Scan barcode
sheranel's review against another edition
dark
emotional
informative
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
kathydavie's review against another edition
5.0
Sixth in the Maisie Dobbs historical mystery series and revolving around a female private investigator with a unique perspective on crime. Takes place in England in late 1931.
My Take
This is truly sad and demonstrates that no matter how "enlightened", governments stay the same, using up their young men and throwing them away when they're useless or no longer needed. By the government. The one advance we seem to have made is that PTSD is recognized now and not automatically considered cowardice.
It's an interesting change as Miss Dobbs is brought in to interact with law enforcement. She's a strong woman who intends to include her ways of working, and while skeptical, I suspect they'll be incorporating some of her methods in future. I do love her insistence on getting paid — go, Maisie! I particularly like how she treats Urquhart!
I suspect there's a sea change being set up in this one with possibilities opening up for Maisie with Special Branch and MI5. As well as a possible future romance. A curious one.
I would have liked to think we were a compassionate people, but after reading what the establishment does to Doreen in the nuthouse. Jesus. It does make me wonder how much better we'll be at treating depression 80-some years in our future. Winspear has a curious balance in this: the lower class Doreen's depression over losing Lizzie and the upper class Priscilla's own depression. It's different ends of the social spectrum and shows that money truly can't buy happiness. Of course, I'd rather be miserable with money than without...
It's also fascinating to "watch" Maisie profile their target. Dang, she's good!
There is also more personal growth for Maisie with her realizing her need to make her flat a home. Pictures make a good start.
I love the sense of history and reality Winspear brings to this series. The manners, how women and different social classes are perceived. The need for introductions. The medical conditions and treatments available at the time. Naturally, I also adore Maisie Dobbs. She's a strong woman, a trailblazer who doesn't believe being a woman is weak or incapable.
The Story
An act of terrorism, a crippled man unable to work and dismissed as "capable" by the War Department resorts to a grenade in a crowded street at Christmas. It's followed up by threatening letters to the Home Secretary and the Prime Minister with one particular demand—that Maisie Dobbs be a part of the investigation.
Miss Dobbs find herself working closely with Special Branch and MI5, and yes, there will be clashes between this free-thinking and very moral woman and the mistrusting self-interests of a government intent on secrecy.
The Characters
Maisie Dobbs is a psychologist and private investigator incorporating psychology in her investigative and questioning techniques. Her use of the yogic discipline is much less obvious, which is a shame. Frankie is Maisie's dad, and he works as the head of stables at Lord and Lady Compton's country home. Jook is his lurcher. Priscilla is Maisie's best friend; Douglas is her husband and a poet. Tarquin, Thomas, and Timothy are their children.
Billy Beale is Maisie's assistant, who still suffers from his wounds in World War I, and married to the very depressed Doreen. Lizzie is the daughter who died in Messenger of Truth, 4. Young Billy and Bobby are their surviving children.
Scotland Yard, Special Branch, and MI5
Detective Inspector Richard Stratton had dated Maisie briefly; he still hopes. Detective Sergeant Caldwell is his assistant (who can't stand Maisie). Detective Chief Superintendent Robert MacFarlane is in charge of Special Branch. Colm Darby seems to be MacFarlane's aide. Gerald Urquhart is with MI5.
Dr. Anthony Laurence is an expert in psychological trauma and is situated at the Princess Victoria Hospital. Croucher is a veteran with memory issues who works as a porter at the hospital. Professor John Gale is a chemist and physicist at Oxford University. Christopher Anton and Walter Mason are scientists under Gale. Dr. Rigby is in charge of the Foundling Hospital. Sydney Oliver is a very dedicated teacher there; his wife, Amelia, taught housekeeping. Their son, Stephen, was a math genius.
Bert Shorter is one of the witnesses at the bombing. Ian Jennings liked to read. Mr. Tinsley has a very crowded used bookstore.
Mr. Baldwin is Lord President of the Council; Mr. Tryon is the Minister for Pensions; Ramsay MacDonald is Prime Minister; and, Robinson is the police commissioner. Oswald Mosley's brand of Fascism is displayed.
Maisie is working to get Doreen transferred to Dr. Elsbeth Masters at the Clifton Hospital.
Lady Rowan Compton was Maisie's patron when she was younger. Dr. Maurice Blanche taught Maisie psychology and how to use yoga to investigate when she was acting as his assistant.
The Cover
The cover is a woodcut style with an old building in silhouette in the dusky blue background, birds circling its roof, its upper floor windows lit up allowing for a silhouette in one to spy on Maisie. A Maisie in one of her new red jackets, a cloche hat, and a dark blue skirt, carrying a portfolio in one hand, the other hand stable on the fender of her little red MG.
The title is where she seeks, Among the Mad, but who are the real inmates in this one?
My Take
This is truly sad and demonstrates that no matter how "enlightened", governments stay the same, using up their young men and throwing them away when they're useless or no longer needed. By the government. The one advance we seem to have made is that PTSD is recognized now and not automatically considered cowardice.
It's an interesting change as Miss Dobbs is brought in to interact with law enforcement. She's a strong woman who intends to include her ways of working, and while skeptical, I suspect they'll be incorporating some of her methods in future. I do love her insistence on getting paid — go, Maisie! I particularly like how she treats Urquhart!
