Scan barcode
midgereads's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
emotional
funny
inspiring
lighthearted
reflective
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.75
I read this for school and I enjoyed it a lot more than I thought I would. I laughed out loud several times and found the main characters very likeable. The biggest problem is that it’s so long. They were not lying when they said Charles Dickens loved descriptions. My other issue is that there are several misogynistic ideas sprinkled throughout (and Dickens often called women “females”) but it was the 19th century so what can you do.
ambipure's review against another edition
challenging
funny
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
1.0
bluestarfish's review against another edition
4.0
As often seems to be the case with me and Dickens I take a little while to get into it, and then I really enjoy it. The Pickwick Papers are a huge undertaking and I struggled at first but then at some point something clicked and I was reading avidly without realising it. I think it was probably around the time when I got the characters straight in my head and could start distinguishing between them. And Sam Weller is a real joy.
Reading the Pickwickian Christmas shortly before the one in real-time was also fortuitous. It's such a lovely description that I could see that being added to the annual Christmas reading.
Reading the Pickwickian Christmas shortly before the one in real-time was also fortuitous. It's such a lovely description that I could see that being added to the annual Christmas reading.
rlintott's review against another edition
4.0
A bit long-winded at times, and I really need to learn a way to read Picaresque novels that doesn't prevent my reading other things, but overall it was a fantastic story. Certainly, as my Aunt said, Dickens on uppers.
lisawreading's review against another edition
3.0
Done, finally! I've been on a mission to read more Dickens, and ended up reading Pickwick Papers with my book group this year. Parts are quite funny, and overall it's silly and endearing, but it lacks the deeper impact of some of his masterpieces.
fruitkate's review against another edition
funny
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.25
srobertsp's review against another edition
4.0
First read in high school (1968?), assigned, I think.
zenithharpink's review against another edition
4.0
4.5 stars. I really love Dickens, so I had high expectations walking into this, but I was not disappointed - of course, Dickens never does! It took a minute for me to get used to the format of the book, it was a bit like soaking into a very warm bath. It was just a touch too hot, but I was slowly able to sink in and thoroughly enjoy myself.
Mr. Pickwick was an enjoyable character, and his friends were stolid, engaging types. It was a new change of pace, a up-beat Dickens novel, but there were moments of this book that had me laughing out loud. It was reminiscent of Wodehouse, though with a fair bit less levity.
I was certainly hoping for a little more satisfaction or even revenge on a couple plot lines, but I was to be disappointed. This book wonderfully ties up loose ends as Dickens always does, but I am clearly more petty than Mr. Dickens & Mr. Pickwick. This book was still thoroughly enjoyable.
I recommend this book to all fans of Dickens or great English literature. While not my favorite of his novels, this was still a great read.
Mr. Pickwick was an enjoyable character, and his friends were stolid, engaging types. It was a new change of pace, a up-beat Dickens novel, but there were moments of this book that had me laughing out loud. It was reminiscent of Wodehouse, though with a fair bit less levity.
I was certainly hoping for a little more satisfaction or even revenge on a couple plot lines, but I was to be disappointed. This book wonderfully ties up loose ends as Dickens always does, but I am clearly more petty than Mr. Dickens & Mr. Pickwick. This book was still thoroughly enjoyable.
I recommend this book to all fans of Dickens or great English literature. While not my favorite of his novels, this was still a great read.
edenseve63's review against another edition
5.0
It has been my ambition for some time to read the Dickens' canon in chronological publication order -- with the exception of "A Christmas Carol" which I read at the holidays. "The Pickwick Papers" was #1 on the list. I tried unsuccessfully to read the text, but time and eyesight being what it is, I didn't get far. A couple of weeks back I came across Audible's "The Dickens Collection" when I re-upped my membership. To my happiness I found this collection of Audible Dickens editions works perfectly with my schedule and allows me to get into the text with the aid of such marvelous narrators like Rory Kinnear, who made each and every character a clear and distinct individual not to be confused with any other.
Dickens, whose work originally came out in serial form, can be somewhat awkward for the modern readers when taken as a full novel. Had he been writing today, I can easily imagine Dickens having long-term gigs as a Show Runner with Netflix and Amazon. Long before tv cliffhangers left us wondering "who shot J.R. Ewing" Dickens had polished this art form. His topsy turvy plots often take one off on tangent adventures in the midst of the main storyline leaving the reader a bit confused. And perhaps, the modern reader can predict how plots will come together in the end after years of watching television serial dramas. But the joy of reading Dickens is he continually delights with humor, meaningful text and the gospel like lessons that remain timeless and universal.
