You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

185 reviews for:

Where I Was from

Joan Didion

3.79 AVERAGE

challenging informative reflective relaxing slow-paced
dark informative reflective slow-paced

i wouldn’t call it succinct, but this book is enlightening on many levels for native californians. amazing reflection of the struggle of the state
emotional informative inspiring reflective

why isn't this book regarded as some of her best, like "the year of magical thinking" and "slouching towards bethelehem"?

a book for californians past, present, and future. whether you love the state or hate it... read it. truly one of the best pieces of writing about california by one of the best californian writers. didion explores the tensions and contradictions in california's history, as well as its residents' cultures and beliefs. the book is a blend of historical review, literary criticism, research, and memoir. 
informative reflective slow-paced
challenging emotional funny informative reflective slow-paced
lbhreads's profile picture

lbhreads's review

2.5

instead of a memoir, this is more of a historical account of didion’s heritage and ancestry in california. i can imagine this would be interesting to some, particularly native californians who would enjoy learning about the history of their home state, but unfortunately it wasn’t what i was looking for, nor what i was expecting due to this book being labelled as joan didion’s ‘first ever memoir’, which it isn’t. but there’s no denying that didion is a fantastic writer, and i enjoyed the last 50 or so pages the most.

very much California to it’s core, felt very familiar

As several people have already mentioned here, this is a disjointed attempt at a cohesive book. Split into four sections, this is more of a hodgepodge of reportage than the California memoir that I had hoped for. In fact, Didion seems to have culled a couple pieces from the past that she then incorporated into this, in addition to examining and analyzing her first novel. This isn't bad, and there truly are some interesting insights on her California life and the State's history, but it's not too solid of a work either.
reflective medium-paced

clairesodium's review

4.0

as with all didion, this is beautifully written and rigorously researched. i didn’t find quite as engaging as some of her other works but still gorgeous and deeply provoking.