Reviews

The Mammoth Book of New Sherlock Holmes Adventures by Amy Myers, Barbara Roden, Basil Copper, David Stuart Davies, Michael Moorcock, Richard Lancelyn Green, F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre, Roger Johnson, David Langford, Simon Clark, Lois H. Gresh, Edward D. Hoch, L.B. Greenwood, Guy N. Smith, Derek Wilson, Barrie Roberts, H.R.F. Keating, Mike Ashley, Eric Brown, Stephen Baxter, John Gregory Betancourt, Claire Griffen, Denis O. Smith, Robert Weinberg, Michael Doyle, Zakaria Erzincloglu, Martin Edwards

linwearcamenel's review

5.0

Really liked pretty much every story in here! Believable Holmes and Watson, very little forcing in of characters who don't belong. Good mix of dates, from Holmes's early career to his retirement, and plenty of Watson! Since I don't like pastiches (usually) that don't involve Watson. Recommended.

wyvernfriend's review

3.0

More 3.5 than 3 star but not quite 4 star.

Some interesting ideas and adventures, including two in Ireland. Now must research if Holmes being a Galwegian who attended Trinity is actual canon.