Scan barcode
11corvus11's review
5.0
Content Warning: This review includes mention (but no gratuitous descriptions or analyses) of sexual violence.
I don't know exactly what I expected going into Tiffany Watt Smith's SHADENFREUDE: The Joy of Another's Misfortune. I think perhaps since I have a bit of a psychology background, I expected an interesting but somewhat dry psychological analysis of the phenomenon. This book was far more than that. I thoroughly enjoyed every second of this little text and laughed out loud at many of the anecdotes and analyses. Perhaps that says more about me than it does about the book.
Smith uses psychology, neuroscience, philosophy, sociology, gender studies, pop culture, and other vehicles to examine the subject in very entertaining ways. She visits experts and gets their take, often detailing entertaining or moving conversations. She packs quite a lot into a small space from celebrating sports injuries to fmylife.com to #metoo and more. The book is broken up into different kinds of schadenfreude and different times that it presents itself. The beginning of each of these sections has three or so anecdotes of schadenfreude happening- most (or perhaps all) of which describe or mirror real life events. Gems like:
...at a family lunch, your parents mention how lovely your brother's children are, and it absolutely definitely sounds like they're really saying that your brother's kids are nicer than your kids, and then your brother's kid comes in sobbing with chocolate smeared all over his face, and screams: "Grandma's a fucking bitch!"
When a married anti-LGBT senator is caught having sex with a man in his office.
And, I would like to add two that I thought of repeatedly throughout the book that were not included, perhaps because it is about to get real dark in here:
When Daniel Holtzclaw- police officer and serial rapist mainly targeting Black women- was in tears after being found guilty of multiple rapes and sexual assaults, with a recommended sentence of 263 years, ON HIS BIRTHDAY.
When white supremacist/alt-right/nazi Richard Spencer was punched in the face during a news interview.
Both of these instances brought people out of the woodwork who claimed they normally don't celebrate pain and violence, but would make an exception in these cases. I have to agree. And some great memes came out of them.
There were some anecdotes Smith included I did not find funny. But, most of them at least made me smirk. It was an interesting experience as I often see myself as less inclined towards schadenfreude than average. Having read this book, I now believe that is not true, especially regarding schadenfreude that offers some form of poetic justice. The book helped me better understand and accept this rather than beating me down as bad for feeling it. Smith truly shows how schadenfreude is woven throughout all of our interactions and how it can serve certain social purposes. I knew a little bit about schadenfreude going in. I did not know that there is a separate word for it in a great many other languages, showing it spreads across locations and cultures.
While there is variance between individuals in just how far they will go with their schadenfreude, a unifying theme is often a feeling that the person or people had it coming. The authors seems to differentiate between sadism and schadenfreude, the former being more of a description of enjoying (and often causing) suffering in general. Misogynists, racists, corrupt politicians, and others bring obvious schadenfreude, but there is also a reality that people who are smug, lack humility, or just have an easier more privileged life also invoke joy in others when they suffer. Smith examines these phenomena both generally and personally being candid and honest about her own feelings and experiences. As she tied up the book she mentions, "I had hoped for a happy ending. Something like... I am, in short, a better person. But you already know that's not true," I laughed out loud. Yet, she follows this with some pretty brilliant life advice regarding dealing with when we find ourselves the target of schadenfreude, especially from people close to us:
If you are the victim of someone else's schadenfreude, you are seen as a worthy opponent. You have- or had, but don't worry, you'll get it again- something they want. Think back to those times when you have enjoyed their losses. Unless you very much deserve your misery, (in which case, take a long hard look at yourself,) their glee will tell you a lot about how you've made them feel.
This really gave me a lot to chew on regarding schadenfreude (that isn't as clear cut as white supremacists deserving a punch to the face) in both directions. If you aren't quite able to see yourself as someone who finds joy in the misery of others at times, pick up this book and you'll find you are just as petty as the rest of us. And that's ok.
This review was also posted to my blog.
I don't know exactly what I expected going into Tiffany Watt Smith's SHADENFREUDE: The Joy of Another's Misfortune. I think perhaps since I have a bit of a psychology background, I expected an interesting but somewhat dry psychological analysis of the phenomenon. This book was far more than that. I thoroughly enjoyed every second of this little text and laughed out loud at many of the anecdotes and analyses. Perhaps that says more about me than it does about the book.
Smith uses psychology, neuroscience, philosophy, sociology, gender studies, pop culture, and other vehicles to examine the subject in very entertaining ways. She visits experts and gets their take, often detailing entertaining or moving conversations. She packs quite a lot into a small space from celebrating sports injuries to fmylife.com to #metoo and more. The book is broken up into different kinds of schadenfreude and different times that it presents itself. The beginning of each of these sections has three or so anecdotes of schadenfreude happening- most (or perhaps all) of which describe or mirror real life events. Gems like:
...at a family lunch, your parents mention how lovely your brother's children are, and it absolutely definitely sounds like they're really saying that your brother's kids are nicer than your kids, and then your brother's kid comes in sobbing with chocolate smeared all over his face, and screams: "Grandma's a fucking bitch!"
