Scan barcode
awhitehouse's review
2.5
a bit disappointing as i love her other stuff but these are basically just abt her dad and not very interesting
drcaligari's review
4.0
the pilgrims, the dream ☆, the false rhyme, the invisible girl ☆, the mourner.
parisreads_pc's review
4.0
I found the first 3 stories pretty uninteresting but very dramatic, but then the last 2, 'The Invisible Girl' and 'The Mourner' were absolutely fantastic.
While it is aguable that the first 3 stories are initially each depressing in there situations I find that they have happier endings which I don't necessarily care for.
However, the last 2 stories had such a strong sense of melancholy wonder that even the ending was so greatly attune to the authors depression. I wish I could have such a fine understanding and respect for sadness and despair.
I did write a review of the invisible girl after reading it because I just felt so strongly for Rosina and the imagery associated with that small story.
While it is aguable that the first 3 stories are initially each depressing in there situations I find that they have happier endings which I don't necessarily care for.
However, the last 2 stories had such a strong sense of melancholy wonder that even the ending was so greatly attune to the authors depression. I wish I could have such a fine understanding and respect for sadness and despair.
I did write a review of the invisible girl after reading it because I just felt so strongly for Rosina and the imagery associated with that small story.
missjaneeyre's review
3.0
Though written and set in the early 1800s, these stories reminded me of medieval romances. Vocabulary increased by +12 words :)
bookwomble's review
4.0
For no good reason, I stalled for nearly a year part way through this book. Somehow, I couldn't get into it: started, stopped, restarted, stopped, restarted from the beginning, stopped - uhh! Then, picked it up towards the end of the year and polished it off in one sitting. I think it was me rather than Mary :-)
It's a slim volume of only ninety-nine pages, containing five stories of a Gothic Romance persuasion. I don't think there's anything in here that breaks new ground, but they are (when you're in the right frame of mind!) interesting and engaging tales of their kind.
My preferred stories in the collection are the last two, The Invisible Girl and The Mourner. Thunder, stormy seas, lost lovers and enduring loyalty. I'm sure there's something in the idea of a period TV mini-series of Shelley's Gothic romances.
It's a slim volume of only ninety-nine pages, containing five stories of a Gothic Romance persuasion. I don't think there's anything in here that breaks new ground, but they are (when you're in the right frame of mind!) interesting and engaging tales of their kind.
My preferred stories in the collection are the last two, The Invisible Girl and The Mourner. Thunder, stormy seas, lost lovers and enduring loyalty. I'm sure there's something in the idea of a period TV mini-series of Shelley's Gothic romances.
joecam79's review
4.0
This is the second Mary Shelley anthology to be published in the Hesperus Classics series. The first one, built around the eerie supernatural tale [b:Transformation|960450|Transformation|Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1295807297s/960450.jpg|1626634], emphasized the eclecticism of Shelley's fantastic fiction, from the diablerie of the title tale to the proto-scifi of "The Mortal Immortal" (see review here: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/1234310015?book_show_action=false ).
On the other hand, all the five stories in this collection fall squarely within the classic "Gothic" genre, sharing such familiar tropes as decaying castles/towers, family feuds, mistaken identities, lovelorn maidens, forbidding atmospheric conditions (storms, mists and rain keep the weatherman busy) and protagonists prone to fainting at every unexpected twist of the plot. The first three stories: "The Pilgrims", "The Dream" and "The False Rhyme" also share a medieval, chivalric setting and deliberately archaic dialogue which makes them come across as the literary equivalent of Pre-Raphaelite paintings.
But there are deeper concerns at work here than just the telling of a good tale. As novelist Kamila Shamsie points out in her insightful foreword, all the stories share a theme very close to Shelley's heart - the uncomfortable triangle between father, daughter and lover. It is only natural to draw a parallel with the life-story of the author herself - young Mary had incurred the wrath of a father she greatly loved when she eloped with poet Percy Bysshe Shelley. With this context in mind, it is hard not to be moved by these works, particularly the poignant "The Mourner" which brings the volume to an emotionally shattering close.
On the other hand, all the five stories in this collection fall squarely within the classic "Gothic" genre, sharing such familiar tropes as decaying castles/towers, family feuds, mistaken identities, lovelorn maidens, forbidding atmospheric conditions (storms, mists and rain keep the weatherman busy) and protagonists prone to fainting at every unexpected twist of the plot. The first three stories: "The Pilgrims", "The Dream" and "The False Rhyme" also share a medieval, chivalric setting and deliberately archaic dialogue which makes them come across as the literary equivalent of Pre-Raphaelite paintings.
But there are deeper concerns at work here than just the telling of a good tale. As novelist Kamila Shamsie points out in her insightful foreword, all the stories share a theme very close to Shelley's heart - the uncomfortable triangle between father, daughter and lover. It is only natural to draw a parallel with the life-story of the author herself - young Mary had incurred the wrath of a father she greatly loved when she eloped with poet Percy Bysshe Shelley. With this context in mind, it is hard not to be moved by these works, particularly the poignant "The Mourner" which brings the volume to an emotionally shattering close.
More...