Take a photo of a barcode or cover
skolastic's review against another edition
5.0
Mignola and Davis coming together on BPRD is absolutely killer. I was very nervous about this after the first two entries and I can’t wait to see what’s next.
booknooknoggin's review against another edition
4.0
This was worth reading just to see Abe Sapian's origin story. Also picks up from Hellboy: Seed of Destruction. Great art as always, and a good story.
owen's review against another edition
5.0
I recently re-read the full Plague of Frogs saga as detailed in the B.P.R.D. comics by Mignola, Arcudi, Davies, and others.
As others have mentioned, Vol 3 is where it really gets good.
The first two volumes (with necessary readings from some past Hellboy comics which are unfortunately collected elsewhere) start some needed plot points and introduce these fully three-dimensional characters (albeit drawn beautifully on 2-D pages). When you get to Vol 3 you're already a fan of Abe, Liz, Kate, Roger, Johann, and the rest.
The Universal Machine does a fantastic job of outlining origin stories while detailing an adventure starring Kate Corrigan. While finally hearing Daimio's backstory is great, I really enjoyed the idea that by using her knowledge, Kate is just as capable of surviving in the field as Abe or Hellboy himself. Sometimes there's no need to punch problems to get to solutions. And all of it circles back to Roger's fate from the last volume - in a sense, this first part of the book is just about friends mourning the passing of a loved one. It's poignant.
Garden of Souls is a great Abe tale with some striking visual designs (those robots are fun). It also gives us more Daimio, which is necessary given the final part, Killing Ground.
Killing Ground is possible my favourite B.P.R.D. limited series. Johann's story arc is tragic here, while being brilliantly comical. The way past plot points come together, the questions of what does it mean to be human? To be a hero or villain? Good vs. bad... there's a lot of deep themes explored. The art feels claustrophobic when needed, there's a solid action-movie vibe to many of the scenes. The ending isn't as much of a shock as Vol 2, but is still pretty unexpected.
Ultimately, Vol 1-2 are build-up, and the action escalates so much in Vol 4 that the pacing feels a bit off. This, Vol 3, is the epitome of a good B.P.R.D comic and why I enjoy this series so much - it's a collection of flawed individuals doing their best to figure out their own stories and place in the world, while struggling with the weight of fighting wars they don't understand or even know they're a part of. That's the Mignola secret - his protagonists, and readers, only ever get a glimpse into what seems like nothing short of an epic, fantastical world of magic, prophecies, and mythical creatures. The revelations start to build, there's great character development, and then finally everything blows up.
As others have mentioned, Vol 3 is where it really gets good.
The first two volumes (with necessary readings from some past Hellboy comics which are unfortunately collected elsewhere) start some needed plot points and introduce these fully three-dimensional characters (albeit drawn beautifully on 2-D pages). When you get to Vol 3 you're already a fan of Abe, Liz, Kate, Roger, Johann, and the rest.
The Universal Machine does a fantastic job of outlining origin stories while detailing an adventure starring Kate Corrigan. While finally hearing Daimio's backstory is great, I really enjoyed the idea that by using her knowledge, Kate is just as capable of surviving in the field as Abe or Hellboy himself. Sometimes there's no need to punch problems to get to solutions. And all of it circles back to Roger's fate from the last volume - in a sense, this first part of the book is just about friends mourning the passing of a loved one. It's poignant.
Garden of Souls is a great Abe tale with some striking visual designs (those robots are fun). It also gives us more Daimio, which is necessary given the final part, Killing Ground.
Killing Ground is possible my favourite B.P.R.D. limited series. Johann's story arc is tragic here, while being brilliantly comical. The way past plot points come together, the questions of what does it mean to be human? To be a hero or villain? Good vs. bad... there's a lot of deep themes explored. The art feels claustrophobic when needed, there's a solid action-movie vibe to many of the scenes. The ending isn't as much of a shock as Vol 2, but is still pretty unexpected.
Ultimately, Vol 1-2 are build-up, and the action escalates so much in Vol 4 that the pacing feels a bit off. This, Vol 3, is the epitome of a good B.P.R.D comic and why I enjoy this series so much - it's a collection of flawed individuals doing their best to figure out their own stories and place in the world, while struggling with the weight of fighting wars they don't understand or even know they're a part of. That's the Mignola secret - his protagonists, and readers, only ever get a glimpse into what seems like nothing short of an epic, fantastical world of magic, prophecies, and mythical creatures. The revelations start to build, there's great character development, and then finally everything blows up.