When a married anti-LGBT senator is caught having sex with a man in his office.
And, I would like to add two that I thought of repeatedly throughout the book that were not included, perhaps because it is about to get real dark in here:
When Daniel Holtzclaw- police officer and serial rapist mainly targeting Black women- was in tears after being found guilty of multiple rapes and sexual assaults, with a recommended sentence of 263 years, ON HIS BIRTHDAY.
When white supremacist/alt-right/nazi Richard Spencer was punched in the face during a news interview.
Both of these instances brought people out of the woodwork who claimed they normally don't celebrate pain and violence, but would make an exception in these cases. I have to agree. And some great memes came out of them.
There were some anecdotes Smith included I did not find funny. But, most of them at least made me smirk. It was an interesting experience as I often see myself as less inclined towards schadenfreude than average. Having read this book, I now believe that is not true, especially regarding schadenfreude that offers some form of poetic justice. The book helped me better understand and accept this rather than beating me down as bad for feeling it. Smith truly shows how schadenfreude is woven throughout all of our interactions and how it can serve certain social purposes. I knew a little bit about schadenfreude going in. I did not know that there is a separate word for it in a great many other languages, showing it spreads across locations and cultures.
While there is variance between individuals in just how far they will go with their schadenfreude, a unifying theme is often a feeling that the person or people had it coming. The authors seems to differentiate between sadism and schadenfreude, the former being more of a description of enjoying (and often causing) suffering in general. Misogynists, racists, corrupt politicians, and others bring obvious schadenfreude, but there is also a reality that people who are smug, lack humility, or just have an easier more privileged life also invoke joy in others when they suffer. Smith examines these phenomena both generally and personally being candid and honest about her own feelings and experiences. As she tied up the book she mentions, "I had hoped for a happy ending. Something like... I am, in short, a better person. But you already know that's not true," I laughed out loud. Yet, she follows this with some pretty brilliant life advice regarding dealing with when we find ourselves the target of schadenfreude, especially from people close to us:
If you are the victim of someone else's schadenfreude, you are seen as a worthy opponent. You have- or had, but don't worry, you'll get it again- something they want. Think back to those times when you have enjoyed their losses. Unless you very much deserve your misery, (in which case, take a long hard look at yourself,) their glee will tell you a lot about how you've made them feel.
This really gave me a lot to chew on regarding schadenfreude (that isn't as clear cut as white supremacists deserving a punch to the face) in both directions. If you aren't quite able to see yourself as someone who finds joy in the misery of others at times, pick up this book and you'll find you are just as petty as the rest of us. And that's ok.
This review was also posted to my blog.
teaganodders's review
funny
informative
lighthearted
reflective
slow-paced
3.75
Very interesting topic and well put together. I enjoyed the combination of historical and modern examples as well as the psychology behind them. Sadly, I couldn’t help but find the book boring and slow at times.
paulsnelling's review
2.0
I was expecting something a bit more challenging than some musing and a few funny stories. I can’t recall Nietzsche and Bertie Wooster in the same paragraph before. But it was an easy enough read.
radbear76's review
3.0
Provides some insights but at times classified what I consider irony as schadenfreude. Also the author goes a little overboard with examples that disrupt the flow of the point she's trying to make. At times it seems like she was trying to pad the number of pages because of a paucity of material. Ok but not recommended.
jonnyfox's review
4.0
It was short and sweet and gave an honest insight into a difficult word we all need to deal with
elnechnntt's review against another edition
4.0
A wondrous little assessment of a curious human condition. I loved the historical and cultural placement, alongside the reassurance that it isn’t a modern/social media thing (heaps and heaps of references from ancient great thinkers to the bible!).
As with many things in life, empathy for the self and others is key. Watt Smith finishes up her analysis by flipping the concept on its head and offering us the idea that Schadenfreude can actually be a positive cognitive process to work with. And tips on how to do this.
The little anecdotes shared within this book provide handy little pearls of amusement that will have you thinking ‘glad it’s not just me!’ and better yet, ‘at least I’m not that bad!’.
As with many things in life, empathy for the self and others is key. Watt Smith finishes up her analysis by flipping the concept on its head and offering us the idea that Schadenfreude can actually be a positive cognitive process to work with. And tips on how to do this.
The little anecdotes shared within this book provide handy little pearls of amusement that will have you thinking ‘glad it’s not just me!’ and better yet, ‘at least I’m not that bad!’.