes Tella, it plays with the idea of a complex relationship—Scarlett feels obligated to protect Tella due to domestic violence from her father and her mother leaving, but she also feels hidden resentment that Tella doesn’t treat her own life (or Scarlett’s in that matter) as careful as Scarlett does. But, for most of the book, the relationship was overshadowed by the romance which made it a little disappointing. But, I will say the ending does make up for some of that disappointment.

Despite a lot of cringy love details that I would rather not deal with, I will still definitely continue with this series.

Content Warnings

lostinthelibrary's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark mysterious medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? No
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.5

I didn't pick this up at it's hype and maybe it's time has passed for me. The book's strength is definitely in it's imaginative setting which was evocative though often unclear. The plot, though a bit scrambled at times, was okay and did surprise me on some occasions so that does put if above similar "atmosphere" books like The Night Circus.

However, I found the characters, especially the protagonist and her love interest, extremely uninteresting. I rolled my eyes in multiple parts of dialogue and they were just not people I felt I could root for. Annoyingly the best character in the book

Tella

is the one who is absent for it's majority. I hope they feature more in the sequel.

A strong premise and setting but not much more substance for me. I might give the sequel a try to see if the weaker elements improve.

Content Warnings