Scan barcode
judeandolin's review against another edition
3.0
★★★½ Full review HERE.
I was quickly engulfed in the picture Larson painted of late 19th-century Chicago, complete with evocative descriptions of filthy streets, destitute workers, the rank smell of horse dung and the slaughterhouses, and, of course, the complement to all of this darkness: the White City, the location of the 1893 World's Fair.
The story follows three separate plot lines; one of the trials and tribulations of the builders of the fair, another of a deranged young man who goes on to commit a terrible crime, and the third, of course, about the infamous serial killer H.H. Holmes, who built a sprawling murder hotel and used the lure of the World's Fair to ensnare women.
Again, as one who reads to be transported, this book was phenomenal. It was vivid and rich with trivia. For instance:
- Olmstead, the man who designed the grounds of the White City, also designed Central Park, the Biltmore, and many other gardens and grounds.
- Shredded wheat was introduced at the World's Fair in 1893.
- In an attempt to outdo the centerpiece of the 1889 Paris World's Fair (the Eiffel Tower) the designers of the Chicago fair went all out and eventually invented the Ferris wheel.
- Frank Lloyd Wright worked under one of the architects who helped design the fair.
- The "snake charmer" song (also called "The Streets of Cairo, or The Poor Little Country Maid") was a random, spur-of-the-moment creation by the young, brilliant Sol Bloom who helped design the Midway of the fair. He then went on to become a politician in New York and a delegate at the convention that established the United Nations; he also suggested the first words to the Preamble to the United Nations Charter.
- Burnham, one of the original designers of the fair, went on to design many other buildings, including the Flatiron Building (originally known as the Fuller Building).
There were about a hundred other interesting factoids that I can't seem to remember now, but it seems to me, a casual know-nothing, that this point in history had its fingers stuck in about a hundred other points in history, and went on to change our world in ways we may not recognize. Reading, I wanted nothing more than to step back in time and experience the whirlwind of change undergoing the country (and then promptly return to 2017, where we have sanitation laws).
This is where my enjoyment of the book comes to a relative halt. Because, if you recall, I can't stand nonfiction. So for me, the majority of this book was a bore. I wanted to know more about H.H. Holmes and his crimes, but I didn't want to know quite so much about all of the old white guys building the fair. Unfortunately, two of the three storylines had such tentative connections to the fair that their inclusion felt more like a way to add drama to the otherwise quite dull account of old men trying and repeatedly failing to build this fair. Without the inclusion of Holmes' or Prenderghast's chapters, of which details are scant, the story would have been a fairly tired, hum-drum collection of newspaper clippings tied together with bits of prose detailing the slow and often unfortunate creation of the Chicago Exposition.
So although the book was interesting, I wouldn't quite be able to call it fascinating (there is a large gap, in my mind, between those two words). It taught me a lot of cool, historical facts (which I'll be sure to fling out the next time I'm at a highbrow dinner party), but I do wish more focus had been placed on exploring the crimes connected (however slightly) to the fair, as I find that more interesting than a bunch of aging architects with cataracts and gout (be they geniuses or not). Overall, it just didn't hold my attention.
I was quickly engulfed in the picture Larson painted of late 19th-century Chicago, complete with evocative descriptions of filthy streets, destitute workers, the rank smell of horse dung and the slaughterhouses, and, of course, the complement to all of this darkness: the White City, the location of the 1893 World's Fair.
The story follows three separate plot lines; one of the trials and tribulations of the builders of the fair, another of a deranged young man who goes on to commit a terrible crime, and the third, of course, about the infamous serial killer H.H. Holmes, who built a sprawling murder hotel and used the lure of the World's Fair to ensnare women.
Again, as one who reads to be transported, this book was phenomenal. It was vivid and rich with trivia. For instance:
- Olmstead, the man who designed the grounds of the White City, also designed Central Park, the Biltmore, and many other gardens and grounds.
- Shredded wheat was introduced at the World's Fair in 1893.
- In an attempt to outdo the centerpiece of the 1889 Paris World's Fair (the Eiffel Tower) the designers of the Chicago fair went all out and eventually invented the Ferris wheel.
- Frank Lloyd Wright worked under one of the architects who helped design the fair.
- The "snake charmer" song (also called "The Streets of Cairo, or The Poor Little Country Maid") was a random, spur-of-the-moment creation by the young, brilliant Sol Bloom who helped design the Midway of the fair. He then went on to become a politician in New York and a delegate at the convention that established the United Nations; he also suggested the first words to the Preamble to the United Nations Charter.
- Burnham, one of the original designers of the fair, went on to design many other buildings, including the Flatiron Building (originally known as the Fuller Building).
There were about a hundred other interesting factoids that I can't seem to remember now, but it seems to me, a casual know-nothing, that this point in history had its fingers stuck in about a hundred other points in history, and went on to change our world in ways we may not recognize. Reading, I wanted nothing more than to step back in time and experience the whirlwind of change undergoing the country (and then promptly return to 2017, where we have sanitation laws).
This is where my enjoyment of the book comes to a relative halt. Because, if you recall, I can't stand nonfiction. So for me, the majority of this book was a bore. I wanted to know more about H.H. Holmes and his crimes, but I didn't want to know quite so much about all of the old white guys building the fair. Unfortunately, two of the three storylines had such tentative connections to the fair that their inclusion felt more like a way to add drama to the otherwise quite dull account of old men trying and repeatedly failing to build this fair. Without the inclusion of Holmes' or Prenderghast's chapters, of which details are scant, the story would have been a fairly tired, hum-drum collection of newspaper clippings tied together with bits of prose detailing the slow and often unfortunate creation of the Chicago Exposition.
So although the book was interesting, I wouldn't quite be able to call it fascinating (there is a large gap, in my mind, between those two words). It taught me a lot of cool, historical facts (which I'll be sure to fling out the next time I'm at a highbrow dinner party), but I do wish more focus had been placed on exploring the crimes connected (however slightly) to the fair, as I find that more interesting than a bunch of aging architects with cataracts and gout (be they geniuses or not). Overall, it just didn't hold my attention.
pickled_pisces's review against another edition
thought it would be more focused on H H Holmes and the construction of this hotel, but instead spent way too many pages on the smallest details of the Worlds fair. Felt like a force to get through some the Worlds fair chapters
gladduck's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
informative
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
medium-paced
4.75
My general impression is that this book was very entertaining, especially for someone who doesn’t generally enjoy non fiction. The author did amazing at pacing and telling interesting stories, connecting the story to figures and facts that readers know like Disney for example. I loved it, especially as a mystery lover, and annoyed reading about the worlds fair which was very inspiring yet dark
owenjetton's review against another edition
challenging
dark
informative
mysterious
reflective
slow-paced
4.0
erindolson's review against another edition
2.0
I feel like it was a good book but just not the book for me. Remove all the chapters that are not about the murders and it's a 4/5.
lillianbentley's review against another edition
2.0
I feel like there was a lot of focus on things that I didn’t feel like were very important to the story. Liked the parts that were focused on Holmes. It was interesting to learn about history that happened so close to me, just not the book for me.