isabellajfisher's review against another edition

DID NOT FINISH: 8%

libby time ran out :( (for a four hour book LOL) 
informative reflective medium-paced

Fans of [b:Life on a Young Planet: The First Three Billion Years of Evolution on Earth|173217|Life on a Young Planet The First Three Billion Years of Evolution on Earth|Andrew H. Knoll|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1416177485l/173217._SY75_.jpg|167300], and I count myself one, will be disappointed. [a:Andrew H. Knoll|101034|Andrew H. Knoll|https://s.gr-assets.com/assets/nophoto/user/u_50x66-632230dc9882b4352d753eedf9396530.png] earlier work was written for scientists, whereas this is pitched to the conscious lay person.
informative fast-paced
informative inspiring fast-paced
informative medium-paced

A quick read that covered a lot of ground. I found it pretty understandable as someone from a science background but who doesn't know much of the topics covered, so there was a lot of new information. The audiobook reading worked well enough, although I suspect it might have stayed more organised in my mind with some of the diagrams and pictures included in the physical version. There was a good mix of space physics, geology, paleoclimatology, evolutionary biology and anthropogenic climate change. It was all structured in quite an easy to follow chronology, and Knoll was quite good at explaining the different ideas and concepts (as you'd expect from his background). I personally appreciated how along with the established knowledge of Earth's history, he would also say where the science isn't yet decided and what potential hypotheses there are. This was just what I was looking for as a quick primer on geological history - a good book to whet my appetite on a range of topics but I'll need to read other works to get deeper into what was introduced here.
informative
informative reflective medium-paced

Great overview and well written. I enjoyed reading it even though I am familiar with most of the topics discussed. I felt it would be a little too technical for a general audience, but pick it up if it’s a topic in which you have interest

This was a really good and comprehensive overview of Earth's history, I enjoyed it and learned a lot. Knoll takes an interdisciplinary approach to explaining the emergence and development of the planet through its various eras and periods.

I did have a few issues. Because its meant to be concise, some things get glossed over and I found some aspects here and there to be disjointed. I also wish that it centered a little bit more on the human/anthropological focus. Like instead of one chapter in the end that focused on humans, maybe have two or three - we kinda went from talking about early hominids to climate change pretty quickly with not enough focus on the in between.

I should say though that this was an audiobook listen for me, and while the narration was super well done, listening to a very sciency book with my attention deficit issues and general science illiteracy was not the best idea, so I'd say that that's something to consider before going into it.

Overall great read, or listen I guess.