Scan barcode
rentabilidad_'s review against another edition
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
ars_poetica's review against another edition
3.0
Un libro de la infancia que despertó mi curiosidad por ver y comprobar cómo habían tratado al célebre detective escrito por Conan Doyle.
Cuando era pequeña me gustó mucho y continué la saga hasta el tercer libro; actualmente me ha parecido una lectura amena, ágil y entretenida gracias a su aventura con encanto y cadáver incluidos.
Cuando era pequeña me gustó mucho y continué la saga hasta el tercer libro; actualmente me ha parecido una lectura amena, ágil y entretenida gracias a su aventura con encanto y cadáver incluidos.
arberry's review
2.0
An ok book. Definitely meant for younger readers. My 3rd grade self would probably have given this a 3.
iwannaberorygilmore's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.75
krysreads's review against another edition
3.0
Via Black 'n Write Review
My final thoughts:
As our introduction is done we meet the three young protagonists of a new series, Sherlock, Lupin and Me, or as Goodreads listed as “Sherlock, Lupin and I”. I’ll go by what the book says.
Our narrator is Irene Adler. This young lady comes from Paris with her mother to a small town of Saint-Malo as per her father’s insistence would make a lovely locale for summer holidays. On her adventure to escape the demands of her mother we meet Sherlock who also goes by William, and later he introduces us to Arsène Lupin, or better known as Lupin.
After a few days of Irene’s arrival the trio find a dead man on the beach and go on their grand mystery tour of interrogating and investigating the who,what and whys of The Man with Three Names. Later solving the big mystery as well as figuring out a few other things along the way.
Needless to say I was slightly thrown off by the narrator’s opening sentence of being Sherlock’s first girlfriend. Why would I be confused you ask, well, between the awkward near-moments between Irene and Lupin, and the closeness of Sherlock and Irene shared there was never one moment that could officiate any of them to be in a relationship or even just hints of becoming a couple. I was a little disappointed really, since I thought for sure the way Lupin always seemed gobsmacked around Irene that they would’ve been the ideal couple.
However, I could be easily misunderstanding the story and that really the reason there is a series is because, perhaps, the second book will reveal a relationship or the spark of one. Right now the three are just a group of friends who enjoy each others quick witticism and the ability to one-up the efforts of making a joke, or later on training techniques.
I will award this book 3.5 stars. I do, however, look forward to the release of the second book in the future.
- Krys
My final thoughts:
As our introduction is done we meet the three young protagonists of a new series, Sherlock, Lupin and Me, or as Goodreads listed as “Sherlock, Lupin and I”. I’ll go by what the book says.
Our narrator is Irene Adler. This young lady comes from Paris with her mother to a small town of Saint-Malo as per her father’s insistence would make a lovely locale for summer holidays. On her adventure to escape the demands of her mother we meet Sherlock who also goes by William, and later he introduces us to Arsène Lupin, or better known as Lupin.
After a few days of Irene’s arrival the trio find a dead man on the beach and go on their grand mystery tour of interrogating and investigating the who,what and whys of The Man with Three Names. Later solving the big mystery as well as figuring out a few other things along the way.
Needless to say I was slightly thrown off by the narrator’s opening sentence of being Sherlock’s first girlfriend. Why would I be confused you ask, well, between the awkward near-moments between Irene and Lupin, and the closeness of Sherlock and Irene shared there was never one moment that could officiate any of them to be in a relationship or even just hints of becoming a couple. I was a little disappointed really, since I thought for sure the way Lupin always seemed gobsmacked around Irene that they would’ve been the ideal couple.
However, I could be easily misunderstanding the story and that really the reason there is a series is because, perhaps, the second book will reveal a relationship or the spark of one. Right now the three are just a group of friends who enjoy each others quick witticism and the ability to one-up the efforts of making a joke, or later on training techniques.
I will award this book 3.5 stars. I do, however, look forward to the release of the second book in the future.
- Krys
antiasreadings's review against another edition
3.0
Todo lo que sea sobre Sherlock siempre me acaba gustando, ¡y este libro no iba a ser menos!. En esta novela tenemos a un joven Sherlock en un pueblo costero de veraneo en Francia, parece un lugar tranquilo y ameno hasta que comienzan a suceder sucesos inesperado: un "náufrago" aparece muerto en la playa y a una señora le roban un collar de diamantes. El pequeño detective no se embarcará solo en esta aventura sino que le acompañarán sus amigos Arsène Lupin e Irene Adler.
Para leer más: http://antiasreadings.blogspot.com/2018/08/sherlock-lupin-y-yo-irene-adler.html
Para leer más: http://antiasreadings.blogspot.com/2018/08/sherlock-lupin-y-yo-irene-adler.html
aliceccbg's review against another edition
3.0
I love mystery since I was little and those were my favourite books when i was like 11.
luciiee's review against another edition
4.0
Un middle grade que j’aurais aimé découvrir quand j’avais 12 ans mais que j’ai autant adoré a 17 ! J’ai adoré la façon dont l’auteur a repris les personnages d’Irene Adler, d’Arsene Lupin et de Sherlock Holmes pour en faire une bande d’amis perspicaces au potentiel incroyable. J’ai hâte de lire la suite de cette saga !
vasiliki_21's review against another edition
3.0
(Το έχω διαβάσει στα ελληνικά ). Μου άρεσε αρκετά αν και το βρήκα σε πολλά σημεια να κάνει κοιλιά και να είναι πολύ αναμενόμενο. Θα του έβαζα 2 αστέρια αλλά επειδή ξετρελάθηκα με μία στιγμή( την οποία δεν θέλω να κάνω σπόιλερ) του έβαλα 3.