I suspect there's a sea change being set up in this one with possibilities opening up for Maisie with Special Branch and MI5. As well as a possible future romance. A curious one.
I would have liked to think we were a compassionate people, but after reading what the establishment does to Doreen in the nuthouse. Jesus. It does make me wonder how much better we'll be at treating depression 80-some years in our future. Winspear has a curious balance in this: the lower class Doreen's depression over losing Lizzie and the upper class Priscilla's own depression. It's different ends of the social spectrum and shows that money truly can't buy happiness. Of course, I'd rather be miserable with money than without...
It's also fascinating to "watch" Maisie profile their target. Dang, she's good!
There is also more personal growth for Maisie with her realizing her need to make her flat a home. Pictures make a good start.
I love the sense of history and reality Winspear brings to this series. The manners, how women and different social classes are perceived. The need for introductions. The medical conditions and treatments available at the time. Naturally, I also adore Maisie Dobbs. She's a strong woman, a trailblazer who doesn't believe being a woman is weak or incapable.
The Story
An act of terrorism, a crippled man unable to work and dismissed as "capable" by the War Department resorts to a grenade in a crowded street at Christmas. It's followed up by threatening letters to the Home Secretary and the Prime Minister with one particular demand—that Maisie Dobbs be a part of the investigation.
Miss Dobbs find herself working closely with Special Branch and MI5, and yes, there will be clashes between this free-thinking and very moral woman and the mistrusting self-interests of a government intent on secrecy.
The Characters
Maisie Dobbs is a psychologist and private investigator incorporating psychology in her investigative and questioning techniques. Her use of the yogic discipline is much less obvious, which is a shame. Frankie is Maisie's dad, and he works as the head of stables at Lord and Lady Compton's country home. Jook is his lurcher. Priscilla is Maisie's best friend; Douglas is her husband and a poet. Tarquin, Thomas, and Timothy are their children.
Billy Beale is Maisie's assistant, who still suffers from his wounds in World War I, and married to the very depressed Doreen. Lizzie is the daughter who died in Messenger of Truth, 4. Young Billy and Bobby are their surviving children.
Scotland Yard, Special Branch, and MI5
Detective Inspector Richard Stratton had dated Maisie briefly; he still hopes. Detective Sergeant Caldwell is his assistant (who can't stand Maisie). Detective Chief Superintendent Robert MacFarlane is in charge of Special Branch. Colm Darby seems to be MacFarlane's aide. Gerald Urquhart is with MI5.
Dr. Anthony Laurence is an expert in psychological trauma and is situated at the Princess Victoria Hospital. Croucher is a veteran with memory issues who works as a porter at the hospital. Professor John Gale is a chemist and physicist at Oxford University. Christopher Anton and Walter Mason are scientists under Gale. Dr. Rigby is in charge of the Foundling Hospital. Sydney Oliver is a very dedicated teacher there; his wife, Amelia, taught housekeeping. Their son, Stephen, was a math genius.
Bert Shorter is one of the witnesses at the bombing. Ian Jennings liked to read. Mr. Tinsley has a very crowded used bookstore.
Mr. Baldwin is Lord President of the Council; Mr. Tryon is the Minister for Pensions; Ramsay MacDonald is Prime Minister; and, Robinson is the police commissioner. Oswald Mosley's brand of Fascism is displayed.
Maisie is working to get Doreen transferred to Dr. Elsbeth Masters at the Clifton Hospital.
Lady Rowan Compton was Maisie's patron when she was younger. Dr. Maurice Blanche taught Maisie psychology and how to use yoga to investigate when she was acting as his assistant.
The Cover
The cover is a woodcut style with an old building in silhouette in the dusky blue background, birds circling its roof, its upper floor windows lit up allowing for a silhouette in one to spy on Maisie. A Maisie in one of her new red jackets, a cloche hat, and a dark blue skirt, carrying a portfolio in one hand, the other hand stable on the fender of her little red MG.
The title is where she seeks, Among the Mad, but who are the real inmates in this one?
chaz_dickens's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
informative
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
medium-paced
4.5
lydiaann's review
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
informative
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
mrsjdoc's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
emotional
mysterious
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? N/A
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
melissa_who_reads's review against another edition
4.0
Another wonderful book, again dealing with those still wounded by the First World War, this time not only with physical ailments but also mental ailments. A madman is threatening to set off poison gas in London: his demands are for better pensions and care for the war wounded: including those who were under-counted because of the government's fear of liability for "shell-shock."
Maisie is forced to work with a team this time: she is seconded to the Special Branch. She doesn't care for the representative from the MI5, but in the end they manage to save London - though not change the plight of the nation's veterans during the Great Depression.
One of the best bits is a small note about her father's concern for her: Maisie herself is one of the war-traumatized, and her only remaining family member is well-aware of her remaining scars, and how easily they could open again.
Maisie is forced to work with a team this time: she is seconded to the Special Branch. She doesn't care for the representative from the MI5, but in the end they manage to save London - though not change the plight of the nation's veterans during the Great Depression.
One of the best bits is a small note about her father's concern for her: Maisie herself is one of the war-traumatized, and her only remaining family member is well-aware of her remaining scars, and how easily they could open again.
mouseczko's review against another edition
dark
emotional
informative
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
sroot45's review against another edition
emotional
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
4.0