Mr. Samuel Pickwick's papers, a report to his club members, on his adventures in each town, hamlet and city he comes to, be it a political rivalry between newspaper editors, or a family drama involving the Wardle family of the adorably named Dingley Dell and their romantic mishaps are all dutifully reported along with serious issues like the condition of those confined to debtors prison. Mr. Pickwick remains throughout the course of the novel kind-hearted, curious, generous and a pillar of morality in a world (like our own) that is sorely lacking in those traits. He can also, like all of us, lose patience with stupidity and become disheartened by the injustices he witnesses. A solitary single gentleman, he finds companionship among assorted characters, each with their distinct good and bad qualities. However, in a time when rank in society was clearly delineated, Pickwick (perhaps like Dickens) does not judge any person based on their place in the order of the day. This is clearly seen in his relationship with Samuel Weller and his father. An ordinary working man with little formal education, he not only serves as Pickwick's employee but his most trusted companion. This is never clearer than when Pickwick finds himself in the Fleet (debtors prison) because he refuses to pay compensation to his former landlady Mrs. Bardell who under the wicked hand of unscrupulous attorneys' Dodson and Fogg brings a case of breach of promise against him. Samuel Weller convinces his father Tony Weller to bring charges against his son and see that he is imprisoned alongside his master, Mr. Pickwick, in the Fleet. Sam's devotion to Pickwick and the childless Pickwick's fatherly feelings for Sam are among the most beautiful parts of the story.
Dickens like Daniel DeFoe sought to render the ills of society and depicting those consigned to the debtors prison fairly details the fateful course when job, money, home are all lost. On a spiritual and practical plain, the reader is taught the blessing of forgiveness in Pickwick's ultimate encounter with Messrs. Jingle and Trotter.
For those like myself, more familiar with Dickens more popular works, in The Pickwick Papers the reader foresees the origins of famed characters like Tiny Tim and Fagan to be reborn to great acclaim in his later novels. In true Dickensian fashion there is plenty of mayhem, miscommunication and hijinx to keep you laughing throughout and all loose ends are eventually tied up in a satisfying ending.
Dickens, whose work originally came out in serial form, can be somewhat awkward for the modern readers when taken as a full novel. Had he been writing today, I can easily imagine Dickens having long-term gigs as a Show Runner with Netflix and Amazon. Long before tv cliffhangers left us wondering "who shot J.R. Ewing" Dickens had polished this art form. His topsy turvy plots often take one off on tangent adventures in the midst of the main storyline leaving the reader a bit confused. And perhaps, the modern reader can predict how plots will come together in the end after years of watching television serial dramas. But the joy of reading Dickens is he continually delights with humor, meaningful text and the gospel like lessons that remain timeless and universal.
Mr. Samuel Pickwick's papers, a report to his club members, on his adventures in each town, hamlet and city he comes to, be it a political rivalry between newspaper editors, or a family drama involving the Wardle family of the adorably named Dingley Dell and their romantic mishaps are all dutifully reported along with serious issues like the condition of those confined to debtors prison. Mr. Pickwick remains throughout the course of the novel kind-hearted, curious, generous and a pillar of morality in a world (like our own) that is sorely lacking in those traits. He can also, like all of us, lose patience with stupidity and become disheartened by the injustices he witnesses. A solitary single gentleman, he finds companionship among assorted characters, each with their distinct good and bad qualities. However, in a time when rank in society was clearly delineated, Pickwick (perhaps like Dickens) does not judge any person based on their place in the order of the day. This is clearly seen in his relationship with Samuel Weller and his father. An ordinary working man with little formal education, he not only serves as Pickwick's employee but his most trusted companion. This is never clearer than when Pickwick finds himself in the Fleet (debtors prison) because he refuses to pay compensation to his former landlady Mrs. Bardell who under the wicked hand of unscrupulous attorneys' Dodson and Fogg brings a case of breach of promise against him. Samuel Weller convinces his father Tony Weller to bring charges against his son and see that he is imprisoned alongside his master, Mr. Pickwick, in the Fleet. Sam's devotion to Pickwick and the childless Pickwick's fatherly feelings for Sam are among the most beautiful parts of the story.
Dickens like Daniel DeFoe sought to render the ills of society and depicting those consigned to the debtors prison fairly details the fateful course when job, money, home are all lost. On a spiritual and practical plain, the reader is taught the blessing of forgiveness in Pickwick's ultimate encounter with Messrs. Jingle and Trotter.
For those like myself, more familiar with Dickens more popular works, in The Pickwick Papers the reader foresees the origins of famed characters like Tiny Tim and Fagan to be reborn to great acclaim in his later novels. In true Dickensian fashion there is plenty of mayhem, miscommunication and hijinx to keep you laughing throughout and all loose ends are eventually tied up in a satisfying ending.
jenmcmaynes's review against another edition
2.0
Probably my least favorite of Dickens' work. The humor was pretty thin, and the long, rather pointless asides were many. I had to work pretty hard to get through it.