Reviews

The Noose by Philip MacDonald

maccymacd's review

Go to review page

3.0

Okay, I found this overall an interesting read, and I was really impressed with the ending and the surprise of who the murderer was which I definitely didn't guess. However, a lot of the book seemed to drag for me and I found it was mostly filler recapping the same points. I was rather disappointed as this was one of my first Detective Club offerings, but I should think I will try and pick up some others, just maybe no more by Philip MacDonald.

theoclarke's review

Go to review page

2.0

This felt too conversational to be a satisfying crime mystery. I did not engage with the characters or the plot.
More...