Reviews

The Pilgrim's Progress - From This World to That Which Is to Come by John Bunyan

nwhyte's review against another edition

http://nhw.livejournal.com/201820.html[return][return]Huckleberry Finn says of this book that "The statements was interesting, but tough", which I think is fair. Several things struck me - the unattractiveness of the main character, Christian, who wilfully abandons his family, and having lost his first travelling companion Faithful by gruesome means then becomes a know-all to his new friend Hopeful; the fact that the metaphors and allegory are about as subtle as a brick (actually, a brick is more subtle - perhaps "as subtle as a Vogon Constructor Fleet" is the simile I am looking for); the fact that when you think you're finished the book it then turns out that his wife Christiana and four sons are going to do the same journey; the repeated use of prisons (as Anne said, write about what you know) and capital punishment; and the fact that the main characters are happy to drink wine without threat of eternal damnation, something that many of the book's greatest fans today would probably disagree with.[return][return]I don't think many people actually do finish the book. Perhaps its most best known image is the Slough of Despond, which is actually described in less than a page in its first appearance (page 31 in my edition). Vanity Fair, while a great name for a town, seems to change out of all recognition between Christian's visit and Christiana's. And their children get married off with rather indecent haste.

numbat's review against another edition

2.0

Interesting to see the origins of phrases such as vanity fair and strait and narrow.