Scan barcode
bookie936's review
4.0
Beaches, bicycles, oligarchs, corruption, murder, journalists, neonazis, and submarines!
stevem0214's review
5.0
WOnderful as always. This one ends with Arkady in love as well as his son...I thought the series ended with this one, but The Siberian Delima came out in 2019. I need to read that one again I suppose!
hedread's review
2.0
Somewhat entertaining but not one of this author's better books. Not smoothly written
sandin954's review
3.0
Investigator Renko takes on another case that his superiors do not want him to solve when a journalist falls to her death. Always a fascinating look at Russian society. Listened to the audio version which was well narrated by Henry Strozier.
constantreader471's review
4.0
I gave this book 4 out of 5 stars. Martin Cruz Smith's books are enjoyable mysteries. His Moscow police investigator Arkady Renko is a determined man in investigating a death already ruled a suicide. Tatiana was a crusading reporter and fell to her death off a balcony. Somehow Renko connects her death to a murder of an organized crime figure. His investigation takes him to Kaliningrad, a part of Russia that used to be Koeingsberg, Germany, prior to 1945. It is now an enclave of Russia, bordered by Poland and Lithuania.
One quote from the book that made me laugh: "Judges can be expensive...
They should put an ATM in the courtroom and eliminate the middleman."
A minor quibble--one of the characters drives from Moscow to Kaliningrad, and has to go through Lithuanian and Polish customs. This book is set in 2012, after Poland and Lithuania joined the Schwengen agreement--meaning only 1 customs check.
One quote from the book that made me laugh: "Judges can be expensive...
They should put an ATM in the courtroom and eliminate the middleman."
A minor quibble--one of the characters drives from Moscow to Kaliningrad, and has to go through Lithuanian and Polish customs. This book is set in 2012, after Poland and Lithuania joined the Schwengen agreement--meaning only 1 customs check.
liberrydude's review
4.0
This should be called "The Unbearable Pervasiveness of Moroseness." The sense of overwhelming gloom and despair is thick. Tatiana is a crusading reporter who "falls" off her balcony in Moscow. Obvious suicide. Renko doesn't think so. He and Tatiana are kindred spirts who both seek out the impossible in corrupt Russia-the truth. Renko goes on a road trip to Kalingrad to see Tatiana's sister and is once again being attacked. Smith seems part Russian as he continues to capture the spirit of the place during the course of this 32 year series. It's like I'm reading a modern mystery written by Chekhov. Lots of twists and turns in this one and often times I'm asking myself why Renko isn't dead. He just walks away from encounters with the Russian Mafia.
heritage's review
2.0
On the same day as the funeral of a Russian gangster, Investigator Arkady Renko hears of the death of Tatiana, a journalist noted for tackling corruption in Moscow. The two events don't seem entirely coincidental to Renko and, as usual, he decides to ask a few questions.
Martin Cruz Smith has long been a favorite author of mine--starting with Gorky Park right on until Wolves Eat Dogs. However, he had lost his way with his next two novels, and so I approached Tatiana with apprehension. What I got was a slightly better story, but it felt like Martin Cruz Smith-lite. The narrative is lighter and the subject matter is less weighty and less thought-provoking. Part of this can be explained by his recent revelation that he has been suffering from Parkinson's disease for almost two decades and that the last several years have been quite difficult for him. However, the novel is what it is: a shadow of his former greatness.
We get a more interesting setting this time round--Kaliningrad, a Russian oblast physically cut off from the rest of the country. We learn about the area, the buildings, the birdwatchers, and the amber--none of which play much of a part in the plot, but interesting to learn about nonetheless. The plot has devolved into too much coincidence and taken a boring tangent again by featuring Arkady's pseudo-adopted ward, Zhenya, as his unwilling sidekick of sorts. Most of the events occur in the novel with little note of significance, even though we know they should be either important or suspenseful.
Not as dreadful as his two preceding novels, this one still pales in comparison to Gorky Park and Rose.
Martin Cruz Smith has long been a favorite author of mine--starting with Gorky Park right on until Wolves Eat Dogs. However, he had lost his way with his next two novels, and so I approached Tatiana with apprehension. What I got was a slightly better story, but it felt like Martin Cruz Smith-lite. The narrative is lighter and the subject matter is less weighty and less thought-provoking. Part of this can be explained by his recent revelation that he has been suffering from Parkinson's disease for almost two decades and that the last several years have been quite difficult for him. However, the novel is what it is: a shadow of his former greatness.
We get a more interesting setting this time round--Kaliningrad, a Russian oblast physically cut off from the rest of the country. We learn about the area, the buildings, the birdwatchers, and the amber--none of which play much of a part in the plot, but interesting to learn about nonetheless. The plot has devolved into too much coincidence and taken a boring tangent again by featuring Arkady's pseudo-adopted ward, Zhenya, as his unwilling sidekick of sorts. Most of the events occur in the novel with little note of significance, even though we know they should be either important or suspenseful.
Not as dreadful as his two preceding novels, this one still pales in comparison to Gorky Park and Rose.
jayyenn's review
3.0
I received a copy of this book through a First Reads giveaway
I loved Gorky Park which is the only other Arkady Renko novel I've read. Tatiana is a much lighter read. It lacks the depth and complexity of Gorky Park leaving mostly just the trappings of a typical hard-boiled story. I thought there were too many tangents for such a short novel but that tends to happen in a series. That being said you don't need to read any of the previous books to get Tatiana.
The book provides a view of modern Russia through the eponymous subject of Renko's investigation and her reporting on corruption in finance and government. The character Tatiana is based on Anna Politkovskaya, a Russian journalist murdered in 2006. Tatiana's murder is officially ruled a suicide but Renko begins investigating when her body is lost. This leads him to discover her audio recordings of her coverage of events such as the Kursk submarine explosion and the Moscow theatre hostage crisis. Renko falls in love with the voice on the tapes and becomes obsessive in his investigation. A large part of the plot centers around a notebook written in code but this is mostly a macguffin. As a procedural it really didn't have enough actual investigation and I didn't get much of a sense of urgency. The resolution is very open-ended which I liked; this isn't a whodunnit to be solved by pointing a finger or killing someone.
Tatiana is an entertaining read and the dialogue and characters are fresh. I enjoyed going to Wikipedia to check references in the book such as the House of Soviets in Kaliningrad. (They really did just paint it blue for Putin's visit)
I loved Gorky Park which is the only other Arkady Renko novel I've read. Tatiana is a much lighter read. It lacks the depth and complexity of Gorky Park leaving mostly just the trappings of a typical hard-boiled story. I thought there were too many tangents for such a short novel but that tends to happen in a series. That being said you don't need to read any of the previous books to get Tatiana.
The book provides a view of modern Russia through the eponymous subject of Renko's investigation and her reporting on corruption in finance and government. The character Tatiana is based on Anna Politkovskaya, a Russian journalist murdered in 2006. Tatiana's murder is officially ruled a suicide but Renko begins investigating when her body is lost. This leads him to discover her audio recordings of her coverage of events such as the Kursk submarine explosion and the Moscow theatre hostage crisis. Renko falls in love with the voice on the tapes and becomes obsessive in his investigation. A large part of the plot centers around a notebook written in code but this is mostly a macguffin. As a procedural it really didn't have enough actual investigation and I didn't get much of a sense of urgency. The resolution is very open-ended which I liked; this isn't a whodunnit to be solved by pointing a finger or killing someone.
Tatiana is an entertaining read and the dialogue and characters are fresh. I enjoyed going to Wikipedia to check references in the book such as the House of Soviets in Kaliningrad. (They really did just paint it blue for Putin's visit)