Scan barcode
haileeraye's review against another edition
emotional
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Loveable characters? Yes
4.0
thesaurus's review against another edition
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? N/A
- Strong character development? No
2.0
rosewelsh's review against another edition
4.0
Star Collector begins by introducing the reader to Flynn, a teenager with an excessive lazy streak. His favorite thing to do is lay around in the grass and have a smoke, skipping out on school and all responsibilities. His girlfriend/best friend, Zoe, dumps him, and to take his mind off of it, he goes on a nightime walk. On a hillside he runs into Niko, a amateur astronomer and classmate who loves the sky that Flynn has never noticed before. The two start to meet up and look at the stars and talk nearly every night, as they slowly develop feelings for one another.
This is a cute boys love manga that subverted a few of the usual romance manga tropes. Our main character Flynn is the kind of guy that's usually painted as the bad boy everyone wants, but in Star Collector he's reads as kind of a loser. He skips school, he has no real goals, he's a nice enough guy but it doesn't go much further than that. However Niko, the resident nerdy astronomer is newer to the school and has made loads of friends. He's not the quiet, nerdy boy who needs the bad boy and is his only form of socialization; he has a whole friend group of his own and seems to be doing fine. They don't make him dependent on the protagonist which I enjoyed.
The relationship growing between Flynn and Niko feels more organic and when they do finally kiss, it makes sense. They spend time together, they have conversations and flirty moments. They don't just fall for one another because of proximity; the author actually takes the time to show that they're learning about one another and figuring things out.
The story doesn't cover a lot of Niko's backstory, or a lot of Flynn's inner feelings about the end of his relationship with Zoe and him coming to terms with being gay, he just sorta moves on, but since this is the first volume I have a feeling that will be explored more in the future. There's enough groundwork laid here that it seems like something that will be called upon again.
This is a simple, cute love story that I managed to read in one sitting on the stationary bike at the gym. It passed the time well and I would happily continue reading the next volume. I also thought the artwork was beautifully done.
Blog / Twitter
This is a cute boys love manga that subverted a few of the usual romance manga tropes. Our main character Flynn is the kind of guy that's usually painted as the bad boy everyone wants, but in Star Collector he's reads as kind of a loser. He skips school, he has no real goals, he's a nice enough guy but it doesn't go much further than that. However Niko, the resident nerdy astronomer is newer to the school and has made loads of friends. He's not the quiet, nerdy boy who needs the bad boy and is his only form of socialization; he has a whole friend group of his own and seems to be doing fine. They don't make him dependent on the protagonist which I enjoyed.
The relationship growing between Flynn and Niko feels more organic and when they do finally kiss, it makes sense. They spend time together, they have conversations and flirty moments. They don't just fall for one another because of proximity; the author actually takes the time to show that they're learning about one another and figuring things out.
The story doesn't cover a lot of Niko's backstory, or a lot of Flynn's inner feelings about the end of his relationship with Zoe and him coming to terms with being gay, he just sorta moves on, but since this is the first volume I have a feeling that will be explored more in the future. There's enough groundwork laid here that it seems like something that will be called upon again.
This is a simple, cute love story that I managed to read in one sitting on the stationary bike at the gym. It passed the time well and I would happily continue reading the next volume. I also thought the artwork was beautifully done.
Blog / Twitter
crossinthepnw's review against another edition
4.0
Cute story, fluffy, and gorgeous artwork! The story was a little shallow in places and felt a bit jumpy in a few scenes, but overall it was a fun read. I hope we learn a little more of the backstory of our MCs in volume 2!
lnluck13's review against another edition
4.0
A guy named Fynn with no direction in his life and coming off a romantic break up with a close friend finds himself interested in a stargazer named Niko. Fynn can’t help but want to know more.
It was good! Not the best thing I have ever read, but I think that may be because the whole story is so short (only 2 volumes). I wish the author duo would have had more time to flesh it out!
3.5-4*
Warnings for homophobia fears, smoking, sexual content (non-graphic)
It was good! Not the best thing I have ever read, but I think that may be because the whole story is so short (only 2 volumes). I wish the author duo would have had more time to flesh it out!
3.5-4*
Warnings for homophobia fears, smoking, sexual content (non-graphic)
dreamsinabook_irene's review against another edition
4.0
Uno shonen-ai davvero carino e dolce. A fine volume vediamo che alcune questioni sono ancora lasciate in sospeso, comunque sono d’accordo con chi dice che possa essere letto anche come autoconclusivo: sicuramente non ti lascia appeso e la storia tra i protagonisti ha una sorta di chiusura in questo volume. Bhe Comuqnue io voglio saperne di più quindi spero che il prossimo esca presto!
Ho apprezzato tantissimo anche i disegni e sia l’immagine sulla copertina che quella sulla sovracopertina sono fantastiche!
Per chi fosse interessato faccio presente che non ci sono scene esplicite all’interno del volume.
Ho apprezzato tantissimo anche i disegni e sia l’immagine sulla copertina che quella sulla sovracopertina sono fantastiche!
Per chi fosse interessato faccio presente che non ci sono scene esplicite all’interno del volume.
jaywalks's review against another edition
emotional
funny
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
3.5
jessicawhitlooo's review against another edition
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0