You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
4.45 AVERAGE
4.45 AVERAGE
3.5 stars.
I wanted to get totally swept away in the story but I did not. I enjoyed many of the characters but I never felt completely engrossed. I loved the themes and the concept and the historical context of the AIDS crisis but, it never quite grabbed me the way I wanted it to. And it was long so there was plenty of time; it just never happened and I can't put my figure on why.
I wanted to get totally swept away in the story but I did not. I enjoyed many of the characters but I never felt completely engrossed. I loved the themes and the concept and the historical context of the AIDS crisis but, it never quite grabbed me the way I wanted it to. And it was long so there was plenty of time; it just never happened and I can't put my figure on why.
challenging
emotional
reflective
sad
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Content Warnings
Graphic: Homophobia, Terminal illness
Moderate: Sexual content
Devastating.. beautiful. Best thing to read when you’ve just moved to Lakeview
Fantastic characterizations of the characters and the structure that jumps forward and backward in time ultimately struggle against the premise, which has basically become the quintessential gay story. There are so many queer stories that do not focus on the AIDS crisis and do not play on this need to humanize people you should not have to struggle to have empathy for, that this feels out of time and place, despite its strengths.
emotional
hopeful
sad
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Oh, the tears shed over this book and its main character, Yale. I know it is the trend to bounce back and forth between time and characters, but this book uses that device so well that it adds depth and intrigue to the story.
emotional
funny
inspiring
reflective
sad
medium-paced
Gorgeous !!! Loved the different timelines and perspectives, such interesting characters. What an important look into the AIDS crisis in the 80s — truly moving
Rebecca Makkai's 'The Great Believers' is a poignant exploration of friendship, loss, and redemption against the backdrop of the AIDS epidemic in 1980s Chicago and its lingering effects into contemporary Paris. Awarding this novel a 4 out of 5 stars, my journey through its pages was both challenging and rewarding, offering a deep, emotional dive into a historical moment that continues to resonate.
Initially, the narrative's structure, with its leaps between decades, presented a hurdle. The shifting timelines were disorienting, requiring a period of adjustment to fully engage with the story's flow. However, perseverance, driven by my commitment to a book club discussion, unveiled a deeply moving narrative that has lingered in my thoughts long after the final page.
Makkai crafts a narrative that is devastatingly beautiful, capturing the tragedy of the AIDS epidemic through the eyes of Yale Tishman, a man navigating both the peaks of his career and the profound losses inflicted by the disease. Yale's story is a testament to the strength found in friendship and love amidst despair. His character, along with those who orbit his world, are drawn with such depth and authenticity that one cannot help but become invested in their fates.
Parallel to Yale's story is that of Fiona, who, decades later, confronts the lasting impact of the epidemic on her life and relationships. While Fiona's journey, particularly in her present-day struggles, initially seemed less compelling, her character's development provides crucial insights into the long-term effects of trauma and loss.
As a queer reader, 'The Great Believers' resonated on a deeply personal level, shedding light on a painful chapter of queer history and its echoes in today's society. The book not only educated but also evoked a profound sense of connection to the past and a recognition of the ongoing challenges within the queer community.
Makkai's novel is more than a historical recounting; it's a mirror reflecting the human condition, our capacity for resilience, and the indelible marks left by love and loss. 'The Great Believers' is an essential read for those looking to understand the depth of the AIDS crisis and its lasting impact on those it touched.
In conclusion, 'The Great Believers' is a compelling, heart-wrenching novel that successfully bridges the gap between past and present, highlighting the enduring power of human connection. It serves as a reminder of the stories we carry and the importance of remembering those who have been lost. Rebecca Makkai has delivered a masterpiece that not only makes us think but encourages us to feel deeply about the complexities of life and love in the face of adversity.
Initially, the narrative's structure, with its leaps between decades, presented a hurdle. The shifting timelines were disorienting, requiring a period of adjustment to fully engage with the story's flow. However, perseverance, driven by my commitment to a book club discussion, unveiled a deeply moving narrative that has lingered in my thoughts long after the final page.
Makkai crafts a narrative that is devastatingly beautiful, capturing the tragedy of the AIDS epidemic through the eyes of Yale Tishman, a man navigating both the peaks of his career and the profound losses inflicted by the disease. Yale's story is a testament to the strength found in friendship and love amidst despair. His character, along with those who orbit his world, are drawn with such depth and authenticity that one cannot help but become invested in their fates.
Parallel to Yale's story is that of Fiona, who, decades later, confronts the lasting impact of the epidemic on her life and relationships. While Fiona's journey, particularly in her present-day struggles, initially seemed less compelling, her character's development provides crucial insights into the long-term effects of trauma and loss.
As a queer reader, 'The Great Believers' resonated on a deeply personal level, shedding light on a painful chapter of queer history and its echoes in today's society. The book not only educated but also evoked a profound sense of connection to the past and a recognition of the ongoing challenges within the queer community.
Makkai's novel is more than a historical recounting; it's a mirror reflecting the human condition, our capacity for resilience, and the indelible marks left by love and loss. 'The Great Believers' is an essential read for those looking to understand the depth of the AIDS crisis and its lasting impact on those it touched.
In conclusion, 'The Great Believers' is a compelling, heart-wrenching novel that successfully bridges the gap between past and present, highlighting the enduring power of human connection. It serves as a reminder of the stories we carry and the importance of remembering those who have been lost. Rebecca Makkai has delivered a masterpiece that not only makes us think but encourages us to feel deeply about the complexities of life and love in the face of adversity.
emotional
hopeful
informative
reflective
medium-paced
Wavering between 4 and 5. Really enjoyable, thoughtful, richly portrayed.