Scan barcode
leschroniques_delea's review against another edition
3.0
3,5/5
J'ai bien aimé ce premier tome mais je l'ai trouvé très introductif pour de la jeunesse. Je reste un peu mitigée sur ma lecture car j'ai beaucoup apprécié l'univers assez différent de ce qu'on peut voir en générale et les personnages qui sont très attachants.
Cependant, l'intrigue est très longue à se mettre en place et on attend un moment avant de comprendre quel est le problème et qui est "l'ennemi" de la famille. En effet avant qu'il apparaisse personne ne parlait d'une quelconque personne qui pourrait être dangereuse pour leur vie.
La fin pour moi a été un peu précipitée par rapport au dérouler de l'histoire et je me suis un peu ennuyée pendant ma lecture mais je pense que je lirai la suite pour avoir la réponse à une question qu'on a en fin de lecture.
Le point positif de l'histoire reste les personnages, comme je l'ai dis je me suis attachée à eux, l'auteur a réussi à montrer les différences et les peurs que peuvent connaître les enfants ou les adultes. A travers Mirabelle et sa famille de monstres il nous montre les différences. Jem et Tom sont deux humains orphelins qui ont subi pas mal de violence de la part de leur oncle et Mirabelle va les accepter parmi sa famille et devenir amie avec Jem. On a une belle histoire d'amitié et d'acceptation entre les personnages qui se crée ce que j'ai apprécié. Tom suite à un événement va prendre conscience de pas mal de chose et son comportement va changer, il va devenir plus altruiste et il va vouloir aider la famille à survivre face à leur ennemi.
J'ai bien aimé ce premier tome mais je l'ai trouvé très introductif pour de la jeunesse. Je reste un peu mitigée sur ma lecture car j'ai beaucoup apprécié l'univers assez différent de ce qu'on peut voir en générale et les personnages qui sont très attachants.
Cependant, l'intrigue est très longue à se mettre en place et on attend un moment avant de comprendre quel est le problème et qui est "l'ennemi" de la famille. En effet avant qu'il apparaisse personne ne parlait d'une quelconque personne qui pourrait être dangereuse pour leur vie.
La fin pour moi a été un peu précipitée par rapport au dérouler de l'histoire et je me suis un peu ennuyée pendant ma lecture mais je pense que je lirai la suite pour avoir la réponse à une question qu'on a en fin de lecture.
Le point positif de l'histoire reste les personnages, comme je l'ai dis je me suis attachée à eux, l'auteur a réussi à montrer les différences et les peurs que peuvent connaître les enfants ou les adultes. A travers Mirabelle et sa famille de monstres il nous montre les différences. Jem et Tom sont deux humains orphelins qui ont subi pas mal de violence de la part de leur oncle et Mirabelle va les accepter parmi sa famille et devenir amie avec Jem. On a une belle histoire d'amitié et d'acceptation entre les personnages qui se crée ce que j'ai apprécié. Tom suite à un événement va prendre conscience de pas mal de chose et son comportement va changer, il va devenir plus altruiste et il va vouloir aider la famille à survivre face à leur ennemi.
korennn's review against another edition
adventurous
inspiring
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
lsparrow's review against another edition
4.0
I enjoyed this book about who is the monster. Feels timely in how our fears can cause such distance and violence between people.
br1na's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
inspiring
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
jodiesbookishposts's review
3.0
I picked this up on a whim completely for the cover, and then put it for a year because it felt like an October read.
It took a while to get into this story which effected the rating the most. It was odd, but not surreal enough to have been captivating. Which is a shame because it really came together in the final third.
This felt like a vibe for Miss Peregrines or Wayward Children’s fans. But I preferred the writing style of WC.
It took a while to get into this story which effected the rating the most. It was odd, but not surreal enough to have been captivating. Which is a shame because it really came together in the final third.
This felt like a vibe for Miss Peregrines or Wayward Children’s fans. But I preferred the writing style of WC.
adamskiboy528491's review against another edition
4.0
Sometimes the monsters take us. Sometimes we become the monsters.
[b:The Monsters of Rookhaven|52778475|The Monsters of Rookhaven (The Monsters of Rookhaven, #1)|Pádraig Kenny|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1585566294l/52778475._SY75_.jpg|78861316] by [a:Pádraig Kenny|17179521|Pádraig Kenny|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1559332791p2/17179521.jpg] was not the horror story I was expecting! I got a real sense of these characters through Kenny's writing and sets to work, in the subtlest of ways, weaving motifs and feelings seemingly drawn from classic and contemporary literature. The horror tropes are beautifully deconstructed, like in Shelley's Frankenstein, the 'monsters' are misunderstood, and there is more to them than meets the eye.
It has a pretty straightforward plot, which makes it all the more enjoyable. Mirabelle lives in a strange house with an even stranger family. Members of the family appear from time to time through portals. Nobody knows where they come from or what they will be, but they will forever be family. Their home and way of life are protected from the 'real' world by a glamour which shields them from being hunted by humans, except one day, the glamour wears thin, and humans enter. Things will never be the same again. They are about to find out just what kind of monsters exist…
This book also has beautifully crafted illustrations by Edward Bettison! The designs bring an extra flare of the gothic atmosphere from the different types of spooky animals, the beauty, yet creepiness of the deadly blooming flowers and even the appearance of the "Big Bad" was truly terrifying (also, if you've arachnophobic, you're probably not going to like a few pages)! While most monsters are not so monstrous when shown in the illustration, the darkness is captured, particularly by the black pages with white font and drawing.
One of the enjoyable aspects of this book is that it is a brilliantly told adventure with just enough magic to be believable and precisely the right amount of elaboration to keep a reader guessing whilst feeling like they get it. The way some characters were unable to look the villain in the eye really added to the tension, and the way he so quickly bent others to his will, and there was nothing that could immediately be done to stop this genuinely terrified me. Events escalate from here, snowballing towards a tense and dramatic climax that is shocking and touching. It could easily be compared to Miss Peregrine's Home of Peculiar Children vs The Addams Family. Please give it a read!
bookofjuliette's review against another edition
5.0
C’était si bien comme lecture !
J’ai très hâte de connaître la suite
J’ai très hâte de connaître la suite
readertasha's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
Honestly it was a decent eerie, gothic, creepy tales of monsters. Took me a while to get into the story but once stuff start to happen, it got interesting!
“Piglet is dangerous.” Is what they were screaming the whole time but yet Piglet was a damn hero & the best of them all. Precious little thing!
The friendships in this was soo wholesome & I loved that part. These kids deserves every happiness..
Also the illustrations in the book was amazing & adds more to the story. I liked how every time it was Piglets POV the page is black with white writing.
Story: 3 STARS
Illustrations: 5 STARS
I might read the second book but I’m not sure just yet…
“Piglet is dangerous.” Is what they were screaming the whole time but yet Piglet was a damn hero & the best of them all. Precious little thing!
The friendships in this was soo wholesome & I loved that part. These kids deserves every happiness..
Also the illustrations in the book was amazing & adds more to the story. I liked how every time it was Piglets POV the page is black with white writing.
Story: 3 STARS
Illustrations: 5 STARS
I might read the second book but I’m not sure just yet…