Reviews

The Red Record by Ida B. Wells-Barnett

cydbeefree's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

To be honest, I didn't finish reading this book. It was too disturbing and I had to stop reading it.

vivifriend's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Necessary

This should be required reading for all students of U.S. history. It is sometimes a bit hard to read but the information is important.

stacie_w_books's review

Go to review page

5.0

There are so many aspects of history in the United States that are not openly discussed. The ramifications of an open discussion would lead people to recognize the true horror that is the African American experience in this country. I always find it fascinating that compared to the horrors of the past, Black people should now feel relatively safe, but that isn’t the case for many. Why? Because many of us are very aware of the past, the injustices that occurred and the scars that have been passed through history because of such violence. Scars that are never given the opportunity to heal. The Red Record was published in 1895 and is an open discussion by Wells of the Lynch Law of the time. Why is it so powerful? Because it lays bare the complete absence of value on the lives of African Americans. Because it proves that an African American could die at the whim of the mob, body flaming on the ground, or swinging from a tree while riddled with bullets. That most of the time law and order did not take place and no one was ever charged with the lynching. No one was ever persecuted. But a life was taken and everyone went on about their lives. Except for the women, children and family members whose loved one was accused and then viciously murdered.

Some people don’t want to talk about this part of history. It's easier to imagine that a wrong was made right when slaves were set free and that there was a rough patch in time when the Civil Rights movement was necessary. No one likes to talk about the time in between. I needed to read The Red Record because I needed to see the proof of that time. I have made a choice to confront history head on so I can better confront the position the United States is currently in as a country. It's disgusting that a book written so many years ago is so very relevant to 2017. It provides a bridge of understanding with painstaking reflection. But in a time when people are asking for their lives to matter, it’s easy to look back and see that for a long time they haven’t. The proof is in the history and we still have to keep fighting for change.

This book is a necessary read. Especially now when the fight for social justice still rages and lives are still taken. Wells was a voice for justice then and her words still matter now. I give this 5 out of 5 stars.

akagingerk's review

Go to review page

3.0

Important & visceral, but difficult to read due to style/repetition between chapters.

audreylee's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Ida B. Wells was a warrior of the antilynching campaign. Her life was threatened and she was exiled from her home due to her activism. In this pamphlet, she enumerates the lynchings over a specific amount of time, the "reasons" for those lynchings, and the facts that showed the lawlessness practiced by the mobs to be brutally unjust. She has no time for hand holding.

miguel's review

Go to review page

5.0

Ida B. Wells's germinal argument against lynching and in favor of due process and equal protection under the law is stupendous, prescient, horrifying, and shameful. America's national shame is far beyond chattel slavery and extends to the absurd racial injustices today, which have far more in common with "lynch law" than chattel slavery or Jim Crow.

Wells's journalistic skill makes The Red Record an important model for the in-house style of news-editorial magazines like The New Yorker. The political importance of the text, then, coincides with the formal value. Wells brings the statistics she draws from the records of lynching alive with vivid narrativization in the method readers have come to expect by talented contemporary essayists. Wells, then, truly paints red the records she consults.

The text's contemporary resonance makes it all the more difficult to read. The spectacular murders of Black men, women, and children without due process and equal protection under the law are constantly circulated in news reports and via social media. Worse, still, often these murders are perpetrated by agents of the law. Wells argues that those who possess institutional power must assert that power to stop lynching. The same could be said today, as those judicial and governmental officials sit, at best, paying lip service to the plight of Black people in this country, or at worse in complete denial.
More...