Scan barcode
tildahlia's review against another edition
3.0
After not loving Room for a Stranger, I had planned to not read this book but was encouraged to by a friend who felt she was better in the short story medium. My friend was right! While still not a showstopper in my view, I enjoyed these stories showcasing modern and diverse Australian characters, without too much cliche or cringe.
rollforlibrarian's review
emotional
reflective
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
rnmcfarlane's review
adventurous
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
samstillreading's review against another edition
5.0
Reading short story collections is something I’ve been meaning to get into for some time. But it’s always stayed on the ‘someday I’ll get around to it’ part of my list until now. I picked up Melanie Cheng’s debut of short stories shortly after it was announced as part of the shortlist for the Readings Prize for New Australian Fiction and…wow. I was completely blown away by Melanie’s power to capture setting, characters and tell a story in just several pages. Some of the stories, particularly ‘Fracture’ and ‘Macca’, left me wondering about the characters and outcomes for several days. I’ve now learned the power of a short story (or three) as a way to sneak in some reading on busy days and nights just to escape to another world.
Many of the stories have a medical slant to them, whether it be as a medical student (‘Australia Day’), overworked GP (‘Macca’), nurse (‘Hotel Cambodia’) or doctor under investigation (‘Fracture’). You definitely don’t need to be involved in healthcare to enjoy them. I found myself nodding with Dr Garrett as she hopes for easy appointment at the end of a day and sharing her momentary despair as she realises that Macca won’t be. The effect of a complaint on a doctor and a patient and their family is very well portrayed in ‘Fracture’. The ending is staggering and even more powerful for the short format. Melanie Chang writes prose that gets straight to the heart of the matter and tells it how it is. The good, bad and ugly of life in Australia from the eyes of different characters that not all of us will be familiar with. Think of Mrs Chan in ‘A Good and Pleasant Thing’ – living in Australia for many years without speaking English who gets to hear that her daughters want to put her in a nursing home and decides to bail. Stanley, a medical student from Hong Kong, spending Australia Day on a farm with Jess, her family and her ex – foreign, loud and a little bit odd. Leila, part-Syrian but mistaken for a British person when she’s asked for her opinion on the end of apartheid in South Africa. The stories capture all of Australia that make it the country it is – multicultural, mainly accepting but with occasional brash, unpopular opinions that lack tolerance. Racism and loneliness are explored side by side with love and family.
The more I sit here and reflect on each story in this collection, the stronger and more powerful they become. Each story holds its own, exploring the good and bad of Australian society and life in general. There are small things to be celebrated (like the nursing home residents having doughnuts bought for them one morning) and larger issues explored. The different cultures, the intriguing characters all left me wanting more. I’d love to see some longer fiction from Melanie Cheng in the future but I’ll happily accept anything and everything she writes. A fantastic talent who has nailed the art of the short story.
Thanks to Text Publishing and Goodreads for the giveaway copy. My review is honest.
Many of the stories have a medical slant to them, whether it be as a medical student (‘Australia Day’), overworked GP (‘Macca’), nurse (‘Hotel Cambodia’) or doctor under investigation (‘Fracture’). You definitely don’t need to be involved in healthcare to enjoy them. I found myself nodding with Dr Garrett as she hopes for easy appointment at the end of a day and sharing her momentary despair as she realises that Macca won’t be. The effect of a complaint on a doctor and a patient and their family is very well portrayed in ‘Fracture’. The ending is staggering and even more powerful for the short format. Melanie Chang writes prose that gets straight to the heart of the matter and tells it how it is. The good, bad and ugly of life in Australia from the eyes of different characters that not all of us will be familiar with. Think of Mrs Chan in ‘A Good and Pleasant Thing’ – living in Australia for many years without speaking English who gets to hear that her daughters want to put her in a nursing home and decides to bail. Stanley, a medical student from Hong Kong, spending Australia Day on a farm with Jess, her family and her ex – foreign, loud and a little bit odd. Leila, part-Syrian but mistaken for a British person when she’s asked for her opinion on the end of apartheid in South Africa. The stories capture all of Australia that make it the country it is – multicultural, mainly accepting but with occasional brash, unpopular opinions that lack tolerance. Racism and loneliness are explored side by side with love and family.
The more I sit here and reflect on each story in this collection, the stronger and more powerful they become. Each story holds its own, exploring the good and bad of Australian society and life in general. There are small things to be celebrated (like the nursing home residents having doughnuts bought for them one morning) and larger issues explored. The different cultures, the intriguing characters all left me wanting more. I’d love to see some longer fiction from Melanie Cheng in the future but I’ll happily accept anything and everything she writes. A fantastic talent who has nailed the art of the short story.
Thanks to Text Publishing and Goodreads for the giveaway copy. My review is honest.
esshgee's review against another edition
2.0
Meh. The writing was fine but not great, and my goodness those stories were depressing
thecheshire_cat's review
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
reflective
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
essjay1's review against another edition
3.0
I really enjoyed the first story, Australia Day. The others were a bit hit and miss but all were interesting. The stories are very well observed, about ordinary Australians and how life can be disappointing. Many are about people who feel like outsiders because of their experience, or lack of English language, or they are new to the district or have a scarred face. I like her writing.
romcm's review against another edition
5.0
Hyper-real slices of Australian life. Each short story a sparkling gem.